bill/whetstone_RSA
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
c4569de9ca0cbae5527ed1d1a0e30309e64cee95
whetstone_RSA/semantic/prereq_op_dataset_1000/rejected.ndjson
Bill Holcombe c4569de9ca Sprint 003 findings + Sprint 004 pipeline decision audit plan 
- split_prereq_op_dataset.py: extract accepted/rejected/schema-drift rows per gate
- gen_prereq_op_rsa_data.py: convert accepted rows to Fabricate TSV format
- 1000-run extracted dataset: 1297 accepted prereq_op rows, 24 schema-drift
- Key finding: needs_validate_intake always True; effective gate is binary
  (needs_resolve_dependencies 77%, needs_architect_review 20%)
- Key finding: run corpus text is template-driven (17 unique inputs) — not
  suitable for text-based training; RSA exists before ideal input is available
- ROADMAP: gate lifecycle framing — goal is choice of backend, not forced
  determinism; RSA operates on imperfect/mixed/incomplete input by design
- training_data_strategy.md: taskitem-as-self-contained-work-unit constraint
- SPRINT-003: updated with 1000-run results, text audit findings, design constraints
- SPRINT-004: pipeline decision audit — manual walkthrough of every decision
  from project description to generated artifact; execute next session

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-04-12 21:43:17 -06:00

25 lines
131 KiB
Plaintext
Raw Blame History

{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 85, "conflict_signals": {"ambiguousRequirementCount": 0, "conflictCount": 0, "hasConflicts": false}, "dependency_task_ids": [], "milestone_id": "milestone-1", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan", "requirementId": "constraint-1", "sourceLine": 4}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "keep changes deterministic and test backed", "requirementId": "constraint-2", "sourceLine": 5}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing editor src modules and mcp toolchain", "requirementId": "dependency-1", "sourceLine": 8}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "whetstone mcp stable binary and workspace config", "requirementId": "dependency-2", "sourceLine": 9}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "datasets project benchmarks challenging fullstack multifile 2026 02 26 jsonl", "requirementId": "dependency-3", "sourceLine": 10}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "all sprint step tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-1", "sourceLine": 13}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "no regression in existing mcp tool behavior", "requirementId": "acceptance-2", "sourceLine": 14}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit", "requirementId": "acceptance-3", "sourceLine": 15}], "parsed_spec": {"acceptanceCriteria": [{"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 13, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "All sprint step tests pass"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 14, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "No regression in existing MCP tool behavior"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 15, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "Generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit"}], "constraints": [{"anchor": "constraints", "line": 4, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "line": 5, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Keep changes deterministic and test-backed"}], "dependencies": [{"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 8, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "Existing editor/src modules and MCP toolchain"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 9, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "whetstone_mcp stable binary and workspace config"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 10, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "datasets/project_benchmarks/challenging_fullstack_multifile_2026-02-26.jsonl"}], "goals": [], "sections": [{"anchor": "goals", "headingLine": 1, "title": "Goals"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "headingLine": 3, "title": "Constraints"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "headingLine": 7, "title": "Dependencies"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "headingLine": 12, "title": "Acceptance Criteria"}, {"anchor": "semantic-planning-packet-auto-extracted", "headingLine": 19, "title": "Semantic Planning Packet (Auto-Extracted)"}]}, "reasons": ["compatibility", "concurrency", "contract", "high_confidence_clear_path", "migration", "performance", "raw_structural_projection", "replay", "risk", "rollout", "security", "semantic", "transaction"], "task_id": "task-1", "title": "Intake Foundation Primary"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": true, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["architect-review", "validate-intake", "whetstone_generate_taskitems", "whetstone_queue_ready", "whetstone_validate_taskitem"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:whetstone_generate_taskitems,whetstone_queue_ready,whetstone_validate_taskitem"], "run_id": "01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-1"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 81, "conflict_signals": {"ambiguousRequirementCount": 0, "conflictCount": 0, "hasConflicts": false}, "dependency_task_ids": ["task-1"], "milestone_id": "milestone-2", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan", "requirementId": "constraint-1", "sourceLine": 4}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "keep changes deterministic and test backed", "requirementId": "constraint-2", "sourceLine": 5}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing editor src modules and mcp toolchain", "requirementId": "dependency-1", "sourceLine": 8}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "whetstone mcp stable binary and workspace config", "requirementId": "dependency-2", "sourceLine": 9}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "datasets project benchmarks challenging fullstack multifile 2026 02 26 jsonl", "requirementId": "dependency-3", "sourceLine": 10}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "all sprint step tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-1", "sourceLine": 13}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "no regression in existing mcp tool behavior", "requirementId": "acceptance-2", "sourceLine": 14}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit", "requirementId": "acceptance-3", "sourceLine": 15}], "parsed_spec": {"acceptanceCriteria": [{"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 13, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "All sprint step tests pass"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 14, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "No regression in existing MCP tool behavior"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 15, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "Generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit"}], "constraints": [{"anchor": "constraints", "line": 4, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "line": 5, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Keep changes deterministic and test-backed"}], "dependencies": [{"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 8, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "Existing editor/src modules and MCP toolchain"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 9, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "whetstone_mcp stable binary and workspace config"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 10, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "datasets/project_benchmarks/challenging_fullstack_multifile_2026-02-26.jsonl"}], "goals": [], "sections": [{"anchor": "goals", "headingLine": 1, "title": "Goals"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "headingLine": 3, "title": "Constraints"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "headingLine": 7, "title": "Dependencies"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "headingLine": 12, "title": "Acceptance Criteria"}, {"anchor": "semantic-planning-packet-auto-extracted", "headingLine": 19, "title": "Semantic Planning Packet (Auto-Extracted)"}]}, "reasons": ["compatibility", "concurrency", "contract", "depends_on_prior_tasks", "migration", "performance", "raw_structural_projection", "replay", "risk", "rollout", "security", "semantic", "transaction"], "task_id": "task-2", "title": "Execution Readiness Primary"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": false, "needs_resolve_dependencies": true, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["resolve-dependencies", "validate-intake", "whetstone_generate_taskitems", "whetstone_queue_ready", "whetstone_validate_taskitem"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:whetstone_generate_taskitems,whetstone_queue_ready,whetstone_validate_taskitem"], "run_id": "01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-2"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 85, "conflict_signals": {"ambiguousRequirementCount": 0, "conflictCount": 0, "hasConflicts": false}, "dependency_task_ids": [], "milestone_id": "milestone-1", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan", "requirementId": "constraint-1", "sourceLine": 4}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "keep changes deterministic and test backed", "requirementId": "constraint-2", "sourceLine": 5}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing editor src modules and mcp toolchain", "requirementId": "dependency-1", "sourceLine": 8}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "whetstone mcp stable binary and workspace config", "requirementId": "dependency-2", "sourceLine": 9}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "datasets project benchmarks challenging fullstack multifile 2026 02 26 jsonl", "requirementId": "dependency-3", "sourceLine": 10}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "all sprint step tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-1", "sourceLine": 13}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "no regression in existing mcp tool behavior", "requirementId": "acceptance-2", "sourceLine": 14}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit", "requirementId": "acceptance-3", "sourceLine": 15}], "parsed_spec": {"acceptanceCriteria": [{"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 13, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "All sprint step tests pass"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 14, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "No regression in existing MCP tool behavior"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 15, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "Generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit"}], "constraints": [{"anchor": "constraints", "line": 4, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "line": 5, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Keep changes deterministic and test-backed"}], "dependencies": [{"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 8, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "Existing editor/src modules and MCP toolchain"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 9, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "whetstone_mcp stable binary and workspace config"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 10, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "datasets/project_benchmarks/challenging_fullstack_multifile_2026-02-26.jsonl"}], "goals": [], "sections": [{"anchor": "goals", "headingLine": 1, "title": "Goals"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "headingLine": 3, "title": "Constraints"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "headingLine": 7, "title": "Dependencies"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "headingLine": 12, "title": "Acceptance Criteria"}, {"anchor": "semantic-planning-packet-auto-extracted", "headingLine": 19, "title": "Semantic Planning Packet (Auto-Extracted)"}]}, "reasons": ["compatibility", "concurrency", "contract", "high_confidence_clear_path", "migration", "performance", "raw_structural_projection", "replay", "risk", "rollout", "security", "semantic", "transaction"], "task_id": "task-1-p3", "title": "Intake Foundation Primary [whetstone_generate_taskitems]"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": true, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["architect-review", "validate-intake", "whetstone_generate_taskitems", "whetstone_queue_ready", "whetstone_validate_taskitem"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:whetstone_generate_taskitems,whetstone_queue_ready,whetstone_validate_taskitem"], "run_id": "01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-1-p3"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 81, "conflict_signals": {"ambiguousRequirementCount": 0, "conflictCount": 0, "hasConflicts": false}, "dependency_task_ids": ["task-1"], "milestone_id": "milestone-2", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan", "requirementId": "constraint-1", "sourceLine": 4}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "keep changes deterministic and test backed", "requirementId": "constraint-2", "sourceLine": 5}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing editor src modules and mcp toolchain", "requirementId": "dependency-1", "sourceLine": 8}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "whetstone mcp stable binary and workspace config", "requirementId": "dependency-2", "sourceLine": 9}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "datasets project benchmarks challenging fullstack multifile 2026 02 26 jsonl", "requirementId": "dependency-3", "sourceLine": 