whetstone_DSL/progress.md

Sprint 9 Progress — Agent-First Tooling

Phase 9a: Standalone MCP Server

Step 245: HeadlessEditorState (no ImGui dependency)

Status: PASS (20/20 tests)

Created the headless agent API surface — same method interface as EditorState but with zero GUI dependencies (no ImGui, no SDL, no WebSocket).

Files created:

• editor/src/ASTUtils.h — Pure AST utility functions extracted from EditorUtils.h (cloneModule, isAnnotationNode, countAnnotationNodes, findNodeById, findNodeAtPosition)
• editor/src/HeadlessEditorState.h — Lightweight state: HeadlessAgentState, HeadlessLibraryState, HeadlessBufferState, buffer management, orchestrator sync
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — Full RPC dispatch mirroring AgentRPCHandler.h (20+ methods: getAST, parseSource, runPipeline, applyMutation, applyBatch, projectLanguage, generateCode, workflow recording, etc.)
• editor/tests/step245_test.cpp — 20 test cases covering construction, buffer management, RPC dispatch, permission enforcement, pipeline execution

Key design decisions:

• JSON roundtrip cloning (matching EditorUtils.h) instead of manual deep copy
• Separate HeadlessAgentState (no AgentMarketplace/WebSocket dependency chain)
• All files under 600-line architecture limit

Step 246: mcp_main.cpp — Standalone MCP Server Entry Point

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Wires HeadlessEditorState + MCPBridge into a standalone whetstone_mcp binary that any MCP client (Claude Code, Cursor, etc.) can launch over stdio.

Files created:

• editor/src/mcp_main.cpp — Standalone MCP server entry point with CLI arg parsing (--workspace, --language, --verbose), signal handling, resource reader lambda routing whetstone:// URIs, and MCPBridge stdio loop
• editor/tests/step246_test.cpp — 12 test cases: initialize, notifications, tools/list (10+), resources/list (5), prompts/list (4), tools/call pipeline, tools/call get_ast, resources/read ast, resources/read diagnostics, ping, resources/read settings, CLI arg parsing

Key design decisions:

• No SDL, no ImGui, no OpenGL — headless only binary
• Fixed "mcp-session" session ID (MCP stdio is single-client)
• Default Refactor role for full MCP access
• Empty scratch buffer on startup so getAST works immediately
• All logging to stderr (stdout is the MCP transport)

Step 247: File Operation Tools for MCP

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds 5 file I/O tools to the MCP server so agents can create, read, write, diff, and list files without a GUI. All operations respect the --workspace root with path-escape security checks.

Files created:

• editor/src/FileOperations.h — Standalone file ops: resolve path, read, write, create (with templates), unified diff, workspace listing via FileTree
• editor/tests/step247_test.cpp — 12 test cases: path resolution, path escape rejection, file create/read/write via RPC, line range, diff, workspace list, glob filter, language templates, parent dir creation, permission denial

Files modified:

• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — fileRead/workspaceList/fileDiff read-only; fileWrite/fileCreate require Refactor/Generator
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — 5 new RPC handlers
• editor/src/HeadlessEditorState.h — include FileOperations.h
• editor/src/MCPServer.h — registerFileTools() with 5 MCP tool definitions
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step247_test target

Key design decisions:

• Path security: all paths resolved against workspaceRoot, escape rejected
• Simple line-by-line unified diff (no external dependency)
• Language templates for Python, C++, Rust, Go, Java, JS/TS
• FileTree.h reuse for .gitignore-aware workspace listing
• tools/list now returns 15 tools (was 10)

Step 248: Compact AST Response Format

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds token-efficient AST responses so agents waste fewer tokens on large ASTs. Compact mode returns a flat list of {id, type, name, line, children} nodes at <30% the size of full AST. Subtree extraction and AST diff (version-based) let agents query only what changed.

Files created:

• editor/src/CompactAST.h — toJsonCompact, toJsonCompactTree, toJsonSubtree, getNodeName, tokenEstimate, ASTVersionTracker (recordMutation, changedSince, buildDiff, pruneOlderThan)
• editor/tests/step248_test.cpp — 12 test cases: full backward compat, compact flat list, <30% size ratio, compact field validation, tokenEstimate, version counter, subtree extraction, invalid nodeId error, empty diff, version increment on mutation, diff after mutation, subtree vs full tokenEstimate

Files modified:

• editor/src/HeadlessEditorState.h — include CompactAST.h, add ASTVersionTracker to HeadlessBufferState
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — getAST compact param, version and tokenEstimate in responses, getASTSubtree and getASTDiff methods, version recording in applyMutation/applyBatch
• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — getASTSubtree/getASTDiff read-only
• editor/src/MCPServer.h — whetstone_get_ast compact param, new whetstone_get_ast_subtree and whetstone_get_ast_diff tools
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step248_test target

Key design decisions:

• Compact mode: flat array of abbreviated nodes (not nested tree)
• Version counter per buffer, incremented on each mutation
• ASTVersionTracker stores affected nodeIds per version for diff
• tokenEstimate = json.dump().size() / 4 (rough LLM token approx)
• tools/list returns 17 tools (was 15): +whetstone_get_ast_subtree, +whetstone_get_ast_diff

Step 249: MCP Server Integration Tests

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

End-to-end integration tests exercising the full MCP server stack through MCPBridge. Simulates a realistic agent session from handshake through tool discovery, AST queries, pipeline execution, resource reads, and file I/O.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step249_test.cpp — 8 integration test cases:
  1. MCP handshake (initialize + notifications/initialized, verify protocol version, server info, capabilities)
  2. tools/list returns all 17 tools with valid schemas (name, description, inputSchema with type field)
  3. tools/call whetstone_get_ast on active buffer returns valid AST
  4. tools/call whetstone_run_pipeline: Python → C++ code generation (5393 chars)
  5. resources/read whetstone://diagnostics returns valid JSON array
  6. prompts/list returns all 4 prompts (annotate_module, cross_language_projection, security_audit, refactor_memory)
  7. File operations cycle: create → write → read → verify on disk (full CRUD through MCP tools/call layer)
  8. Compact AST vs full AST size comparison via MCP (3% ratio — 1,469 vs 39,446 chars)

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step249_test target

Key results:

• Phase 9a complete: all 5 steps pass (64/64 tests across steps 245–249)
• Full MCP stack validated end-to-end: handshake → tools → resources → prompts → file ops
• Compact AST achieves 97% token savings through MCP layer (3% of full size)
• 17 tools, 5 resources, 4 prompts all verified with correct schemas

---

Phase 9b: Agent-Optimized Diagnostics

Step 250: Structured Diagnostic Format

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Unified diagnostic format for agent consumption. Merges tree-sitter parse errors, annotation validation diagnostics, and strategy validation violations into a single stream with error codes, severity levels, AST node references, and machine-applicable fix mutations.

Files created:

• editor/src/StructuredDiagnostics.h — Unified diagnostic format:
  • StructuredDiagnostic struct: code, severity, nodeId, line, col, message, source, fix (optional mutation object)
  • Error code scheme: E01xx (parser), E02xx (annotation), E03xx (strategy)
  • Severity enum: Error(1), Warning(2), Info(3), Hint(4)
  • Collectors: collectParseDiagnostics, collectAnnotationDiagnostics, collectStrategyDiagnostics, collectAllDiagnostics, collectPipelineDiagnostics
  • Fix builders: suggest concrete mutations (deleteNode, setProperty, insertNode)
  • Filters: filterBySeverity, filterBySource
  • JSON serialization: diagnosticToJson, diagnosticsToJson
• editor/tests/step250_test.cpp — 12 test cases: valid code (zero diags), parse error codes (E01xx), parse location/severity, annotation validation (E02xx), nodeId presence, fix suggestions, getDiagnostics RPC, severity filter, JSON field validation, MCP tool registration, pipeline diagnostics, source filter

Files modified:

• editor/src/HeadlessEditorState.h — include StructuredDiagnostics.h
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — getDiagnostics RPC method with optional severity and source filters
• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — getDiagnostics as read-only
• editor/src/MCPServer.h — whetstone_get_diagnostics tool registration
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step250_test target

Key design decisions:

• Error codes are hierarchical: E01xx=parser, E02xx=annotation, E03xx=strategy
• Fix suggestions are concrete mutation objects (same format as applyMutation)
• Severity filtering uses numeric comparison (lower = more severe)
• Source filtering allows isolating parser vs annotation vs strategy diagnostics
• tools/list now returns 18 tools (was 17): +whetstone_get_diagnostics

Step 251: Quick-Fix Actions as RPC Mutations

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Turns diagnostic fix suggestions into one-shot RPC calls. getQuickFixes returns concrete mutation objects the agent can review; applyQuickFix takes a diagnostic code + nodeId, applies the fix, and reports whether the diagnostic cleared.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step251_test.cpp — 12 test cases: fix discovery, required fields, mutation structure, nodeId filtering, apply fix, diagnostic clearing report, invalid diagCode error, missing param error, permission enforcement, MCP tool registration, missing-return heuristic, category validation

Files modified:

• editor/src/StructuredDiagnostics.h — QuickFix struct, getQuickFixesForNode, getQuickFixesAll, findQuickFix, heuristic fixes (unused variable removal, missing return statement)
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — getQuickFixes and applyQuickFix RPC methods
• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — getQuickFixes read-only, applyQuickFix requires Refactor/Generator
• editor/src/MCPServer.h — whetstone_get_quick_fixes and whetstone_apply_quick_fix tool registration
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step251_test target

Key design decisions:

• QuickFix has unique id, diagCode, nodeId, description, category, mutation
• Fix categories: remove-annotation, change-strategy, resolve-conflict, remove-use-after-free, add-deallocation, remove-unused, missing-return
• applyQuickFix delegates to existing applyMutation path for consistency
• After applying, re-runs diagnostics to report if the error cleared
• tools/list now returns 20 tools (was 18): +whetstone_get_quick_fixes, +whetstone_apply_quick_fix

Step 252: Diagnostic Delta Streaming

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Efficient delta computation so agents only see what changed since their last diagnostic query. getDiagnosticsDelta returns added/removed diagnostics based on a version number, enabling fast mutate → check loops.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step252_test.cpp — 12 test cases: version tracking, empty delta, addition detection, removal detection, response structure, version increment, DiagnosticKey comparison, tracker reset, MCP tool, structured format in delta, Linter role access

Files modified:

• editor/src/StructuredDiagnostics.h — DiagnosticKey (code, nodeId, line), DiagnosticDelta (added, removed, version), DiagnosticVersionTracker (recordSnapshot, getDelta, reset), deltaToJson
• editor/src/HeadlessEditorState.h — DiagnosticVersionTracker in HeadlessBufferState
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — getDiagnosticsDelta RPC method, getDiagnostics now records snapshots for delta tracking
• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — getDiagnosticsDelta as read-only
• editor/src/MCPServer.h — whetstone_get_diagnostics_delta tool
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step252_test target

Key design decisions:

• DiagnosticKey tuple (code, nodeId, line) uniquely identifies a diagnostic
• Version bumps on each getDiagnostics/getDiagnosticsDelta call
• Delta computed by set difference between previous and current snapshots
• Response includes addedCount/removedCount for quick checks without parsing
• tools/list now returns 21 tools (was 20): +whetstone_get_diagnostics_delta

Step 253: Diagnostic and Delta Integration Tests

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Comprehensive end-to-end tests for the full diagnostic pipeline: structured diagnostics, quick fixes, delta streaming, and filtering. Exercises the complete flow: introduce error → diagnose → fix → verify clearing.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step253_test.cpp — 8 integration test cases:
  1. Valid Python → zero diagnostics
  2. Annotation error → structured diagnostics with nodeIds and codes
  3. Quick fixes include concrete mutation objects
  4. applyQuickFix resolves diagnostic (cleared=true, remaining=0)
  5. Delta after fix shows removal (removed=1, added=0)
  6. Delta after new error shows addition (added=1, removed=0)
  7. Combined parser + annotation diagnostics in streams
  8. Severity filtering across the pipeline

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step253_test target

Key results:

• Phase 9b complete: all 4 steps pass (44/44 tests across steps 250–253)
• Full diagnostic pipeline validated: diagnose → fix → verify → delta
• 21 MCP tools, structured error codes (E01xx/E02xx/E03xx), delta streaming

---

Phase 9c: Token-Efficient Agent Protocol

Step 254: Response Budget System

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Optional budget parameter on query methods. If the response exceeds the budget, it's truncated with truncated: true and a continuation token for paginated follow-up. Arrays are shrunk via binary search; responses sorted by priority (errors first).

Files created:

• editor/src/ResponseBudget.h — applyBudget (binary search truncation of arrays), applyContinuation (resume from offset), sortDiagnosticsByPriority
• editor/tests/step254_test.cpp — 12 test cases: no-budget backward compat, compact AST truncation, totalCount/returnedCount, continuation pagination, full-mode truncated flag, diagnostics with budget, non-array truncation, large budget passthrough, invalid continuation error, priority sorting, budget=0 unlimited, multi-page coverage

Files modified:

• editor/src/HeadlessEditorState.h — include ResponseBudget.h
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — getAST and getDiagnostics gain optional budget parameter with truncation
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step254_test target

Key design decisions:

• Budget in chars (not tokens) — simple, predictable, cheap to compute
• Binary search finds max array elements that fit within budget
• Continuation token format: "field:offset:total" (opaque to agent)
• Diagnostics sorted by severity before truncation (errors first)
• budget=0 or omitted → unlimited (backward compatible)

Step 255: Symbol-Only Mode for Scope Queries

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Lean vs detailed mode for getInScopeSymbols, getCallHierarchy, and getDependencyGraph. Default (lean) mode returns minimal symbol data (name, kind, nodeId); detailed: true includes full node JSON.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step255_test.cpp — 12 test cases: lean scope (no node data), detailed scope (with node JSON), count field, size comparison, lean call hierarchy (names + IDs), detailed call hierarchy (node arrays), lean deps (ID list + count), detailed deps (full nodes), both modes valid output, field validation (name/kind/nodeId), node concept field, functionName

Files modified:

• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — getInScopeSymbols, getCallHierarchy, getDependencyGraph gain detailed parameter; lean mode returns symbols-only, detailed mode includes full node JSON via toJson()
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step255_test target

Key design decisions:

• Default mode is "symbols" (lean) — agents get names/IDs without node JSON
• detailed: true adds full node serialization for each symbol/caller/callee/dep
• Lean scope responses ~7% the size of detailed (302 vs 4329 chars)
• getDependencyGraph lean mode converts vector IDs to JSON array
• Uses getNodeName() from CompactAST.h for cross-type name extraction

Step 256: Batch Query Endpoint

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

batchQuery method accepts an array of sub-queries, executes each independently, and returns all results in a single round-trip. Errors in one sub-query don't affect others.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step256_test.cpp — 12 test cases: 3-query batch, method fields, result fields, error isolation, AST+diagnostics+scope batch, empty batch, missing params error, budget passthrough, single-envelope multi-result, permission-denied isolation, MCP registration, lean+detailed mixed batch

Files modified:

• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — batchQuery RPC method: iterates sub-queries, calls handleHeadlessAgentRequest recursively, collects results/errors independently
• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — batchQuery allowed for all roles (sub-queries enforce their own permissions)
• editor/src/MCPServer.h — registerBatchTools() with whetstone_batch_query tool definition and callWhetstone handler
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step256_test target

Key design decisions:

• Sub-queries reuse the same dispatch function (recursive call)
• Each sub-query result tagged with its method name for correlation
• Error isolation: failed sub-query returns error object, others unaffected
• batchQuery itself requires no special permission; sub-queries enforce their own
• tools/list now returns 22 tools (was 21): +whetstone_batch_query

Step 257: Token Efficiency Tests + Benchmarks

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Phase 9c closer. Systematic measurement of token savings across all compact/lean/delta/budget/batch features, plus throughput benchmarking.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step257_test.cpp — 12 test cases:
  1. Compact vs full AST ratio for 10-function module (7%)
  2. Compact vs full AST ratio for 50-function module (6%)
  3. Compact vs full AST ratio for 200-function module (6%)
  4. Lean scope vs detailed scope ratio (4%, under 20% target)
  5. Diagnostic delta vs full diagnostics validation
  6. Budget pagination across 3 pages covers all 51 nodes
  7. Batch query vs sequential bytes (single-envelope efficiency)
  8. Token estimates: compact < full (1001 vs 15039)
  9. Lean call hierarchy + lean deps both produce valid output
  10. Combined efficiency: batch + compact + lean + budget = 95% savings
  11. Benchmark: 100 parse→mutate→diagnose cycles in 8ms (0ms/cycle)
  12. Compact AST ratio stable across module sizes (spread=1%)

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step257_test target

Key results:

• Phase 9c complete: all 4 steps pass (48/48 tests across steps 254–257)
• Compact AST: 6–7% of full AST size across all module sizes (93–94% savings)
• Lean scope: 4% of detailed size (96% savings)
• Combined optimized query path: 95% total token savings vs naive approach
• Compact ratio stable across 10/50/200 function modules (1% spread)
• Throughput: 0ms/cycle for parse→mutate→diagnose (sub-millisecond)

---

Phase 9d: Multi-File Project Support

Step 258: Project Model and Workspace Indexing

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

HeadlessEditorState gains project awareness: openFile, closeFile, listBuffers, setActiveBuffer RPC methods for multi-buffer management, plus indexWorkspace for workspace-level file scanning. Language auto-detected from file extension.