10}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "all sprint step tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-1", "sourceLine": 13}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "no regression in existing mcp tool behavior", "requirementId": "acceptance-2", "sourceLine": 14}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit", "requirementId": "acceptance-3", "sourceLine": 15}], "parsed_spec": {"acceptanceCriteria": [{"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 13, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "All sprint step tests pass"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 14, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "No regression in existing MCP tool behavior"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 15, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "Generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit"}], "constraints": [{"anchor": "constraints", "line": 4, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "line": 5, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Keep changes deterministic and test-backed"}], "dependencies": [{"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 8, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "Existing editor/src modules and MCP toolchain"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 9, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "whetstone_mcp stable binary and workspace config"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 10, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "datasets/project_benchmarks/challenging_fullstack_multifile_2026-02-26.jsonl"}], "goals": [], "sections": [{"anchor": "goals", "headingLine": 1, "title": "Goals"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "headingLine": 3, "title": "Constraints"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "headingLine": 7, "title": "Dependencies"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "headingLine": 12, "title": "Acceptance Criteria"}, {"anchor": "semantic-planning-packet-auto-extracted", "headingLine": 19, "title": "Semantic Planning Packet (Auto-Extracted)"}]}, "reasons": ["compatibility", "concurrency", "contract", "depends_on_prior_tasks", "migration", "performance", "raw_structural_projection", "replay", "risk", "rollout", "security", "semantic", "transaction"], "task_id": "task-2-p4", "title": "Execution Readiness Primary [whetstone_queue_ready]"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": false, "needs_resolve_dependencies": true, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["resolve-dependencies", "validate-intake", "whetstone_generate_taskitems", "whetstone_queue_ready", "whetstone_validate_taskitem"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:whetstone_generate_taskitems,whetstone_queue_ready,whetstone_validate_taskitem"], "run_id": "01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-2-p4"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 85, "conflict_signals": {"ambiguousRequirementCount": 0, "conflictCount": 0, "hasConflicts": false}, "dependency_task_ids": [], "milestone_id": "milestone-1", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan", "requirementId": "constraint-1", "sourceLine": 4}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "keep changes deterministic and test backed", "requirementId": "constraint-2", "sourceLine": 5}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing editor src modules and mcp toolchain", "requirementId": "dependency-1", "sourceLine": 8}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "whetstone mcp stable binary and workspace config", "requirementId": "dependency-2", "sourceLine": 9}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "datasets project benchmarks challenging fullstack multifile 2026 02 26 jsonl", "requirementId": "dependency-3", "sourceLine": 10}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "all sprint step tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-1", "sourceLine": 13}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "no regression in existing mcp tool behavior", "requirementId": "acceptance-2", "sourceLine": 14}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit", "requirementId": "acceptance-3", "sourceLine": 15}], "parsed_spec": {"acceptanceCriteria": [{"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 13, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "All sprint step tests pass"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 14, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "No regression in existing MCP tool behavior"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 15, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "Generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit"}], "constraints": [{"anchor": "constraints", "line": 4, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "line": 5, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Keep changes deterministic and test-backed"}], "dependencies": [{"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 8, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "Existing editor/src modules and MCP toolchain"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 9, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "whetstone_mcp stable binary and workspace config"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 10, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "datasets/project_benchmarks/challenging_fullstack_multifile_2026-02-26.jsonl"}], "goals": [], "sections": [{"anchor": "goals", "headingLine": 1, "title": "Goals"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "headingLine": 3, "title": "Constraints"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "headingLine": 7, "title": "Dependencies"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "headingLine": 12, "title": "Acceptance Criteria"}, {"anchor": "semantic-planning-packet-auto-extracted", "headingLine": 19, "title": "Semantic Planning Packet (Auto-Extracted)"}]}, "reasons": ["compatibility", "concurrency", "contract", "high_confidence_clear_path", "migration", "performance", "raw_structural_projection", "replay", "risk", "rollout", "security", "semantic", "transaction"], "task_id": "task-1-p5", "title": "Intake Foundation Primary [whetstone_validate_taskitem]"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": true, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["architect-review", "validate-intake", "whetstone_generate_taskitems", "whetstone_queue_ready", "whetstone_validate_taskitem"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:whetstone_generate_taskitems,whetstone_queue_ready,whetstone_validate_taskitem"], "run_id": "01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-1-p5"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 81, "conflict_signals": {"ambiguousRequirementCount": 0, "conflictCount": 0, "hasConflicts": false}, "dependency_task_ids": ["task-1"], "milestone_id": "milestone-2", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan", "requirementId": "constraint-1", "sourceLine": 4}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "keep changes deterministic and test backed", "requirementId": "constraint-2", "sourceLine": 5}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing editor src modules and mcp toolchain", "requirementId": "dependency-1", "sourceLine": 8}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "whetstone mcp stable binary and workspace config", "requirementId": "dependency-2", "sourceLine": 9}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "datasets project benchmarks challenging fullstack multifile 2026 02 26 jsonl", "requirementId": "dependency-3", "sourceLine": 10}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "all sprint step tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-1", "sourceLine": 13}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "no regression in existing mcp tool behavior", "requirementId": "acceptance-2", "sourceLine": 14}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit", "requirementId": "acceptance-3", "sourceLine": 15}], "parsed_spec": {"acceptanceCriteria": [{"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 13, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "All sprint step tests pass"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 14, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "No regression in existing MCP tool behavior"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 15, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "Generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit"}], "constraints": [{"anchor": "constraints", "line": 4, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "line": 5, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Keep changes deterministic and test-backed"}], "dependencies": [{"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 8, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "Existing editor/src modules and MCP toolchain"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 9, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "whetstone_mcp stable binary and workspace config"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 10, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "datasets/project_benchmarks/challenging_fullstack_multifile_2026-02-26.jsonl"}], "goals": [], "sections": [{"anchor": "goals", "headingLine": 1, "title": "Goals"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "headingLine": 3, "title": "Constraints"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "headingLine": 7, "title": "Dependencies"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "headingLine": 12, "title": "Acceptance Criteria"}, {"anchor": "semantic-planning-packet-auto-extracted", "headingLine": 19, "title": "Semantic Planning Packet (Auto-Extracted)"}]}, "reasons": ["compatibility", "concurrency", "contract", "depends_on_prior_tasks", "migration", "performance", "raw_structural_projection", "replay", "risk", "rollout", "security", "semantic", "transaction"], "task_id": "task-2-p6", "title": "Execution Readiness Primary [whetstone_generate_taskitems]"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": false, "needs_resolve_dependencies": true, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["resolve-dependencies", "validate-intake", "whetstone_generate_taskitems", "whetstone_queue_ready", "whetstone_validate_taskitem"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:whetstone_generate_taskitems,whetstone_queue_ready,whetstone_validate_taskitem"], "run_id": "01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170014/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-2-p6"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 85, "conflict_signals": {"ambiguousRequirementCount": 0, "conflictCount": 0, "hasConflicts": false}, "dependency_task_ids": [], "milestone_id": "milestone-1", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan", "requirementId": "constraint-1", "sourceLine": 4}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "keep changes deterministic and test backed", "requirementId": "constraint-2", "sourceLine": 5}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing editor src modules and mcp toolchain", "requirementId": "dependency-1", "sourceLine": 8}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "whetstone mcp stable binary and workspace config", "requirementId": "dependency-2", "sourceLine": 9}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "datasets project benchmarks challenging fullstack multifile 2026 02 26 jsonl", "requirementId": "dependency-3", "sourceLine": 10}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "all sprint step tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-1", "sourceLine": 13}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "no regression in existing mcp tool behavior", "requirementId": "acceptance-2", "sourceLine": 14}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit", "requirementId": "acceptance-3", "sourceLine": 15}], "parsed_spec": {"acceptanceCriteria": [{"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 13, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "All sprint step tests pass"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 14, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "No regression in existing MCP tool behavior"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 15, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "Generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit"}], "constraints": [{"anchor": "constraints", "line": 4, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "line": 5, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Keep changes deterministic and test-backed"}], "dependencies": [{"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 8, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "Existing editor/src modules and MCP toolchain"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 9, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "whetstone_mcp stable binary and workspace config"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 10, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "datasets/project_benchmarks/challenging_fullstack_multifile_2026-02-26.jsonl"}], "goals": [], "sections": [{"anchor": "goals", "headingLine": 1, "title": "Goals"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "headingLine": 3, "title": "Constraints"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "headingLine": 7, "title": "Dependencies"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "headingLine": 12, "title": "Acceptance Criteria"}, {"anchor": "semantic-planning-packet-auto-extracted", "headingLine": 19, "title": "Semantic Planning Packet (Auto-Extracted)"}]}, "reasons": ["compatibility", "concurrency", "contract", "high_confidence_clear_path", "migration", "performance", "raw_structural_projection", "replay", "risk", "rollout", "security", "semantic", "transaction"], "task_id": "task-1", "title": "Intake Foundation Primary"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": true, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["architect-review", "validate-intake", "whetstone_generate_taskitems", "whetstone_queue_ready", "whetstone_validate_taskitem"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:whetstone_generate_taskitems,whetstone_queue_ready,whetstone_validate_taskitem"], "run_id": "01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-1"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 81, "conflict_signals": {"ambiguousRequirementCount": 0, "conflictCount": 0, "hasConflicts": false}, "dependency_task_ids": ["task-1"], "milestone_id": "milestone-2", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan", "requirementId": "constraint-1", "sourceLine": 4}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "keep changes deterministic and test backed", "requirementId": "constraint-2", "sourceLine": 5}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing editor src modules and mcp toolchain", "requirementId": "dependency-1", "sourceLine": 8}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "whetstone mcp stable binary and workspace config", "requirementId": "dependency-2", "sourceLine": 9}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "datasets project benchmarks challenging fullstack multifile 2026 02 26 jsonl", "requirementId": "dependency-3", "sourceLine": 10}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "all sprint step tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-1", "sourceLine": 13}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "no regression in existing mcp tool behavior", "requirementId": "acceptance-2", "sourceLine": 14}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit", "requirementId": "acceptance-3", "sourceLine": 15}], "parsed_spec": {"acceptanceCriteria": [{"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 13, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "All sprint step tests pass"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 14, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "No regression in existing MCP tool behavior"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 15, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "Generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit"}], "constraints": [{"anchor": "constraints", "line": 4, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "line": 5, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Keep changes deterministic and test-backed"}], "dependencies": [{"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 8, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "Existing editor/src modules and MCP toolchain"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 9, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "whetstone_mcp stable binary and workspace config"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 10, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "datasets/project_benchmarks/challenging_fullstack_multifile_2026-02-26.jsonl"}], "goals": [], "sections": [{"anchor": "goals", "headingLine": 1, "title": "Goals"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "headingLine": 3, "title": "Constraints"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "headingLine": 7, "title": "Dependencies"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "headingLine": 12, "title": "Acceptance Criteria"}, {"anchor": "semantic-planning-packet-auto-extracted", "headingLine": 19, "title": "Semantic Planning Packet (Auto-Extracted)"}]}, "reasons": ["compatibility", "concurrency", "contract", "depends_on_prior_tasks", "migration", "performance", "raw_structural_projection", "replay", "risk", "rollout", "security", "semantic", "transaction"], "task_id": "task-2", "title": "Execution Readiness Primary"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": false, "needs_resolve_dependencies": true, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["resolve-dependencies", "validate-intake", "whetstone_generate_taskitems", "whetstone_queue_ready", "whetstone_validate_taskitem"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:whetstone_generate_taskitems,whetstone_queue_ready,whetstone_validate_taskitem"], "run_id": "01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-2"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 85, "conflict_signals": {"ambiguousRequirementCount": 0, "conflictCount": 0, "hasConflicts": false}, "dependency_task_ids": [], "milestone_id": "milestone-1", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan", "requirementId": "constraint-1", "sourceLine": 4}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "keep changes deterministic and test backed", "requirementId": "constraint-2", "sourceLine": 5}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing editor src modules and mcp toolchain", "requirementId": "dependency-1", "sourceLine": 8}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "whetstone mcp stable binary and workspace config", "requirementId": "dependency-2", "sourceLine": 9}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "datasets project benchmarks challenging fullstack multifile 2026 02 26 jsonl", "requirementId": "dependency-3", "sourceLine": 10}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "all sprint step tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-1", "sourceLine": 13}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "no regression in existing mcp tool behavior", "requirementId": "acceptance-2", "sourceLine": 14}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit", "requirementId": "acceptance-3", "sourceLine": 15}], "parsed_spec": {"acceptanceCriteria": [{"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 13, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "All sprint step tests pass"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 14, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "No regression in existing MCP tool behavior"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 15, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "Generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit"}], "constraints": [{"anchor": "constraints", "line": 4, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "line": 5, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Keep changes deterministic and test-backed"}], "dependencies": [{"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 8, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "Existing editor/src modules and MCP toolchain"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 9, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "whetstone_mcp stable binary and workspace config"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 10, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "datasets/project_benchmarks/challenging_fullstack_multifile_2026-02-26.jsonl"}], "goals": [], "sections": [{"anchor": "goals", "headingLine": 1, "title": "Goals"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "headingLine": 3, "title": "Constraints"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "headingLine": 7, "title": "Dependencies"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "headingLine": 12, "title": "Acceptance Criteria"}, {"anchor": "semantic-planning-packet-auto-extracted", "headingLine": 19, "title": "Semantic Planning Packet (Auto-Extracted)"}]}, "reasons": ["compatibility", "concurrency", "contract", "high_confidence_clear_path", "migration", "performance", "raw_structural_projection", "replay", "risk", "rollout", "security", "semantic", "transaction"], "task_id": "task-1-p3", "title": "Intake Foundation Primary [whetstone_generate_taskitems]"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": true, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["architect-review", "validate-intake", "whetstone_generate_taskitems", "whetstone_queue_ready", "whetstone_validate_taskitem"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:whetstone_generate_taskitems,whetstone_queue_ready,whetstone_validate_taskitem"], "run_id": "01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-1-p3"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 81, "conflict_signals": {"ambiguousRequirementCount": 0, "conflictCount": 0, "hasConflicts": false}, "dependency_task_ids": ["task-1"], "milestone_id": "milestone-2", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan", "requirementId": "constraint-1", "sourceLine": 4}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "keep changes deterministic and test backed", "requirementId": "constraint-2", "sourceLine": 5}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing editor src modules and mcp toolchain", "requirementId": "dependency-1", "sourceLine": 8}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "whetstone mcp stable binary and workspace config", "requirementId": "dependency-2", "sourceLine": 9}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "datasets project benchmarks challenging fullstack multifile 2026 02 26 jsonl", "requirementId": "dependency-3", "sourceLine": 10}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "all sprint step tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-1", "sourceLine": 13}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "no regression in existing mcp tool behavior", "requirementId": "acceptance-2", "sourceLine": 14}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit", "requirementId": "acceptance-3", "sourceLine": 15}], "parsed_spec": {"acceptanceCriteria": [{"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 13, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "All sprint step tests pass"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 14, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "No regression in existing MCP tool behavior"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 15, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "Generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit"}], "constraints": [{"anchor": "constraints", "line": 4, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "line": 5, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Keep changes deterministic and test-backed"}], "dependencies": [{"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 8, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "Existing editor/src modules and MCP toolchain"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 9, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "whetstone_mcp stable binary and workspace config"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 10, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "datasets/project_benchmarks/challenging_fullstack_multifile_2026-02-26.jsonl"}], "goals": [], "sections": [{"anchor": "goals", "headingLine": 1, "title": "Goals"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "headingLine": 3, "title": "Constraints"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "headingLine": 7, "title": "Dependencies"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "headingLine": 12, "title": "Acceptance Criteria"}, {"anchor": "semantic-planning-packet-auto-extracted", "headingLine": 19, "title": "Semantic Planning Packet (Auto-Extracted)"}]}, "reasons": ["compatibility", "concurrency", "contract", "depends_on_prior_tasks", "migration", "performance", "raw_structural_projection", "replay", "risk", "rollout", "security", "semantic", "transaction"], "task_id": "task-2-p4", "title": "Execution Readiness Primary [whetstone_queue_ready]"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": false, "needs_resolve_dependencies": true, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["resolve-dependencies", "validate-intake", "whetstone_generate_taskitems", "whetstone_queue_ready", "whetstone_validate_taskitem"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:whetstone_generate_taskitems,whetstone_queue_ready,whetstone_validate_taskitem"], "run_id": "01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-2-p4"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 85, "conflict_signals": {"ambiguousRequirementCount": 0, "conflictCount": 0, "hasConflicts": false}, "dependency_task_ids": [], "milestone_id": "milestone-1", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan", "requirementId": "constraint-1", "sourceLine": 4}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "keep changes deterministic and test backed", "requirementId": "constraint-2", "sourceLine": 5}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing editor src modules and mcp toolchain", "requirementId": "dependency-1", "sourceLine": 8}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "whetstone mcp stable binary and workspace config", "requirementId": "dependency-2", "sourceLine": 9}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "datasets project benchmarks challenging fullstack multifile 2026 02 26 jsonl", "requirementId": "dependency-3", "sourceLine": 10}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "all sprint step tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-1", "sourceLine": 13}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "no regression in existing mcp tool behavior", "requirementId": "acceptance-2", "sourceLine": 14}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit", "requirementId": "acceptance-3", "sourceLine": 15}], "parsed_spec": {"acceptanceCriteria": [{"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 13, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "All sprint step tests pass"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 14, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "No regression in existing MCP tool behavior"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 15, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "Generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit"}], "constraints": [{"anchor": "constraints", "line": 4, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "line": 5, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Keep changes deterministic and test-backed"}], "dependencies": [{"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 8, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "Existing editor/src modules and MCP toolchain"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 9, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "whetstone_mcp stable binary and workspace config"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 10, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "datasets/project_benchmarks/challenging_fullstack_multifile_2026-02-26.jsonl"}], "goals": [], "sections": [{"anchor": "goals", "headingLine": 1, "title": "Goals"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "headingLine": 3, "title": "Constraints"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "headingLine": 7, "title": "Dependencies"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "headingLine": 12, "title": "Acceptance Criteria"}, {"anchor": "semantic-planning-packet-auto-extracted", "headingLine": 19, "title": "Semantic Planning Packet (Auto-Extracted)"}]}, "reasons": ["compatibility", "concurrency", "contract", "high_confidence_clear_path", "migration", "performance", "raw_structural_projection", "replay", "risk", "rollout", "security", "semantic", "transaction"], "task_id": "task-1-p5", "title": "Intake Foundation Primary [whetstone_validate_taskitem]"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": true, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["architect-review", "validate-intake", "whetstone_generate_taskitems", "whetstone_queue_ready", "whetstone_validate_taskitem"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:whetstone_generate_taskitems,whetstone_queue_ready,whetstone_validate_taskitem"], "run_id": "01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-1-p5"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 81, "conflict_signals": {"ambiguousRequirementCount": 0, "conflictCount": 0, "hasConflicts": false}, "dependency_task_ids": ["task-1"], "milestone_id": "milestone-2", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan", "requirementId": "constraint-1", "sourceLine": 4}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "keep changes deterministic and test backed", "requirementId": "constraint-2", "sourceLine": 5}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing editor src modules and mcp toolchain", "requirementId": "dependency-1", "sourceLine": 8}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "whetstone mcp stable binary and workspace config", "requirementId": "dependency-2", "sourceLine": 9}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "datasets project benchmarks challenging fullstack multifile 2026 02 26 jsonl", "requirementId": "dependency-3", "sourceLine": 10}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "all sprint step tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-1", "sourceLine": 13}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "no regression in existing mcp tool behavior", "requirementId": "acceptance-2", "sourceLine": 14}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit", "requirementId": "acceptance-3", "sourceLine": 15}], "parsed_spec": {"acceptanceCriteria": [{"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 13, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "All sprint step tests pass"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 14, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "No regression in existing MCP tool behavior"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "line": 15, "sectionTitle": "Acceptance Criteria", "text": "Generated task queue is ready or blockers are explicit"}], "constraints": [{"anchor": "constraints", "line": 4, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Follow architecture gate requirements from sprint plan"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "line": 5, "sectionTitle": "Constraints", "text": "Keep changes deterministic and test-backed"}], "dependencies": [{"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 8, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "Existing editor/src modules and MCP toolchain"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 9, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "whetstone_mcp stable binary and workspace config"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "line": 10, "sectionTitle": "Dependencies", "text": "datasets/project_benchmarks/challenging_fullstack_multifile_2026-02-26.jsonl"}], "goals": [], "sections": [{"anchor": "goals", "headingLine": 1, "title": "Goals"}, {"anchor": "constraints", "headingLine": 3, "title": "Constraints"}, {"anchor": "dependencies", "headingLine": 7, "title": "Dependencies"}, {"anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "headingLine": 12, "title": "Acceptance Criteria"}, {"anchor": "semantic-planning-packet-auto-extracted", "headingLine": 19, "title": "Semantic Planning Packet (Auto-Extracted)"}]}, "reasons": ["compatibility", "concurrency", "contract", "depends_on_prior_tasks", "migration", "performance", "raw_structural_projection", "replay", "risk", "rollout", "security", "semantic", "transaction"], "task_id": "task-2-p6", "title": "Execution Readiness Primary [whetstone_generate_taskitems]"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": false, "needs_resolve_dependencies": true, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["resolve-dependencies", "validate-intake", "whetstone_generate_taskitems", "whetstone_queue_ready", "whetstone_validate_taskitem"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:whetstone_generate_taskitems,whetstone_queue_ready,whetstone_validate_taskitem"], "run_id": "01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/01a_fallback_intake_spec_20260226_170301/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-2-p6"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 48, "conflict_signals": [], "dependency_task_ids": [], "milestone_id": "milestone-1", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add 5 attribution columns to registry table db v12 migration derived from prior art license author node ids attribution version", "requirementId": "goal-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement get apiary tool name attribution returning authorship metadata json", "requirementId": "goal-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement post apiary tool name attribution with patch semantics for updating attribution fields", "requirementId": "goal-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement get apiary tool name download returning tool source as application x tar tarball", "requirementId": "goal-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "update ingestion agent py to parse attribution json from tool submissions write stub if not found", "requirementId": "goal-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "register whetstone as founding tool via orchestrator register whetstone py script", "requirementId": "goal-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "write 5 pytest integration tests in tests test s20 attribution py", "requirementId": "goal-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "python 3 9 compatible no x y union types no walrus operator", "requirementId": "constraint-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "db migration must use alter table idempotent guard if not exists pattern where supported", "requirementId": "constraint-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "get download must handle missing repo path with 404 not unhandled exception", "requirementId": "constraint-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "post attribution has patch semantics only update fields present in request body", "requirementId": "constraint-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "ingestion must write a stub attribution json when none found in repo path", "requirementId": "constraint-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "no hardcoded paths use registry repo path from db", "requirementId": "constraint-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s18 contributions table exists for future attribution credit flow", "requirementId": "dependency-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s19 hypergraph tables exist problem type linkage", "requirementId": "dependency-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing registry table in jobs queue db columns tool name repo path language capabilities required", "requirementId": "dependency-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing ingestion agent py mqtt handler for borg registry commit topic", "requirementId": "dependency-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "db v12 migration runs without error all 5 new columns present on registry table", "requirementId": "acceptance-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get apiary test tool attribution returns valid json with fields tool name author node ids derived from prior art license attribution version", "requirementId": "acceptance-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "post attribution updates only specified fields get reflects changes without clobbering unspecified fields", "requirementId": "acceptance-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get download returns content type application x tar with schema json inside the archive", "requirementId": "acceptance-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "unknown tool returns 404 on get attribution and get download", "requirementId": "acceptance-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "ingesting a tool with attribution json stores parsed author node ids derived from license correctly", "requirementId": "acceptance-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "5 5 pytest tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-7"}], "parsed_spec": {}, "reasons": ["conflicts_detected:4", "low_confidence"], "task_id": "task-s20-2", "title": "Architect Review \u2014 S20 Apiary Attribution"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": true, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["validate-intake", "architect-review", "manual-approval"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:manual-approval"], "run_id": "hivemind_s20_20260225_133936", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s20_20260225_133936/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s20_20260225_133936/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-s20-2"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 49, "conflict_signals": [], "dependency_task_ids": ["task-s20-3"], "milestone_id": "milestone-2", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add 5 attribution columns to registry table db v12 migration derived from prior art license author node ids attribution version", "requirementId": "goal-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement get apiary tool name attribution returning authorship metadata json", "requirementId": "goal-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement post apiary tool name attribution with patch semantics for updating attribution fields", "requirementId": "goal-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement get apiary tool name download returning tool source as application x tar tarball", "requirementId": "goal-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "update ingestion agent py to parse attribution json from tool submissions write stub if not found", "requirementId": "goal-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "register whetstone as founding tool via orchestrator register whetstone py script", "requirementId": "goal-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "write 5 pytest integration tests in tests test s20 attribution py", "requirementId": "goal-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "python 3 9 compatible no x y union types no walrus operator", "requirementId": "constraint-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "db migration must use alter table idempotent guard if not exists pattern where supported", "requirementId": "constraint-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "get download must handle missing repo path with 404 not unhandled exception", "requirementId": "constraint-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "post attribution has patch semantics only update fields present in request body", "requirementId": "constraint-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "ingestion must write a stub attribution json when none found in repo path", "requirementId": "constraint-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "no hardcoded paths use registry repo path from db", "requirementId": "constraint-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s18 contributions table exists for future attribution credit flow", "requirementId": "dependency-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s19 hypergraph tables exist problem type linkage", "requirementId": "dependency-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing registry table in jobs queue db columns tool name repo path language capabilities required", "requirementId": "dependency-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing ingestion agent py mqtt handler for borg registry commit topic", "requirementId": "dependency-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "db v12 migration runs without error all 5 new columns present on registry table", "requirementId": "acceptance-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get apiary test tool attribution returns valid json with fields tool name author node ids derived from prior art license attribution version", "requirementId": "acceptance-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "post attribution updates only specified fields get reflects changes without clobbering unspecified fields", "requirementId": "acceptance-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get download returns content type application x tar with schema json inside the archive", "requirementId": "acceptance-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "unknown tool returns 404 on get attribution and get download", "requirementId": "acceptance-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "ingesting a tool with attribution json stores parsed author node ids derived from license correctly", "requirementId": "acceptance-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "5 5 pytest tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-7"}], "parsed_spec": {}, "reasons": ["conflicts_detected:4", "depends_on_prior_tasks", "low_confidence"], "task_id": "task-s20-4", "title": "Architect Review Final \u2014 S20 Apiary Attribution"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": false, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["validate-intake", "manual-approval"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:manual-approval"], "run_id": "hivemind_s20_20260225_133936", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s20_20260225_133936/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s20_20260225_133936/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-s20-4"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 32, "conflict_signals": [], "dependency_task_ids": [], "milestone_id": "milestone-1", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "extend accounts table with display name account type bio public key columns db v13", "requirementId": "goal-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "create prior art table for founding contributions", "requirementId": "goal-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement post accounts and get accounts node id with sufficiency bracket calculation", "requirementId": "goal-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement get accounts node id contributions paginated 3 table join with contributions registry jobs", "requirementId": "goal-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement get accounts node id credits lightweight bracket summary", "requirementId": "goal-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement post prior art with idempotent ecu bonus award on first registration", "requirementId": "goal-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement get prior art with node id and verified query filters", "requirementId": "goal-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement calculate bracket as a pure function no db access", "requirementId": "goal-8"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "insert 7 governance params on migration founding contribution bonus ecu sufficiency threshold 1 sufficiency threshold 2 account weighting exponent individual account weighting exponent cooperative account weighting exponent nonprofit account weighting exponent enterprise", "requirementId": "goal-9"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "python 3 9 compatible no x y union types no walrus operator", "requirementId": "constraint-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "calculate bracket must be a pure function with no side effects and no db access", "requirementId": "constraint-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "post prior art must be idempotent same title node id combination never double credits ecu", "requirementId": "constraint-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "post accounts upsert uses insert or replace semantics on node id", "requirementId": "constraint-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "weighting exponent must vary by account type sourced from governance params", "requirementId": "constraint-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "no new tables beyond v13 additions do not alter tables from s18 s19", "requirementId": "constraint-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s18 contributions table exists for contribution history join", "requirementId": "dependency-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s21 prior art and accounts tables are prerequisites for s24 founding contributions script", "requirementId": "dependency-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing accounts table created in migrate v3 sql", "requirementId": "dependency-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing contributions table from s18", "requirementId": "dependency-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "db v13 migration runs without error prior art table exists accounts has 4 new columns", "requirementId": "acceptance-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "post accounts creates account get accounts id returns weighting exponent matching account type governance param", "requirementId": "acceptance-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get accounts id credits returns bracket normal for zero balance", "requirementId": "acceptance-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "ecu award causes bracket to transition correctly at sufficiency threshold 1 10000 and sufficiency threshold 2 50000", "requirementId": "acceptance-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get accounts id contributions returns paginated list with fields contribution id tool name job type ecu amount track created at", "requirementId": "acceptance-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "post prior art awards founding contribution bonus ecu ecu second call with same title node id is idempotent", "requirementId": "acceptance-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get prior art filters correctly by node id query param", "requirementId": "acceptance-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "8 8 pytest tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-8"}], "parsed_spec": {}, "reasons": ["conflicts_detected:6", "low_confidence"], "task_id": "task-s21-2", "title": "Architect Review \u2014 S21 Account System"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": true, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["validate-intake", "architect-review", "manual-approval"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:manual-approval"], "run_id": "hivemind_s21_20260225_133936", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s21_20260225_133936/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s21_20260225_133936/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-s21-2"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 33, "conflict_signals": [], "dependency_task_ids": ["task-s21-3"], "milestone_id": "milestone-2", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "extend accounts table with display name account type bio public key columns db v13", "requirementId": "goal-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "create prior art table for founding contributions", "requirementId": "goal-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement post accounts and get accounts node id with sufficiency bracket calculation", "requirementId": "goal-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement get accounts node id contributions paginated 3 table join with contributions registry jobs", "requirementId": "goal-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement get accounts node id credits lightweight bracket summary", "requirementId": "goal-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement post prior art with idempotent ecu bonus award on first registration", "requirementId": "goal-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement get prior art with node id and verified query filters", "requirementId": "goal-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement calculate bracket as a pure function no db access", "requirementId": "goal-8"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "insert 7 governance params on migration founding contribution bonus ecu sufficiency threshold 1 sufficiency threshold 2 account weighting exponent individual account weighting exponent cooperative account weighting exponent nonprofit account weighting exponent enterprise", "requirementId": "goal-9"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "python 3 9 compatible no x y union types no walrus operator", "requirementId": "constraint-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "calculate bracket must be a pure function with no side effects and no db access", "requirementId": "constraint-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "post prior art must be idempotent same title node id combination never double credits ecu", "requirementId": "constraint-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "post accounts upsert uses insert or replace semantics on node id", "requirementId": "constraint-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "weighting exponent must vary by account type sourced from governance params", "requirementId": "constraint-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "no new tables beyond v13 additions do not alter tables from s18 s19", "requirementId": "constraint-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s18 contributions table exists for contribution history join", "requirementId": "dependency-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s21 prior art and accounts tables are prerequisites for s24 founding contributions script", "requirementId": "dependency-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing accounts table created in migrate v3 sql", "requirementId": "dependency-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing contributions table from s18", "requirementId": "dependency-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "db v13 migration runs without error prior art table exists accounts has 4 new columns", "requirementId": "acceptance-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "post accounts creates account get accounts id returns weighting exponent matching account type governance param", "requirementId": "acceptance-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get accounts id credits returns bracket normal for zero balance", "requirementId": "acceptance-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "ecu award causes bracket to transition correctly at sufficiency threshold 1 10000 and sufficiency threshold 2 50000", "requirementId": "acceptance-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get accounts id contributions returns paginated list with fields contribution id tool name job type ecu amount track created at", "requirementId": "acceptance-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "post prior art awards founding contribution bonus ecu ecu second call with same title node id is idempotent", "requirementId": "acceptance-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get prior art filters correctly by node id query param", "requirementId": "acceptance-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "8 8 pytest tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-8"}], "parsed_spec": {}, "reasons": ["conflicts_detected:6", "depends_on_prior_tasks", "low_confidence"], "task_id": "task-s21-4", "title": "Architect Review Final \u2014 S21 Account System"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": false, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["validate-intake", "manual-approval"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:manual-approval"], "run_id": "hivemind_s21_20260225_133936", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s21_20260225_133936/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s21_20260225_133936/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-s21-4"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 1, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 62, "conflict_signals": [], "dependency_task_ids": [], "milestone_id": "milestone-1", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement localtoolcache c class in drone include local tool cache h 600 lines max", "requirementId": "goal-1"}, {"ambiguous": true, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement sync to fetch get apiary index and download matching tools as tarballs", "requirementId": "goal-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement find tool to scan cache dir subdirectories for schema json with matching job type field", "requirementId": "goal-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement execute to run run tool sh subprocess with payload validation against schema json", "requirementId": "goal-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement post observation to post results to nexus observations with solved locally true", "requirementId": "goal-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement inventory returning json of cached tools for mqtt publish", "requirementId": "goal-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "wire localtoolcache into job poller h cpp constructor takes optional localtoolcache nullptr disabled", "requirementId": "goal-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "call cache sync on startup in on job ready check cache before nexus claim", "requirementId": "goal-8"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add no local cache flag to main cpp default cache enabled dir hivemind dir tools", "requirementId": "goal-9"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "publish hivemind nodes id tool cache mqtt retained message after sync with tool count and synced at", "requirementId": "goal-10"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "c 20 cmake build zero compilation warnings", "requirementId": "constraint-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "localtoolcache header must not exceed 600 lines", "requirementId": "constraint-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "localtoolcache constructor takes optional localtoolcache nullptr disabled no crash", "requirementId": "constraint-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "payload validation checks required fields from schema json only no full json schema validation", "requirementId": "constraint-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "execute timeout sourced from governance params local tool max timeout s default 120", "requirementId": "constraint-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "ecu cost computed from duration s times profile rate no external api call", "requirementId": "constraint-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "no hardcoded paths cache dir and nexus url from config passed to constructor", "requirementId": "constraint-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s20 get apiary tool download endpoint must exist tarball download", "requirementId": "dependency-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing job poller h cpp and main cpp structure in drone", "requirementId": "dependency-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing nexus observations post endpoint", "requirementId": "dependency-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing mqtt broker connection in drone", "requirementId": "dependency-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "localtoolcache compiles with zero errors and zero warnings", "requirementId": "acceptance-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "sync called against running nexus populates cache dir with downloaded tool tarballs", "requirementId": "acceptance-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "find tool returns populated cachedtool when matching schema json present in cache dir", "requirementId": "acceptance-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "mqtt tool cache retained message appears on broker after sync", "requirementId": "acceptance-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "execute runs a test shell tool and returns toolresult with success true and duration s populated", "requirementId": "acceptance-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "job matching cached tool drone logs executing locally no nexus claim request sent observation at get observations", "requirementId": "acceptance-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "job not matching cached tool drone proceeds with normal nexus claim flow", "requirementId": "acceptance-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "3 3 shell integration tests pass cmake build exits 0", "requirementId": "acceptance-8"}], "parsed_spec": {}, "reasons": ["ambiguous_requirements:1", "conflicts_detected:1"], "task_id": "task-s22-2", "title": "Architect Review \u2014 S22 Drone Local Cache"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": true, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["validate-intake", "architect-review", "manual-approval"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:manual-approval"], "run_id": "hivemind_s22_20260225_133936", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s22_20260225_133936/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s22_20260225_133936/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-s22-2"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 1, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 63, "conflict_signals": [], "dependency_task_ids": ["task-s22-3"], "milestone_id": "milestone-2", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement localtoolcache c class in drone include local tool cache h 600 lines max", "requirementId": "goal-1"}, {"ambiguous": true, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement sync to fetch get apiary index and download matching tools as tarballs", "requirementId": "goal-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement find tool to scan cache dir subdirectories for schema json with matching job type field", "requirementId": "goal-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement execute to run run tool sh subprocess with payload validation against schema json", "requirementId": "goal-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement post observation to post results to nexus observations with solved locally true", "requirementId": "goal-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement inventory returning json of cached tools for mqtt publish", "requirementId": "goal-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "wire localtoolcache into job poller h cpp constructor takes optional localtoolcache nullptr disabled", "requirementId": "goal-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "call cache sync on startup in on job ready check cache before nexus claim", "requirementId": "goal-8"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add no local cache flag to main cpp default cache enabled dir hivemind dir tools", "requirementId": "goal-9"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "publish hivemind nodes id tool cache mqtt retained message after sync with tool count and synced at", "requirementId": "goal-10"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "c 20 cmake build zero compilation warnings", "requirementId": "constraint-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "localtoolcache header must not exceed 600 lines", "requirementId": "constraint-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "localtoolcache constructor takes optional localtoolcache nullptr disabled no crash", "requirementId": "constraint-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "payload validation checks required fields from schema json only no full json schema validation", "requirementId": "constraint-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "execute timeout sourced from governance params local tool max timeout s default 120", "requirementId": "constraint-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "ecu cost computed from duration s times profile rate no external api call", "requirementId": "constraint-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "no hardcoded paths cache dir and nexus url from config passed to constructor", "requirementId": "constraint-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s20 get apiary tool download endpoint must exist tarball download", "requirementId": "dependency-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing job poller h cpp and main cpp structure in drone", "requirementId": "dependency-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing nexus observations post endpoint", "requirementId": "dependency-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing mqtt broker connection in drone", "requirementId": "dependency-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "localtoolcache compiles with zero errors and zero warnings", "requirementId": "acceptance-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "sync called against running nexus populates cache dir with downloaded tool tarballs", "requirementId": "acceptance-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "find tool returns populated cachedtool when matching schema json present in cache dir", "requirementId": "acceptance-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "mqtt tool cache retained message appears on broker after sync", "requirementId": "acceptance-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "execute runs a test shell tool and returns toolresult with success true and duration s populated", "requirementId": "acceptance-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "job matching cached tool drone logs executing locally no nexus claim request sent observation at get observations", "requirementId": "acceptance-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "job not matching cached tool drone proceeds with normal nexus claim flow", "requirementId": "acceptance-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "3 3 shell integration tests pass cmake build exits 0", "requirementId": "acceptance-8"}], "parsed_spec": {}, "reasons": ["ambiguous_requirements:1", "conflicts_detected:1", "depends_on_prior_tasks"], "task_id": "task-s22-4", "title": "Architect Review Final \u2014 S22 Drone Local Cache"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": false, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["validate-intake", "manual-approval"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:manual-approval"], "run_id": "hivemind_s22_20260225_133936", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s22_20260225_133936/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s22_20260225_133936/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-s22-4"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 40, "conflict_signals": [], "dependency_task_ids": [], "milestone_id": "milestone-1", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add get health endpoint returning ok true ts iso without hitting the db", "requirementId": "goal-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add get status endpoint with 11 runtime fields status nexus version started at uptime s db path db schema version mqtt host active jobs count pending jobs count registered nodes count active inference last run", "requirementId": "goal-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add sigterm and sigint graceful shutdown handlers in lifespan context using signal module", "requirementId": "goal-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add shutting down module level boolean flag not per request", "requirementId": "goal-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add 503 guard on post jobs id claim when shutting down is true", "requirementId": "goal-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add log startup banner function printing version db path schema version mqtt host listen address", "requirementId": "goal-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add rotate log if needed log rotation on startup truncate to last 1000 lines if file exceeds 10mb", "requirementId": "goal-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "write deploy install nexus daemon sh idempotent launchd install script for macos borgswarm", "requirementId": "goal-8"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "python 3 9 compatible no x y union types no walrus operator", "requirementId": "constraint-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "get health must never hit the db under any circumstances pure liveness probe", "requirementId": "constraint-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "get status must return all 11 specified fields with correct types int for counts iso string for timestamps", "requirementId": "constraint-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "shutting down flag is module level not stored per request or per connection", "requirementId": "constraint-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "log rotation must execute before logger initialization not after", "requirementId": "constraint-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "install nexus daemon sh must be idempotent unload before load safe to run multiple times", "requirementId": "constraint-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "no db migration needed for this sprint", "requirementId": "constraint-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing nexus api py lifespan context asynccontextmanager pattern already in place", "requirementId": "dependency-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing governance params key last inference run at written by active inference py", "requirementId": "dependency-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "orchestrator com hivemind nexus plist already exists at correct path", "requirementId": "dependency-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get health returns ok true ts iso datetime with http 200", "requirementId": "acceptance-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get health returns ok false error db unreachable with http 503 when db file missing", "requirementId": "acceptance-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get status returns all 11 fields status nexus version started at uptime s db path db schema version mqtt host active jobs count pending jobs count registered nodes count active inference last run", "requirementId": "acceptance-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "uptime s value increases between two consecutive get status calls", "requirementId": "acceptance-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "post jobs id claim returns 503 when shutting down is true", "requirementId": "acceptance-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "post jobs id claim returns 200 normal behavior when shutting down is false", "requirementId": "acceptance-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "install nexus daemon sh is executable idempotent exits 0 when nexus becomes healthy within 