Files created:

• editor/src/ProjectState.h — WorkspaceIndex (scan, findByExtension, findByLanguage, findByRelativePath, fileCount/dirCount), detectLanguage, IndexedFile struct, ProjectState wrapper
• editor/tests/step258_test.cpp — 12 test cases: openFile buffer creation, listBuffers with 3 files, setActiveBuffer switches AST context, closeFile removes buffer, language auto-detection, active flag in listBuffers, workspace indexing (5 files, 2 dirs), openFile reads from disk, closeFile error on nonexistent, Linter permission denied, MCP tool registration (5 new tools, 27 total), full open→switch→query→close workflow

Files modified:

• editor/src/HeadlessEditorState.h — include ProjectState.h, add ProjectState member
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — openFile, closeFile, listBuffers, setActiveBuffer, indexWorkspace RPC methods
• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — listBuffers/setActiveBuffer/ indexWorkspace read-only; openFile/closeFile require Refactor/Generator
• editor/src/MCPServer.h — registerProjectTools() with 5 MCP tool definitions (whetstone_open_file, whetstone_close_file, whetstone_list_buffers, whetstone_set_active_buffer, whetstone_index_workspace)
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step258_test target

Key design decisions:

• openFile auto-detects language from extension (detectLanguage)
• openFile reads from disk if no content provided (uses fileOpsResolvePath)
• listBuffers includes path, language, modified, and active flag per buffer
• indexWorkspace scans using FileTree (respects .gitignore) without opening files
• WorkspaceIndex provides findByExtension/findByLanguage for agent queries
• tools/list now returns 27 tools (was 22): +5 project management tools

Step 259: Cross-File Symbol Resolution

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

getInScopeSymbols gains crossFile: true parameter to include exported symbols from all other open buffers. Import graph tracks which files import which, updated automatically on openFile/closeFile. getImportGraph RPC method exposes the graph.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step259_test.cpp — 12 test cases: baseline local scope, crossFile includes other buffers' exports, cross-file symbols have file path, import graph populated on openFile, full import graph across 3 files, importedBy reverse query, cross-file detailed mode with node JSON, cross-file count > local count, closeFile removes from import graph, single buffer crossFile=local, collectExportedSymbols extraction, Linter role can read cross-file data

Files modified:

• editor/src/ProjectState.h — ImportGraph (addEdge, clearFile, importsOf, importedBy, updateFromAST, updateFromSource), ExportedSymbol struct, collectExportedSymbols, ProjectState gains ImportGraph member
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — getInScopeSymbols gains crossFile parameter (scans all bufferStates for exports), getImportGraph RPC method (per-file or full graph), openFile updates import graph, closeFile clears import graph entry
• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — getImportGraph as read-only
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step259_test target

Key design decisions:

• Cross-file symbols include file field identifying source buffer path
• Import graph built from AST Import nodes + source text fallback (Python parser doesn't generate Import AST nodes, so text scan catches import foo and from foo import bar patterns)
• Import graph auto-maintained: updated on openFile, cleared on closeFile
• getImportGraph supports per-file query (imports + importedBy) or full graph
• Cross-file detailed mode resolves node JSON from the source buffer's AST

Step 260: Project-Wide Diagnostics

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

getProjectDiagnostics returns diagnostics across all open files in one call, grouped by file path. Includes cross-file errors (E0400 for undefined imports). Supports optional severity filter and file glob filter.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step260_test.cpp — 12 test cases: basic result structure, cross-file E0400 for undefined import, known import not flagged, severity filter (error-only excludes warnings), fileGlob *.py, fileGlob specific file, empty project returns 0, multiple files with cross-file errors, diagnostic field validation, Linter role access, MCP tool registration, priority sorting

Files modified:

• editor/src/StructuredDiagnostics.h — added <set>, <sstream>, ast/Import.h includes; E04xx error code scheme documented; collectCrossFileDiagnostics() (AST-based) and collectCrossFileDiagnosticsFromSource() (text-based fallback) for detecting imports of modules not open in the project
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — getProjectDiagnostics RPC method: iterates all bufferStates, collects per-file + cross-file diagnostics, deduplicates AST vs source-based cross-file diags, applies severity and fileGlob filters, groups by file path
• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — getProjectDiagnostics as read-only
• editor/src/MCPServer.h — whetstone_get_project_diagnostics tool registered in registerDiagnosticTools()
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step260_test target

Key design decisions:

• Compact grouped format: {files: {"/path/foo.py": [{code,line,message}]}}
• Cross-file deduplication: source-text fallback only adds diags for lines not already covered by AST-based cross-file checks
• File glob filter: * prefix for suffix match (*.py), otherwise substring
• Severity filter reuses existing filterBySeverity() infrastructure
• Diagnostics sorted by priority within each file group
• All roles can call (read-only); 28 MCP tools total

Step 261: Project-Wide Search and Refactor

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

searchProject finds symbol references across all open files by name or nodeId. renameSymbol renames a symbol across all files with preview and apply modes. Both use recursive AST traversal to find Function definitions, FunctionCalls, Variable declarations, VariableReferences, and Parameters.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step261_test.cpp — 12 test cases: cross-file search by name, correct result fields, search by nodeId, definition vs call kind distinction, preview mode (shows changes without applying), apply mode (renames across 2 files with verification), parameter/variable reference rename, no-match error, Linter can search but not rename, unknown name returns 0, MCP tool registration, rename marks buffers as modified

Files modified:

• editor/src/ProjectState.h — SymbolReference struct, RenameChange struct, collectSymbolRefsRecursive() and collectSymbolReferences() (recursive AST search for matching names), buildRenameChangesRecursive() and buildRenameChanges() (builds property-change list for rename operations)
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — searchProject RPC method (by name or nodeId, returns file/line/col/nodeId/kind/context per reference), renameSymbol RPC method (preview mode returns change list, apply mode modifies AST nodes directly, marks buffers modified)
• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — searchProject as read-only, renameSymbol as mutation (Refactor/Generator only)
• editor/src/MCPServer.h — whetstone_search_project and whetstone_rename_symbol tools registered in registerProjectTools()
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step261_test target

Key design decisions:

• Recursive tree walk for deep references (FunctionCalls inside function bodies)
• Preview mode returns full change list without applying (agent can review)
• Apply mode directly modifies AST node properties (name, functionName, variableName)
• Rename changes include property name so agent sees what exactly changes
• Buffers marked as modified after rename for save-tracking
• Search returns kind field (definition/call/reference/parameter) to categorize
• 30 MCP tools total

Step 262: Phase 9d Multi-File Project Integration Tests

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

End-to-end integration tests exercising the full multi-file project workflow across 3-file Python projects. Simulates a realistic agent session from file opening through cross-file analysis, search, rename, and batch queries.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step262_test.cpp — 8 integration test cases:
  1. Open 3 files, listBuffers shows all with correct state
  2. setActiveBuffer switches context, getAST returns correct module
  3. Cross-file symbol resolution (crossFile=true includes other buffers' exports)
  4. Import graph tracks which files import which (main.py→utils+math_ops)
  5. Project-wide diagnostics: undefined import raises cross-file E0400
  6. searchProject finds symbol across 3 files (definition + call kinds)
  7. renameSymbol: preview then apply across 3 files, verified both directions
  8. Full workflow: open→batch(diagnostics+search+buffers)→rename→batch verify

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step262_test target

Key results:

• Phase 9d complete: all 5 steps pass (56/56 tests across steps 258–262)
• Full multi-file project workflow validated end-to-end
• 30 MCP tools, cross-file symbols, import graph, project diagnostics, search, rename
• Sprint 9 phases 9a–9d complete: 212/212 tests across steps 245–262

---

Phase 9e: Persistence and Undo/Redo

Step 263: Save Buffer to Disk

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

saveBuffer writes a buffer's editBuf to disk, resolving paths against the workspace root and creating parent directories as needed. saveAllBuffers saves all modified buffers in one call. Both clear the modified flag.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step263_test.cpp — 12 test cases: write to disk, clear modified flag, response fields (path/bytesWritten/success), saveAllBuffers batch save, mutation→save→verify content, Linter permission denied, default to active buffer, error on unknown buffer, saveAllBuffers clears all flags, returns saved paths, MCP tool registration, workspace path resolution with parent dir creation

Files modified:

• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — saveBuffer (resolve path, create parent dirs, write editBuf, clear modified, return bytesWritten), saveAllBuffers (iterate bufferStates, save modified, return savedCount/skippedCount/paths); renameSymbol editBuf regeneration via Pipeline::generate() after AST rename
• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — saveBuffer/saveAllBuffers/undo/redo as mutation methods (Refactor/Generator only)
• editor/src/MCPServer.h — registerSaveUndoTools() with 4 MCP tools: whetstone_save_buffer, whetstone_save_all_buffers, whetstone_undo, whetstone_redo
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step263_test target

Key design decisions:

• Paths resolved against workspaceRoot with escape protection
• Parent directories created automatically (std::filesystem::create_directories)
• saveAllBuffers skips unmodified buffers, reports savedCount/skippedCount
• renameSymbol now regenerates editBuf so saved content reflects renamed code
• 34 MCP tools total (was 30): +saveBuffer, +saveAllBuffers, +undo, +redo

Step 264: Undo/Redo for Headless Mode

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

State-based undo/redo using HeadlessUndoStack. Every mutation (applyMutation, applyBatch, renameSymbol) automatically records a snapshot (editBuf + AST JSON). undo restores the previous state; redo re-applies after undo. New mutations after undo clear the redo stack.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step264_test.cpp — 12 test cases: no history error, rename→undo restores original, editBuf restoration, undo→redo restores mutation, redo error, depth tracking (undoDepth/redoDepth), Linter permission denied, 3 mutations→3 undos, new mutation clears redo stack, undo sets modified flag, MCP tool registration, applyMutation→undo

Files modified:

• editor/src/HeadlessEditorState.h — HeadlessUndoState (text + astJson), HeadlessUndoStack class (record, canUndo/canRedo, undo/redo, undoDepth/redoDepth), HeadlessBufferState gains undoStack field, openBuffer records initial state
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — undo RPC method (restore AST via fromJson + sync.setAST, restore editBuf, set modified, return depths), redo RPC method (same restoration), post-mutation undoStack.record() calls in applyMutation, applyBatch, renameSymbol handlers

Key design decisions:

• State-based undo (snapshot text + AST JSON) vs operation-based
• Initial state recorded at openFile (position=0), post-mutation at position=N
• Undo decrements position, redo increments — classic position-based stack
• New mutation truncates redo states (standard undo/redo behavior)
• AST restored via JSON roundtrip (toJson/fromJson) for reliable deep clone
• Response includes undoDepth/redoDepth for agent awareness of stack state

Step 265: Phase 9e Persistence & Undo/Redo Integration Tests

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

End-to-end integration tests exercising save + undo/redo workflows together. Validates that save writes the correct version to disk after mutations, undos, and redos, and that saveAllBuffers respects mixed undo states across buffers.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step265_test.cpp — 8 integration test cases:
  1. mutate→save writes mutated code to disk
  2. mutate→undo→save writes original code to disk
  3. undo→redo→save writes mutated code back to disk
  4. saveAllBuffers with mixed undo states (a.py mutated, b.py undone)
  5. undo/redo/save cycle: greet→a→b all consistent on disk
  6. MCP has 34 tools with save+undo+redo tools present
  7. undo in memory doesn't affect already-saved file on disk
  8. Full workflow: open→mutate→diagnose→undo→redo→save

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step265_test target

Key results:

• Phase 9e complete: all 3 steps pass (32/32 tests across steps 263–265)
• Save + undo/redo integration validated end-to-end
• 34 MCP tools total
• Sprint 9 complete: all 5 phases pass (244/244 tests across steps 245–265)

---

Sprint 10 Progress — Semantic Annotation Taxonomy & Environment Layer

Phase 10a: Semantic Annotation Core + Sidecar Persistence (Steps 266-268)

Status: PASS (32/32 tests) — committed as 976161d

5 semantic annotation types (IntentAnnotation, ComplexityAnnotation, RiskAnnotation, ContractAnnotation, SemanticTagAnnotation) with JSON roundtrip, compact AST semantic summary, and sidecar persistence (.whetstone/.ast.json).

Key files:

• editor/src/ast/Annotation.h — 5 annotation class definitions
• editor/src/ast/Serialization.h — propertiesToJson/createNode/setPropertiesFromJson
• editor/src/CompactAST.h — extractSemanticSummary()
• editor/src/SidecarPersistence.h — sidecarPath, save/load, isSemanticAnnotation

---

Phase 10b: Annotation Agent Interface (Steps 269-271)

Status: PASS (32/32 tests) — committed as a049d60

High-level RPC methods for agent annotation workflow: setSemanticAnnotation, getSemanticAnnotations, removeSemanticAnnotation, getUnannotatedNodes. MCP prompt templates for annotation guidance.

Key additions:

• HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — 4 new RPC methods
• MCPServer.h — 4 MCP tools + 5 annotation prompt templates
• AgentPermissionPolicy.h — read/write permission mapping

---

Phase 10c: Type System, Execution & Scope Annotations (Steps 272-277)

Status: PASS (171/171 tests) — committed as e2d1872

24 new annotation classes across Subjects 2-4:

• Subject 2 (Type System): BitWidth, Endian, Layout, Nullability, Variance, Identity, Mut, TypeState
• Subject 3 (Concurrency): Atomic, Sync, ThreadModel, MemoryBarrier, Exec, Blocking, Parallel, Trap, Exception, Panic
• Subject 4 (Scope): Binding, Lookup, Capture, Visibility, Namespace, Scope

All wired through Serialization.h (3 dispatch points), CompactAST.h, SidecarPersistence.h, and HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h setSemanticAnnotation type mapping.

---

Phase 10d: Shims, Optimization, Meta-Programming & Policy Annotations (Steps 278-283)

Status: PASS (117/117 tests) — committed as 090320f

29 new annotation classes across Subjects 5-8:

• Subject 5 (Shims): Intrinsic, Raw, CallingConv, Link, Shim, PointerArithmetic, Opaque, Target, Feature, Original, Mapping
• Subject 6 (Optimization): TailCall, Loop, Data, Align, Pack, BoundsCheck, Overflow
• Subject 7 (Meta-Programming): Meta, Symbol, Evaluate, Template, Synthetic
• Subject 8 (Policy): Policy, Ambiguity, Candidate, Tradeoff, Choice, Decision

Generic fallback added to getSemanticAnnotations RPC for extensible annotation type support.

---

Phase 10e: Environment Layer (Steps 284-289)

Status: PASS (200/200 checks across steps 284–289)

New files created:

• editor/src/EnvironmentSpec.h — EnvironmentSpec AST node (envId, envVersion, capabilities, constraints, scheduler, memory, bindingTimes, exceptions, ffi), CapabilityRequirement annotation, capability vocabulary (17 known capabilities), validateCapabilities() (E0501 diagnostics), validateEnvAnnotations() (E0502-E0505 diagnostics), getLoweringHints() (env-aware lowering patterns), envSpecToJson/envSpecFromJson helpers
• editor/src/ast/HostBoundary.h — HostCall (Expression), ScheduleTask (Statement), ModuleLoad (Statement)

Core files updated:

• Serialization.h — propertiesToJson/createNode/setPropertiesFromJson for HostCall, ScheduleTask, ModuleLoad, EnvironmentSpec, CapabilityRequirement
• CompactAST.h — CapabilityRequirement in extractSemanticSummary, host boundary nodes in getNodeName
• SidecarPersistence.h — CapabilityRequirement in isSemanticAnnotation
• HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — capabilityRequirement type in setSemanticAnnotation, 4 new RPCs: setEnvironment, getEnvironment, validateEnvironment, getLoweringHints
• AgentPermissionPolicy.h — getEnvironment/validateEnvironment/getLoweringHints (read-only), setEnvironment (mutation)
• MCPServer.h — registerEnvironmentTools() with 4 MCP tool definitions (whetstone_set_environment, whetstone_get_environment, whetstone_validate_environment, whetstone_get_lowering_hints)

Test files:

• step284_test.cpp — 12 tests (EnvironmentSpec schema, JSON roundtrip, module attachment)
• step285_test.cpp — 12 tests (capability vocabulary, validation, CapabilityRequirement)
• step286_test.cpp — 12 tests (validateEnvAnnotations E0502-E0505, RPC validate/set/get, Linter permissions, MCP tool registration, env replacement)
• step287_test.cpp — 12 tests (getLoweringHints: callback/std_async/coroutine, suppress_dealloc/explicit_delete/raii_cleanup, try_catch/expected, combined hints, RPC method, null safety)
• step288_test.cpp — 12 tests (HostCall/ScheduleTask/ModuleLoad construction, JSON roundtrip, createNode, compact AST names, capability validation, nested body children)
• step289_test.cpp — 8 integration tests (full env workflow, env switch clears issues, host boundary roundtrip, capability validation e2e, lowering hints change with env, batch env queries, MCP tool count 38+, compact AST with host boundary)

Key results:

• Phase 10e complete: all 6 steps pass (200/200 checks across steps 284–289)
• 4 environment RPCs: setEnvironment, getEnvironment, validateEnvironment, getLoweringHints
• 5 environment diagnostics: E0501 (unmet capability), E0502–E0505 (annotation/scheduler incompatibility)
• 3 host boundary AST nodes: HostCall, ScheduleTask, ModuleLoad
• Lowering hint patterns: callback, std_async, coroutine, suppress_dealloc, explicit_delete, raii_cleanup, try_catch, expected, checked_throw
• 38 MCP tools total (was 34): +whetstone_set_environment, +whetstone_get_environment, +whetstone_validate_environment, +whetstone_get_lowering_hints
• Sprint 10 complete: all 5 phases pass (phases 10a–10e)

---

Sprint 11 Progress — Dial It In

Phase 11a: Semanno Format + Annotation Codegen (Steps 290-296)

Step 290: SemannoFormat.h — Comment Format Standard (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

@semanno:type(key=value) comment format standard with emitter and parser. Roundtrip-correct for all 8 annotation subjects + semantic core + environment.

Key files:

• editor/src/SemannoFormat.h — SemannoEmitter::emit() (67+ annotation types), SemannoParser::parse() (comment prefix detection for //, #, ;;), SemannoParser::isSemannoComment(), value escaping, vector properties
• editor/tests/step290_test.cpp — 12 tests: roundtrip for all 8 subjects, marker annotations, vector properties, comment prefix parsing, value escaping

Step 291: ProjectionGenerator — Subject 2-4 Visitors (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Verifies dispatchGenerate() correctly routes Subject 2-4 annotation types through SemannoAnnotationImpl visitor methods (Python and C++ generators).

Key files:

• editor/src/SemannoAnnotationImpl.h — CRTP mixin with virtual inheritance from AnnotationVisitorExtended, provides default visitor implementations for all 56 annotation types
• editor/src/ast/ProjectionGenerator.h — virtual inheritance from AnnotationVisitorExtended, dispatchGenerate() template
• editor/tests/step291_test.cpp — 12 tests: BitWidth, Endian, Layout, Nullability, Variance, Atomic, Sync, Exec, Capture, Visibility dispatch

Step 292: ProjectionGenerator — Subject 5-8 + Semantic Visitors (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Verifies Subject 5-8, Semantic Core, and Environment annotation dispatch through all generators. Exhaustive no-Unknown checks.

Key files:

• editor/tests/step292_test.cpp — 12 tests: Intrinsic, CallingConv, Target, TailCall, Loop, Meta, Synthetic, Policy, Intent, Capability dispatch

Step 293: Generator Implementations — Python/C++/Rust/Go (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Validates SemannoAnnotationImpl integration across Python, C++, Rust, and Go generators. Mixed annotation types, roundtrip verification, commentPrefix().

Key files:

• editor/tests/step293_test.cpp — 12 tests: type/concurrency/scope/shim/ optimization/meta/policy/semantic annotations across 4 generators

Step 294: Generator Implementations — Java/JS/Elisp (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Validates SemannoAnnotationImpl integration for Java, JavaScript, and Elisp generators. Prefix verification, annotation output, exhaustive no-Unknown check.

Key files:

• editor/tests/step294_test.cpp — 12 tests: prefix verification, annotation output, roundtrip, exhaustive no-Unknown for all 56+ types

Infrastructure fixes applied:

• Virtual inheritance: ProjectionGenerator : public virtual AnnotationVisitorExtended and SemannoAnnotationImpl : public virtual AnnotationVisitorExtended to resolve diamond inheritance ambiguity in generator classes
• Removed circular include: EnvironmentSpec.h no longer includes ast/Serialization.h

Step 295: Semanno Sidecar Integration (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Semanno sidecar persistence now supports full save/load roundtrip behavior, including empty sidecar file handling.

Key files:

• editor/src/SemannoSidecar.h — implemented sidecar API with structured save/load results, path helper, line-keyed L<line>: @semanno:... emission, and empty-module sidecar creation.
• editor/src/SidecarPersistence.h — include fixes for AST helper symbols used by sidecar merge logic.
• editor/tests/step295_test.cpp — includes sidecar persistence integration checks alongside Semanno sidecar tests.

Step 296: Phase 11a Integration Tests (8 tests)

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Full Phase 11a integration validation now passes end-to-end.

Key files:

• editor/src/SemannoSidecar.h — added result-based free-function API used by Sprint 11 tests (semannoSidecarPath, saveSemannoSidecar, loadSemannoSidecar), path/error/count reporting, and corrected line mapping to use parent spanStartLine.
• editor/tests/step296_test.cpp — integration suite executed and passing.

Verified checks:

• Parse/annotate/generate path preserves Subject 2-8 Semanno output.
• Cross-language generators preserve Semanno annotations.
• Exhaustive no-Unknown emission for 56+ annotation types.
• Semanno parse roundtrip for structured properties.
• Mixed legacy + new annotation handling in one module.
• Semanno sidecar save/load integration with expected counts.
• Language comment prefix conventions.
• Marker annotation emission without property parentheses.

---

Phase 11b: Validation & Conflict Completion (Steps 297-301)

Step 297: AnnotationValidatorExtended — Subject 2-4 Rules (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Validates type system (E0600-E0608), concurrency (E0700-E0708), and scope (E0800-E0805) annotations with structured diagnostic codes.

Key files:

• editor/src/AnnotationValidatorExtended.h — AnnotationValidatorExtended::validate() with isPowerOf2(), isOneOf() helpers, recursive AST walk, hasThreadModelOnAncestor() for E0704
• editor/tests/step297_test.cpp — 12 tests: BitWidth E0600 (invalid + valid), Endian E0601, Layout E0602+E0603, Nullability E0604, Variance E0605, Atomic E0700, Exec async E0704 (with/without ThreadModel), Capture E0802, Visibility E0803, all-valid-no-diags

Rules implemented:

• E0600: BitWidth must be power of 2
• E0601: Endian order must be "big" or "little"
• E0602: Layout mode must be "packed" or "aligned"
• E0603: Layout alignment must be power of 2
• E0604: Nullability strategy must be "strict" or "nullable"
• E0605: Variance must be "covariant", "contravariant", or "invariant"
• E0606: Identity mode must be "nominal" or "structural"
• E0607: Mut depth must be "shallow", "deep", or "interior"
• E0608: TypeState must be "erased" or "reified"
• E0700: Atomic consistency must be valid ordering
• E0701: Sync primitive must be "monitor", "spin", or "semaphore"
• E0702: ThreadModel must be "green", "os", or "fiber"
• E0703: Exec mode must be "async" or "event"
• E0704: Exec(async) requires ThreadModel on ancestor
• E0705: Blocking kind must be "io" or "compute"
• E0706: Parallel kind must be "data" or "task"
• E0707: Exception style must be "checked" or "unchecked"
• E0708: Panic behavior must be "abort" or "unwind"
• E0800: Binding time must be "static" or "dynamic"
• E0801: Lookup mode must be "lexical" or "hoisted"
• E0802: Capture strategy must be "value", "ref", or "move"
• E0803: Visibility must be "private", "internal", "friend", or "public"
• E0804: Namespace style must be "qualified" or "flat"
• E0805: Scope kind must be "local", "global_leaked", or "singleton"

Step 298: AnnotationValidatorExtended — Subject 5-8 Rules (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Validates shim/FFI (E0900-E0901), optimization (E1000-E1004), meta-programming (E1100-E1104), and policy (E1200-E1202) annotations.

Key files:

• editor/src/AnnotationValidatorExtended.h — extended with Subject 5-8 branches
• editor/tests/step298_test.cpp — 12 tests: CallingConv E0900, Shim E0901, Inline+TailCall E1000 (Always vs Hint), Loop hint E1001, Loop factor E1002, Align E1003, Overflow E1004, Meta state E1100, Template E1104, Policy strictness E1200, all-valid-no-diags

Rules implemented:

• E0900: CallingConv must be "stdcall", "cdecl", or "fastcall"
• E0901: Shim strategy must be "vtable", "trampoline", "union_tag", or "cast"
• E1000: Inline(Always) conflicts with TailCall
• E1001: Loop hint must be "unroll", "vectorize", or "fuse"
• E1002: Loop unroll factor must be positive
• E1003: Align bytes must be positive power of 2
• E1004: Overflow behavior must be "wrap", "saturation", or "panic"
• E1100: Meta state must be "quoted" or "unquoted"
• E1101: Meta phase must be "compile" or "runtime"
• E1102: Symbol mode must be "gensym" or "interned"
• E1103: Evaluate phase must be "compile_time" or "runtime"
• E1104: Template specialization must be "trait", "monomorphize", or "erasure"
• E1200: Policy strictness must be "high" or "low"
• E1201: Policy perf must be "critical" or "normal"
• E1202: Policy style must be "idiomatic" or "literal"

Step 299: Cross-Type Annotation Conflict Detection (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Detects semantic conflicts between different annotation families on the same node. Extends AnnotationConflict.h (which handles same-family parent/child conflicts) with cross-type detection.

Key files:

• editor/src/AnnotationConflictExtended.h — CrossTypeConflict struct, collectCrossTypeConflicts() with conditional lambda predicates, recursive child traversal
• editor/tests/step299_test.cpp — 12 tests: 6 conflict pairs detected, 4 no-false-positive tests (Capture value, ConstExpr+event, Inline Hint, Pack+packed), recursive child detection, multiple conflicts on same node

Conflict pairs:

1. @Pure + @Blocking — purity violated by blocking behavior
2. @Atomic + @Sync — conflicting synchronization models
3. @Capture(move) + @Owner(Shared_ARC) — move semantics incompatible with shared ref counting
4. @ConstExpr + @Exec(async) — compile-time eval can't be async
5. @Inline(Always) + @TailCall — inlining defeats tail call optimization
6. @Pack + @Layout(aligned) — packing and alignment contradict

Step 300: TransformEngineExtended (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Extended transform engine with float constant folding, dead variable elimination, and annotation-aware optimization that respects @OptimizationLock and @BoundsCheck.

Key files:

• editor/src/TransformEngineExtended.h — extends TransformEngine with floatConstantFolding() (bottom-up BinaryOperation folding on FloatLiterals), deadVariableElimination() (removes unreferenced Variable declarations), annotationAwareOptimize() (skips OptimizationLock/BoundsCheck-protected nodes), applyAllExtended() (runs all 3 transforms)
• editor/tests/step300_test.cpp — 12 tests: float add/mul folding, div-by-zero safety, dead var removal, used var preservation, OptimizationLock blocking, BoundsCheck skipping, nested float fold, multiple dead vars, applyAllExtended, nodesModified count accuracy

Step 301: Phase 11b Integration Tests (8 tests)

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

End-to-end integration tests for the full validation + conflict + transform pipeline.

Key files:

• editor/tests/step301_test.cpp — 8 integration tests:
  1. Extended E06xx-E12xx codes appear in collectAllDiagnostics
  2. Valid AST produces 0 diagnostics (no regressions)
  3. Cross-type conflicts (E0210) appear in diagnostic output
  4. Structured JSON fields correct (code/severity/nodeId/source)
  5. Combined extended validation + cross-type conflict on same AST
  6. annotationErrorCode extracts embedded [Exxxx] codes correctly
  7. Pipeline wiring: validator + conflict API work together
  8. Exhaustive coverage: all 7 subjects produce diagnostics for invalid input

Key results:

• Phase 11b complete: all 5 steps pass (56/56 tests across steps 297–301)
• 33+ annotation types with explicit validation rules (E0600-E1202)
• 6 cross-type conflict pairs detected with conditional predicates
• Float constant folding, dead variable elimination, annotation-aware optimization
• No regressions on existing E01xx-E05xx diagnostics

---

Phase 11c: Parser Deepening (Steps 302-308)

Step 302: New AST Nodes — Class/Interface/Generic (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

5 new AST node types for structured OOP and generic programming support. Full JSON roundtrip via Serialization.h (propertiesToJson, createNode, setPropertiesFromJson).

Key files:

• editor/src/ast/ClassDeclaration.h — ClassDeclaration (name, superClass, isAbstract; children: interfaces, fields, methods, annotations), InterfaceDeclaration (name; children: methods, annotations), MethodDeclaration (extends Function with className, isStatic, visibility, isOverride, isVirtual)
• editor/src/ast/GenericType.h — GenericType (baseName; children: typeParameters), TypeParameter (name, constraint)
• editor/src/ast/Serialization.h — propertiesToJson/createNode/setPropertiesFromJson for all 5 new types
• editor/tests/step302_test.cpp — 12 tests: construction + properties for all 5 types, child roles (methods/fields/interfaces), MethodDeclaration inherits Function children (parameters/body), JSON roundtrip for all 5 types, nested class structure with generic + method + field roundtrip

Step 303: New AST Nodes — Async/Lambda/Decorator (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

4 new AST node types for modern language constructs: async/await, lambdas/closures, and decorator annotations. Full JSON roundtrip via Serialization.h.

Key files:

• editor/src/ast/AsyncNodes.h — AsyncFunction (extends Function, isAsync flag), AwaitExpression (children: expression), LambdaExpression (captureList vector; children: parameters, body), DecoratorAnnotation (name; children: arguments)
• editor/src/ast/Serialization.h — propertiesToJson/createNode/setPropertiesFromJson for all 4 new types (captureList as JSON array)
• editor/tests/step303_test.cpp — 12 tests: construction for all 4 types, child roles (parameters/body/expression/arguments), JSON roundtrip for all 4, captureList array preservation, async+await nested in module roundtrip, lambda with captures inside function body roundtrip

Step 304: Serialization + Dispatch for New Nodes (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

All 9 new AST node types (ClassDeclaration, InterfaceDeclaration, MethodDeclaration, GenericType, TypeParameter, AsyncFunction, AwaitExpression, LambdaExpression, DecoratorAnnotation) dispatch through PythonGenerator and CppGenerator with language-appropriate output. JSON roundtrip preserves dispatch output identity.

Key files:

• editor/src/ast/PythonGenerator.h — 9 visitor implementations: class→class Name(Super):, interface→class Name(ABC):, method→def name(self):, generic→Name[T], async→async def name():, await→await expr, lambda→lambda x: body, decorator→@name(args)
• editor/src/ast/CppGeneratorTypes.h — 9 visitor implementations: class→class Name : public Super {}, interface→class Name {}, method→virtual void name(), generic→Name<T>, async→std::future<void> name(), await→co_await expr, lambda→[captures](auto x) { body }, decorator→// @name
• editor/src/ast/ProjectionGenerator.h — dispatchGenerate branches for all 9 types (lines 322-339)
• editor/tests/step304_test.cpp — 12 tests: per-type Python+C++ dispatch (9 types), nested class-with-methods dispatch, async-with-await nested dispatch, all-9-types JSON roundtrip→dispatch identity check

Step 305: Python + Java Parser Deepening (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Python: class, async def, await, lambda, @decorator. Java: class, interface, generics.

Step 306: JS/TS + Rust Parser Deepening (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

JS/TS: class, async/await, arrow functions. Rust: struct, impl, trait, async fn, closures.

Step 307: Go + C++ + Elisp Parser Deepening (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Go: struct/interface, method receivers. C++: class/struct, templates, virtual methods, lambdas. Elisp: lambda forms.

Step 308: Generator Updates + Phase 11c Integration (8 tests)

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

All 8 generators now produce language-appropriate output for all 9 new AST node types (ClassDeclaration, InterfaceDeclaration, MethodDeclaration, GenericType, TypeParameter, AsyncFunction, AwaitExpression, LambdaExpression, DecoratorAnnotation).

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/RustGenerator.h — 9 new visitor methods: struct/impl, trait, fn(&self), async fn, .await, |closures|, // @decorator
• editor/src/ast/GoGenerator.h — 9 new visitor methods: type struct, type interface, func receiver, func (goroutine async), <-channel await, func() lambda
• editor/src/ast/JavaGenerator.h — 9 new visitor methods: class extends, interface, public void method, List, CompletableFuture async, .get() await, (x) -> lambda, @annotation
• editor/src/ast/JavaScriptGenerator.h — 9 new visitor methods: class extends, class (interface fallback), method(), Name, async function, await, (x) => arrow, // @decorator
• editor/src/ast/ElispGenerator.h — 9 new visitor methods: cl-defstruct, cl-defgeneric, cl-defmethod, baseName (dynamic types), defun ;; async, (async-get), (lambda), ; @decorator
• editor/tests/step308_test.cpp — 8 integration tests
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step308_test target

Key results:

• Phase 11c complete: all 7 steps pass (80/80 tests across steps 302-308)
• All 8 generators produce non-empty, language-appropriate output for all 9 new AST types
• Language idioms verified: Rust struct+impl, Go type struct, Java extends/implements, JS extends/arrow, Python ABC/async def/lambda, C++ virtual/co_await/captures, Elisp defstruct/lambda
• JSON roundtrip → generate identity verified for ClassDeclaration
• TypeScript inherits JavaScript generator implementations

Phase 11d: New Languages — Kotlin + C# (Steps 309-313)

Step 309: Kotlin Parser (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

KotlinParser (regex-based, standalone) parses: fun → Function, suspend fun → AsyncFunction, class/data class → ClassDeclaration, val/var → Variable. Module target language set to "kotlin".

Step 310: Kotlin Generator (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

KotlinGenerator produces idiomatic Kotlin: fun, val, suspend fun, class : Super(), interface, { params -> body } lambdas, @decorator, generic types. Type mappings: int→Int, string→String, bool→Boolean, void→Unit, double→Double. Collection types: List<>, Set<>, Map<>, Array<>, Pair<>.

Step 311: C# Parser (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

CSharpParser (regex-based, standalone) parses: methods with visibility/return-type detection, async methods → AsyncFunction, class → ClassDeclaration, interface → InterfaceDeclaration. Skips using directives and namespace wrappers.

Step 312: C# Generator (12 tests)

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

CSharpGenerator produces idiomatic C#: public void, Allman braces, foreach..in, class : Base, interface, public async Task, await, (x) => lambda, [Attribute]. Type mappings: int, float, double, string, bool, void. Collection types: List<>, HashSet<>, Dictionary<>.

Step 313: New Languages Integration + MCP (8 tests)

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Full pipeline integration for Kotlin + C#:

• Pipeline.parse() and Pipeline.generate() route correctly for both languages
• Cross-language projection verified (Python→Kotlin, Java→C#)
• MemoryStrategyInference runs without error on Kotlin/C# modules
• All 10 generators produce non-empty output
• Final count: 10 parsers, 10 generators

Files created:

• editor/tests/step309_test.cpp — 12 Kotlin parser tests
• editor/tests/step310_test.cpp — 12 Kotlin generator tests
• editor/tests/step311_test.cpp — 12 C# parser tests
• editor/tests/step312_test.cpp — 12 C# generator tests
• editor/tests/step313_test.cpp — 8 integration tests

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/KotlinGenerator.h — 9 new AST node visitors (class, interface, method, generic, type param, suspend fun, await, lambda, @decorator)
• editor/src/ast/CSharpGenerator.h — 9 new AST node visitors (class, interface, method, generic, type param, async Task, await, lambda, [Attribute])
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — fixed Kotlin/C# parser routing (KotlinParser/CSharpParser instead of TreeSitterParser)
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — 5 new test targets (steps 309-313)

Key results:

• Phase 11d complete: all 5 steps pass (56/56 tests across steps 309-313)
• 10 language parsers, 10 language generators fully operational
• No regressions: Phase 11c (80/80) still passes
• Total Phase 11c+11d: 136/136 tests

---

Sprint 12 — Workflow Model + C++ Depth

Phase 12a: Core Workflow Model

Step 320: WorkItem — Core Execution Model

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

WorkItem extends SkeletonTask with execution lifecycle tracking — status transitions, worker assignment, timestamps, and results. This is the unit of work that flows through the routing engine.

Files created:

• editor/src/WorkItem.h — WorkItemResult struct (generatedCode, astJson, diagnostics, confidence, tokens, reasoning + JSON roundtrip), WorkItem struct (identity, routing, lifecycle, assignment, result), state machine helpers (isTerminal, canTransition, transitionWorkItem), createWorkItem from SkeletonTask, priorityToInt ordering, full JSON serialization
• editor/tests/step320_test.cpp — 12 tests: construction from SkeletonTask, unique ID generation, valid/invalid state transitions, timestamp population, WorkItemResult roundtrip, WorkItem roundtrip, isTerminal, createdAt, dependencies preserved, priority ordering, result attachment roundtrip

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step320_test target

State machine: pending→ready→assigned→in-progress→(review→complete|rejected OR complete); rejected→ready

Step 321: TaskQueue — Priority Queue with Dependencies

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Ordered queue that respects both priority levels and dependency chains. Items whose dependencies are unsatisfied stay blocked; ready items are ordered by priority (critical first) then creation time.

Files created:

• editor/src/TaskQueue.h — TaskQueue class with enqueue, dequeue, peek, complete, reject, getReady, getBlocked, getByStatus, getItem, updateItem; dependency resolution on completion, priority-based sorting
• editor/tests/step321_test.cpp — 12 tests: enqueue/dequeue ordering, priority ordering, dependency blocking, reject/re-enqueue, getReady filtering, empty queue, getByStatus, size tracking, completion cascading (A→B→C chain), mixed priorities with deps, peek no-remove, updateItem

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step321_test target

Step 322: WorkflowState — Project-Level Workflow Tracking

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Top-level state managing the full workflow lifecycle for a project: from skeleton creation through routing, execution, review, and completion. Auto-detects phase from item statuses, tracks audit trail, computes stats.

Files created:

• editor/src/WorkflowState.h — WorkflowPhase enum (Modeling/Routing/Executing/ Reviewing/Complete), StatusChange audit trail struct, WorkflowStats struct, WorkflowState class with populateFromSkeleton, getStats, getPhase (auto-computed), getHistory, recordChange, toJson/fromJson
• editor/tests/step322_test.cpp — 12 tests: populate from skeleton, phase auto-detection (empty, all pending, executing, reviewing, complete), stats accuracy, history tracking, JSON roundtrip, empty workflow, phase transitions through lifecycle, populate records history

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step322_test target

Step 323: Workflow Sidecar Persistence

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Save and load workflow state to .whetstone/<project>.workflow.json so workflows survive across sessions. Handles directory creation, overwrite, delete, and multiple workflows in the same workspace.

Files created:

• editor/src/WorkflowPersistence.h — SaveResult struct, workflowSidecarPath, ensureDirectoryExists, saveWorkflow (serialize + write), loadWorkflow (read + deserialize, nullopt if missing), deleteWorkflow
• editor/tests/step323_test.cpp — 12 tests: save/load roundtrip, all fields preserved, history preserved, missing file nullopt, directory creation, delete removes file, multiple workflows, results preserved, empty workflow, sidecar path format, overwrite, delete nonexistent

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step323_test target

Step 324: Workflow RPC + MCP Tools

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Exposes workflow management through 8 RPC methods and 8 MCP tools so agents can create, inspect, and advance workflows. Linter role restricted to read-only access; Refactor/Generator can mutate.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step324_test.cpp — 12 tests: createWorkflow, getReadyTasks ordering, assignTask transitions, completeTask with result + cascade, rejectTask re-enqueue, getWorkItem details, Linter restrictions, MCP registration (8 new tools, 50+ total), saveWorkflow RPC, getWorkflowState, no-workflow error, nonexistent item error

Files modified:

• editor/src/HeadlessEditorState.h — added WorkflowState/WorkflowPersistence includes, optional workflow member
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — 8 new RPC methods: createWorkflow, getWorkflowState, getReadyTasks, getWorkItem, assignTask, completeTask, rejectTask, saveWorkflow
• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — read-only: getWorkflowState, getReadyTasks, getWorkItem; mutation: createWorkflow, assignTask, completeTask, rejectTask, saveWorkflow
• editor/src/MCPServer.h — registerWorkflowExecutionTools() with 8 tools
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step324_test target

Tool count: 50+ (42 existing + 8 workflow execution tools)

Step 325: Phase 12a Integration Tests

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

End-to-end workflow lifecycle from skeleton to completion. Covers priority ordering, dependency chains (A→B→C cascade), full lifecycle with results, rejection flow, persistence roundtrip, stats accuracy, and a combined 5-function workflow with mixed priorities and dependencies.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step325_test.cpp — 8 integration tests: skeleton→workflow, priority ordering, dependency chain cascade, full lifecycle with result, rejection flow, persistence save/load, stats accuracy, combined 5-item workflow completing to phase=Complete

Files modified:

• editor/src/TaskQueue.h — updateItem triggers resolveDependencies when item status becomes complete (fixes cascade through RPC path)
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step325_test target

Phase 12a complete: 6/6 steps (320-325), 68/68 tests passing

Phase 12b: Routing Engine + Workers

Step 326: RoutingEngine — Annotation-to-Dispatch Logic

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Given a WorkItem with routing annotations, produces a RoutingDecision with worker type, context width, token budget, review requirements, confidence, and reasoning. Priority cascade: explicit override → ambiguity gate → context width escalation → getter/setter patterns → defaults.

Files created:

• editor/src/RoutingEngine.h — RoutingDecision struct (with JSON helpers), estimateContextBudget, agentRoleForWorker, isGetterSetterPattern, RoutingEngine class with route, routeBatch, routeAndApply
• editor/tests/step326_test.cpp — 12 tests: explicit override, ambiguity→human, getter/setter→deterministic, cross-project→llm, project→llm, review annotation, batch routing, default local/file, confidence levels, context budgets

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step326_test target

Step 327: WorkerRegistry — Worker Abstractions

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Worker interface with 5 concrete implementations: DeterministicWorker (intent-based code gen), TemplateWorker (getter/setter/accessor patterns), SLMAgentWorker/LLMAgentWorker (context bundle preparation for external invocation), HumanWorker (marks for human review). Registry with lookup.

Files created:

• editor/src/WorkerRegistry.h — WorkerContext struct, WorkerInterface abstract base, DeterministicWorker, TemplateWorker, SLMAgentWorker, LLMAgentWorker, HumanWorker, WorkerRegistry with getDefaultRegistry
• editor/tests/step327_test.cpp — 12 tests: deterministic with/without intent, template getter/setter/boolean accessor, LLM context bundle, human review marking, registry lookup, canHandle filtering, worker type strings, SLM context assembly, rejection feedback in context

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step327_test target

Step 328: ContextAssembler — Context Window Assembly + Budget

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Builds context windows per @ContextWidth (local/file/project/cross-project) with token budget enforcement. Prioritizes: target node > annotations > siblings > buffer content > project summaries under truncation.

Files created:

• editor/src/ContextAssembler.h — BufferInfo struct, estimateTokens helpers, ContextAssembler class with assembleContext (local/file/project/cross-project strategies), budget truncation, sibling/import graph inclusion
• editor/tests/step328_test.cpp — 12 tests: local/file/project/cross-project context, budget truncation, priority under truncation, import graph, empty project fallback, token estimation, unlimited budget, siblings, rejection feedback preservation

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step328_test target

Step 329: Routing RPC + MCP Tools

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Exposes routing and worker dispatch through 4 RPC methods and 4 MCP tools. routeTask/routeAllReady apply routing decisions, executeTask runs workers (deterministic/template produce code, agent/human prepare context bundles), getRoutingExplanation shows reasoning.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step329_test.cpp — 12 tests: routeTask, routeAllReady batch, execute deterministic, agent prepared, human marked, routing explanation, Linter restrictions, MCP registration (4 new, 54+ total), route updates item, no-worker error, itemIds in batch, auto-approved for template

Files modified:

• editor/src/HeadlessEditorState.h — added RoutingEngine, WorkerRegistry, ContextAssembler members
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — 4 new RPC methods: routeTask, routeAllReady, executeTask, getRoutingExplanation
• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — read-only: getRoutingExplanation; mutation: routeTask, routeAllReady, executeTask
• editor/src/MCPServer.h — registerRoutingTools() with 4 tools
• editor/src/RoutingEngine.h — getter/setter routes to "template" (not "deterministic") for correct auto-approve with TemplateWorker
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step329_test target

Tool count: 54+ (50 existing + 4 routing tools)

Step 330: Review Gates

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Configurable auto-approve rules and review queue. Default policy auto-approves deterministic/template workers with >=0.9 confidence; everything else requires review. Explicit @Review(required) always overrides auto-approve.

Files created:

• editor/src/ReviewGate.h — AutoApproveRule, ReviewPolicy (with default), ReviewDecision, ReviewGate with shouldAutoApprove, risk level helpers
• editor/tests/step330_test.cpp — 12 tests: deterministic/template auto-approve, LLM requires review, low confidence rejected, custom policy, default policy, @Review override, wildcard rule, policy roundtrip, empty policy, default require-review, human requires review

Files modified:

• editor/src/HeadlessEditorState.h — ReviewGate + ReviewPolicy members
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — setReviewPolicy, getReviewPolicy RPCs
• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — getReviewPolicy read-only, setReviewPolicy mutation
• editor/src/MCPServer.h — registerReviewTools() with 2 tools
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step330_test target

Tool count: 56+ (54 existing + 2 review tools)

Step 331: Phase 12b Integration Tests

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Full routing pipeline integration tests covering skeleton→workflow→route→execute→review lifecycle. Tests verify mixed worker type routing, getter template auto-approve, LLM context preparation, human routing for high-ambiguity, dependency chains with mixed routing, rejection with feedback flow, review policy switching, and 5-function mixed skeleton lifecycle.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step331_test.cpp — 8 integration tests: skeleton_route_all, getter_full_lifecycle, complex_llm_context, high_ambiguity_human, dependency_mixed_routing, rejection_with_feedback, review_policy_switch, full_lifecycle_mixed

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step331_test target with tree-sitter libraries

Phase 12b complete: Steps 326-331 (RoutingEngine, WorkerRegistry, ContextAssembler, Routing RPC+MCP, ReviewGate, Integration Tests)

Phase 12c: C++ AST Depth — Inheritance + CRTP

Step 332: Multiple Inheritance in ClassDeclaration

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Upgraded ClassDeclaration from single superClass string to vector with access specifiers (public/protected/private) and virtual inheritance flags. Backward compatible: legacy superClass field still works via getBases() migration. Added diamond inheritance detection via static hasDiamondInheritance() with BFS traversal.

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/ClassDeclaration.h — BaseClass struct, addBase(), getBases(), hasDiamondInheritance() static method
• editor/src/ast/Serialization.h — baseClasses array serialization/deserialization with legacy superClass backward compat
• editor/src/CompactAST.h — getNodeName for ClassDeclaration, InterfaceDeclaration, MethodDeclaration
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step332_test target

Files created:

• editor/tests/step332_test.cpp — 12 tests: backward compat, multiple bases, access specifiers, virtual inheritance, JSON roundtrip, diamond detection, legacy migration, addBase helper, full serialization roundtrip

Step 333: Template Class Declarations

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Extended GenericType with isClassTemplate flag and TypeParameter with isVariadic for variadic template packs. Added isCRTPClass() helper for CRTP pattern detection. Full serialization round-trip for both flags.

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/GenericType.h — isCRTPClass() helper, isClassTemplate/isVariadic already had fields, replaced stub isCRTP()
• editor/src/ast/Serialization.h — isClassTemplate for GenericType, isVariadic for TypeParameter in propertiesToJson/createNode/setPropertiesFromJson
• editor/src/CompactAST.h — getNodeName for GenericType ("template:name"), TypeParameter
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step333_test target

Files created:

• editor/tests/step333_test.cpp — 12 tests: isClassTemplate flag, isVariadic, CRTP detection, JSON roundtrip, CompactAST output

Step 334: C++ Parser — Inheritance + Templates

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Extended CppParser to extract multiple base classes from tree-sitter CST, including access specifiers and virtual keyword. Iterates ALL children (named + unnamed) of base_class_clause to detect virtual (unnamed node), access_specifier, and type identifiers.

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/CppParser.h — Rewrote base_class_clause parsing to iterate all children with pending access/virtual state machine
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step334_test target with tree-sitter libraries

Files created:

• editor/tests/step334_test.cpp — 12 tests: single/multiple inheritance, access specifiers, virtual, template classes, CRTP detection, struct default public

Step 335: C++ Generator — Inheritance + Templates

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Updated CppGenerator, PythonGenerator, and JavaGenerator to emit correct inheritance syntax using getBases(). C++ outputs access specifiers + virtual keyword + template prefix. Python outputs direct multiple inheritance. Java uses first base as extends, rest as implements.

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/CppGeneratorTypes.h — visitClassDeclaration: template prefix from GenericType.isClassTemplate, multiple inheritance with access specifiers + virtual
• editor/src/ast/PythonGenerator.h — visitClassDeclaration: getBases() for multi-base
• editor/src/ast/JavaGenerator.h — visitClassDeclaration: extends + implements adaptation
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step335_test target

Files created:

• editor/tests/step335_test.cpp — 12 tests: C++ multi-inheritance, access specifiers, virtual, template class, CRTP, cross-language (Python/Java/Rust), variadic templates, combined template + inheritance, method visibility, full roundtrip

Step 336: Phase 12c Integration Tests

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Full integration pipeline for C++ inheritance + templates. Parse real C++ classes with multiple inheritance, CRTP, and templates via tree-sitter, generate cross-language output, verify diamond detection, and JSON serialization roundtrip.

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step336_test target with tree-sitter libraries

Files created:

• editor/tests/step336_test.cpp — 8 tests: parse Whetstone-style class, CRTP detection, parse→generate roundtrip, C++→Java extends+implements, C++→Python multi-base, template 3 params, diamond inheritance detection, mixed template+inheritance+virtual pipeline

Phase 12d: C++ AST Depth — Preprocessor, Enums, Namespaces

Step 337: Preprocessor AST Nodes

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added first-class AST nodes for C++ preprocessor directives: IncludeDirective (path, isSystem), PragmaDirective (directive), MacroDefinition (name, parameters, body, isFunctionLike). Statement-level nodes that attach to Module children. Full JSON serialization roundtrip and CompactAST node name support.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/PreprocessorNodes.h — IncludeDirective, PragmaDirective, MacroDefinition
• editor/tests/step337_test.cpp — 12 tests: construction, system vs local include, JSON roundtrip, pragma, function-like vs object-like macros, CompactAST names, module with mixed nodes, empty body, createNode dispatch

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Serialization.h — propertiesToJson/createNode/setPropertiesFromJson for all 3 preprocessor types
• editor/src/CompactAST.h — getNodeName for IncludeDirective, PragmaDirective, MacroDefinition
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step337_test target

Step 338: EnumDeclaration + NamespaceDeclaration

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added EnumDeclaration (scoped/unscoped, underlying type, EnumMember children), NamespaceDeclaration (with body children, supports nesting), and TypeAlias (using vs typedef). Full JSON serialization roundtrip and CompactAST names for all 4 types.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/EnumNamespaceNodes.h — EnumDeclaration, EnumMember, NamespaceDeclaration, TypeAlias
• editor/tests/step338_test.cpp — 12 tests: construction, scoped vs unscoped enum, members with values, namespace with body, typedef vs using, JSON roundtrip for all 4 types, CompactAST names, nested namespace, enum inside namespace

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Serialization.h — propertiesToJson/createNode/setPropertiesFromJson for all 4 types
• editor/src/CompactAST.h — getNodeName for EnumDeclaration, EnumMember, NamespaceDeclaration, TypeAlias
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step338_test target

Step 339: C++ Parser — Preprocessor, Enum, Namespace

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Extended CppParser to parse preprocessor directives (#include, #pragma, #define), enums (scoped/unscoped with values), namespaces (with recursive body parsing), and type aliases (using/typedef) from tree-sitter CST. Handles preproc_include, preproc_def, preproc_function_def, preproc_call, enum_specifier, namespace_definition, alias_declaration, and type_definition node types.

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Parser.h — Added PreprocessorNodes.h, EnumNamespaceNodes.h includes
• editor/src/ast/CppParser.h — Extended convertCppTranslationUnit dispatch, added convertCppInclude, convertCppMacroDef, convertCppPragma, convertCppEnum, convertCppNamespace, convertCppTypeAlias converter functions
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step339_test target with tree-sitter libraries

Files created:

• editor/tests/step339_test.cpp — 12 tests: system/local include, pragma once, object-like/function-like macros, scoped/plain enums, namespace with body, using alias, typedef, mixed file, backward compat

Step 340: C++ Generator — Preprocessor, Enum, Namespace

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

All 9 generators (C++, Python, Java, Rust, Go, JavaScript, Elisp, Kotlin, C#) now produce language-appropriate output for all 6 new AST node types: IncludeDirective, PragmaDirective, MacroDefinition, EnumDeclaration, NamespaceDeclaration, TypeAlias. ProjectionGenerator.h dispatch extended with 6 new branches + default visitor methods.

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/ProjectionGenerator.h — 6 new virtual visitors + dispatch branches, added PreprocessorNodes.h + EnumNamespaceNodes.h includes
• editor/src/ast/CppGeneratorTypes.h — 6 visitor implementations (native C++ output)
• editor/src/ast/PythonGenerator.h — import, class(Enum), def macro, type alias
• editor/src/ast/JavaGenerator.h — import, enum, package, static final
• editor/src/ast/RustGenerator.h — use, enum, mod, macro_rules!, type alias
• editor/src/ast/GoGenerator.h — import, type+iota, package, const
• editor/src/ast/JavaScriptGenerator.h — import, Object.freeze enum, const, JSDoc typedef
• editor/src/ast/ElispGenerator.h — require, defconst enum, defmacro, defalias
• editor/src/ast/KotlinGenerator.h — import, enum class, package, typealias
• editor/src/ast/CSharpGenerator.h — using, enum, namespace, #pragma, type alias

Files created:

• editor/tests/step340_test.cpp — 12 tests: C++ include/enum/namespace output, Python/Java/Rust/Go enum adaptation, cross-language includes (8 generators), using/typedef, Kotlin+C# enum, pragma+define, all 9 generators non-empty for 6 types

Step 341: Phase 12d Integration + Sprint 12 Summary

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

End-to-end integration tests for full C++