10s", "requirementId": "acceptance-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "4 4 pytest tests pass all testable without launchd", "requirementId": "acceptance-8"}], "parsed_spec": {}, "reasons": ["conflicts_detected:5", "low_confidence"], "task_id": "task-s23-2", "title": "Architect Review \u2014 S23 Nexus Daemon"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": true, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["validate-intake", "architect-review", "manual-approval"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:manual-approval"], "run_id": "hivemind_s23_20260225_133936", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s23_20260225_133936/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s23_20260225_133936/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-s23-2"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 41, "conflict_signals": [], "dependency_task_ids": ["task-s23-3"], "milestone_id": "milestone-2", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add get health endpoint returning ok true ts iso without hitting the db", "requirementId": "goal-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add get status endpoint with 11 runtime fields status nexus version started at uptime s db path db schema version mqtt host active jobs count pending jobs count registered nodes count active inference last run", "requirementId": "goal-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add sigterm and sigint graceful shutdown handlers in lifespan context using signal module", "requirementId": "goal-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add shutting down module level boolean flag not per request", "requirementId": "goal-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add 503 guard on post jobs id claim when shutting down is true", "requirementId": "goal-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add log startup banner function printing version db path schema version mqtt host listen address", "requirementId": "goal-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add rotate log if needed log rotation on startup truncate to last 1000 lines if file exceeds 10mb", "requirementId": "goal-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "write deploy install nexus daemon sh idempotent launchd install script for macos borgswarm", "requirementId": "goal-8"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "python 3 9 compatible no x y union types no walrus operator", "requirementId": "constraint-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "get health must never hit the db under any circumstances pure liveness probe", "requirementId": "constraint-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "get status must return all 11 specified fields with correct types int for counts iso string for timestamps", "requirementId": "constraint-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "shutting down flag is module level not stored per request or per connection", "requirementId": "constraint-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "log rotation must execute before logger initialization not after", "requirementId": "constraint-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "install nexus daemon sh must be idempotent unload before load safe to run multiple times", "requirementId": "constraint-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "no db migration needed for this sprint", "requirementId": "constraint-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing nexus api py lifespan context asynccontextmanager pattern already in place", "requirementId": "dependency-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing governance params key last inference run at written by active inference py", "requirementId": "dependency-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "orchestrator com hivemind nexus plist already exists at correct path", "requirementId": "dependency-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get health returns ok true ts iso datetime with http 200", "requirementId": "acceptance-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get health returns ok false error db unreachable with http 503 when db file missing", "requirementId": "acceptance-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get status returns all 11 fields status nexus version started at uptime s db path db schema version mqtt host active jobs count pending jobs count registered nodes count active inference last run", "requirementId": "acceptance-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "uptime s value increases between two consecutive get status calls", "requirementId": "acceptance-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "post jobs id claim returns 503 when shutting down is true", "requirementId": "acceptance-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "post jobs id claim returns 200 normal behavior when shutting down is false", "requirementId": "acceptance-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "install nexus daemon sh is executable idempotent exits 0 when nexus becomes healthy within 10s", "requirementId": "acceptance-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "4 4 pytest tests pass all testable without launchd", "requirementId": "acceptance-8"}], "parsed_spec": {}, "reasons": ["conflicts_detected:5", "depends_on_prior_tasks", "low_confidence"], "task_id": "task-s23-4", "title": "Architect Review Final \u2014 S23 Nexus Daemon"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": false, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["validate-intake", "manual-approval"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:manual-approval"], "run_id": "hivemind_s23_20260225_133936", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s23_20260225_133936/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s23_20260225_133936/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-s23-4"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 56, "conflict_signals": [], "dependency_task_ids": [], "milestone_id": "milestone-1", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "write orchestrator register founding contributions py as a standalone idempotent script", "requirementId": "goal-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement dry run flag that prints what would be registered without modifying any state", "requirementId": "goal-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement verify only flag that checks db state and exits 0 if all conditions met", "requirementId": "goal-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "step a upsert founder account via post accounts with node id founder", "requirementId": "goal-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "step b seed 17 canonical problem types via post problems insert or ignore semantics", "requirementId": "goal-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "step c register 5 founding prior art works via post prior art idempotent by title node id", "requirementId": "goal-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "step d seed hypergraph nodes for all 17 problem types with founded by edge type", "requirementId": "goal-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "step e print summary table of founder ecu balance prior art count problem types seeded hypergraph nodes created", "requirementId": "goal-8"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add founding contribution decay rate governance param default 0 95", "requirementId": "goal-9"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "python 3 9 compatible no x y union types no walrus operator", "requirementId": "constraint-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "script must be idempotent running twice produces identical db state with no double credits", "requirementId": "constraint-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "uses only existing api endpoints post accounts post prior art post problems no direct db access", "requirementId": "constraint-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "no new api endpoints needed for this sprint", "requirementId": "constraint-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "no db migration needed uses tables created in s21", "requirementId": "constraint-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "dry run must not create update or delete any db state", "requirementId": "constraint-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s21 prior art table post accounts endpoint post prior art endpoint must exist", "requirementId": "dependency-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s19 hypergraph nodes and hypergraph edges tables must exist", "requirementId": "dependency-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing post problems endpoint", "requirementId": "dependency-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "nexus must be running at nexus url environment variable for api calls", "requirementId": "dependency-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "dry run prints registration plan with all 5 works and 17 problem types without modifying db", "requirementId": "acceptance-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "founder account with node id founder exists after first run", "requirementId": "acceptance-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "17 problem types present in problem types table after run", "requirementId": "acceptance-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "5 prior art entries present in prior art table after run second run leaves count at exactly 5", "requirementId": "acceptance-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "hypergraph has nodes for at least 10 of the 17 problem types after run", "requirementId": "acceptance-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "founder account ecu balance is at least 5 times founding contribution bonus ecu", "requirementId": "acceptance-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "verify only exits with code 0 when all 5 prior art entries and 17 problem types are present", "requirementId": "acceptance-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "5 5 pytest tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-8"}], "parsed_spec": {}, "reasons": ["conflicts_detected:3", "low_confidence"], "task_id": "task-s24-2", "title": "Architect Review \u2014 S24 Founding Contributions"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": true, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["validate-intake", "architect-review", "manual-approval"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:manual-approval"], "run_id": "hivemind_s24_20260225_133936", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s24_20260225_133936/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s24_20260225_133936/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-s24-2"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 57, "conflict_signals": [], "dependency_task_ids": ["task-s24-3"], "milestone_id": "milestone-2", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "write orchestrator register founding contributions py as a standalone idempotent script", "requirementId": "goal-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement dry run flag that prints what would be registered without modifying any state", "requirementId": "goal-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement verify only flag that checks db state and exits 0 if all conditions met", "requirementId": "goal-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "step a upsert founder account via post accounts with node id founder", "requirementId": "goal-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "step b seed 17 canonical problem types via post problems insert or ignore semantics", "requirementId": "goal-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "step c register 5 founding prior art works via post prior art idempotent by title node id", "requirementId": "goal-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "step d seed hypergraph nodes for all 17 problem types with founded by edge type", "requirementId": "goal-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "step e print summary table of founder ecu balance prior art count problem types seeded hypergraph nodes created", "requirementId": "goal-8"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add founding contribution decay rate governance param default 0 95", "requirementId": "goal-9"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "python 3 9 compatible no x y union types no walrus operator", "requirementId": "constraint-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "script must be idempotent running twice produces identical db state with no double credits", "requirementId": "constraint-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "uses only existing api endpoints post accounts post prior art post problems no direct db access", "requirementId": "constraint-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "no new api endpoints needed for this sprint", "requirementId": "constraint-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "no db migration needed uses tables created in s21", "requirementId": "constraint-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "dry run must not create update or delete any db state", "requirementId": "constraint-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s21 prior art table post accounts endpoint post prior art endpoint must exist", "requirementId": "dependency-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s19 hypergraph nodes and hypergraph edges tables must exist", "requirementId": "dependency-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "existing post problems endpoint", "requirementId": "dependency-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "nexus must be running at nexus url environment variable for api calls", "requirementId": "dependency-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "dry run prints registration plan with all 5 works and 17 problem types without modifying db", "requirementId": "acceptance-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "founder account with node id founder exists after first run", "requirementId": "acceptance-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "17 problem types present in problem types table after run", "requirementId": "acceptance-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "5 prior art entries present in prior art table after run second run leaves count at exactly 5", "requirementId": "acceptance-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "hypergraph has nodes for at least 10 of the 17 problem types after run", "requirementId": "acceptance-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "founder account ecu balance is at least 5 times founding contribution bonus ecu", "requirementId": "acceptance-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "verify only exits with code 0 when all 5 prior art entries and 17 problem types are present", "requirementId": "acceptance-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "5 5 pytest tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-8"}], "parsed_spec": {}, "reasons": ["conflicts_detected:3", "depends_on_prior_tasks", "low_confidence"], "task_id": "task-s24-4", "title": "Architect Review Final \u2014 S24 Founding Contributions"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": false, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["validate-intake", "manual-approval"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:manual-approval"], "run_id": "hivemind_s24_20260225_133936", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s24_20260225_133936/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s24_20260225_133936/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-s24-4"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 16, "conflict_signals": [], "dependency_task_ids": [], "milestone_id": "milestone-1", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "create db v14 migration with federation peers table id peer url peer id shared resources last sync at first seen at active", "requirementId": "goal-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add 4 federation governance params federation sync interval minutes 15 federation max peers 10 federation job offer timeout s 30 this swarm id generated uuid", "requirementId": "goal-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement post federation peers verifying peer reachability via get peer url health before insert", "requirementId": "goal-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement get federation peers listing all peers with sync status", "requirementId": "goal-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement delete federation peers id performing soft delete sets active 0", "requirementId": "goal-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement get federation apiary delta since iso returning tools modified after timestamp metadata only no source", "requirementId": "goal-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement post federation job offers checking local node capabilities against requirements create local job copy if accepted", "requirementId": "goal-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement get federation observations delta since iso returning aggregated observation stats never raw content", "requirementId": "goal-8"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement run federation sync async background task running in lifespan loop", "requirementId": "goal-9"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "python 3 9 compatible no x y union types no walrus operator", "requirementId": "constraint-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "get federation observations delta must never return raw observation content only aggregates", "requirementId": "constraint-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "post federation peers must verify peer reachability before inserting reject with error if unreachable", "requirementId": "constraint-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "delete federation peers sets active 0 soft delete only never hard delete from table", "requirementId": "constraint-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "this swarm id must be auto generated uuid on first run if not already in governance params", "requirementId": "constraint-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "run federation sync background loop must not block lifespan startup", "requirementId": "constraint-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "federation is opt in per resource type apiary job offers observations in shared resources json", "requirementId": "constraint-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s20 get apiary tool download and updated at column on registry for delta sync", "requirementId": "dependency-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s23 get health endpoint on nexus used by peer reachability check before registration", "requirementId": "dependency-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s24 attribution data present in registry for apiary delta content", "requirementId": "dependency-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "httpx async http client available in python environment", "requirementId": "dependency-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "db v14 migration runs without error select from federation peers returns empty table", "requirementId": "acceptance-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "post federation peers rejects unreachable peer url with connection refused error does not insert", "requirementId": "acceptance-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get federation apiary delta returns only tools where updated at is after the since parameter", "requirementId": "acceptance-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "post federation job offers returns accepted true local job id when matching node capability exists", "requirementId": "acceptance-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "post federation job offers returns accepted false reason when no matching node capability", "requirementId": "acceptance-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "two nexus instances on different ports register as peers register tool on a trigger sync tool appears on b", "requirementId": "acceptance-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "run federation sync background task starts and logs completion within sync interval", "requirementId": "acceptance-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "6 6 pytest tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-8"}], "parsed_spec": {}, "reasons": ["conflicts_detected:8", "low_confidence"], "task_id": "task-s25-2", "title": "Architect Review \u2014 S25 Federation"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": true, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["validate-intake", "architect-review", "manual-approval"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:manual-approval"], "run_id": "hivemind_s25_20260225_133936", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s25_20260225_133936/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s25_20260225_133936/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-s25-2"}
{"decision_context": {"ambiguity_count": 0, "ambiguity_signals": [], "confidence": 17, "conflict_signals": [], "dependency_task_ids": ["task-s25-3"], "milestone_id": "milestone-2", "normalized_requirements": [{"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "create db v14 migration with federation peers table id peer url peer id shared resources last sync at first seen at active", "requirementId": "goal-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "add 4 federation governance params federation sync interval minutes 15 federation max peers 10 federation job offer timeout s 30 this swarm id generated uuid", "requirementId": "goal-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement post federation peers verifying peer reachability via get peer url health before insert", "requirementId": "goal-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement get federation peers listing all peers with sync status", "requirementId": "goal-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement delete federation peers id performing soft delete sets active 0", "requirementId": "goal-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement get federation apiary delta since iso returning tools modified after timestamp metadata only no source", "requirementId": "goal-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement post federation job offers checking local node capabilities against requirements create local job copy if accepted", "requirementId": "goal-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement get federation observations delta since iso returning aggregated observation stats never raw content", "requirementId": "goal-8"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "goals", "kind": "goal", "normalizedText": "implement run federation sync async background task running in lifespan loop", "requirementId": "goal-9"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "python 3 9 compatible no x y union types no walrus operator", "requirementId": "constraint-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "get federation observations delta must never return raw observation content only aggregates", "requirementId": "constraint-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "post federation peers must verify peer reachability before inserting reject with error if unreachable", "requirementId": "constraint-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "delete federation peers sets active 0 soft delete only never hard delete from table", "requirementId": "constraint-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "this swarm id must be auto generated uuid on first run if not already in governance params", "requirementId": "constraint-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "run federation sync background loop must not block lifespan startup", "requirementId": "constraint-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "constraints", "kind": "constraint", "normalizedText": "federation is opt in per resource type apiary job offers observations in shared resources json", "requirementId": "constraint-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s20 get apiary tool download and updated at column on registry for delta sync", "requirementId": "dependency-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s23 get health endpoint on nexus used by peer reachability check before registration", "requirementId": "dependency-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "s24 attribution data present in registry for apiary delta content", "requirementId": "dependency-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "dependencies", "kind": "dependency", "normalizedText": "httpx async http client available in python environment", "requirementId": "dependency-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "db v14 migration runs without error select from federation peers returns empty table", "requirementId": "acceptance-1"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "post federation peers rejects unreachable peer url with connection refused error does not insert", "requirementId": "acceptance-2"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "get federation apiary delta returns only tools where updated at is after the since parameter", "requirementId": "acceptance-3"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "post federation job offers returns accepted true local job id when matching node capability exists", "requirementId": "acceptance-4"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "post federation job offers returns accepted false reason when no matching node capability", "requirementId": "acceptance-5"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "two nexus instances on different ports register as peers register tool on a trigger sync tool appears on b", "requirementId": "acceptance-6"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "run federation sync background task starts and logs completion within sync interval", "requirementId": "acceptance-7"}, {"ambiguous": false, "anchor": "acceptance-criteria", "kind": "acceptance", "normalizedText": "6 6 pytest tests pass", "requirementId": "acceptance-8"}], "parsed_spec": {}, "reasons": ["conflicts_detected:8", "depends_on_prior_tasks", "low_confidence"], "task_id": "task-s25-4", "title": "Architect Review Final \u2014 S25 Federation"}, "decision_label": {"needs_architect_review": false, "needs_resolve_dependencies": false, "needs_validate_intake": true, "source_values": ["validate-intake", "manual-approval"]}, "decision_provenance": "direct_bundled", "gate_id": "prereq_op_selector", "rejection_flags": ["invalid_prerequisite_values:manual-approval"], "run_id": "hivemind_s25_20260225_133936", "source_artifacts": ["/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s25_20260225_133936/01_intake.json", "/home/bill/Documents/CLionProjects/whetstone_DSL/logs/taskitem_runs/hivemind_s25_20260225_133936/02_generate_taskitems.json", "/home/bill/Documents/whetstone_RSA/semantic/rsa_gate_extraction_contracts_v0.json"], "task_id": "task-s25-4"}
Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink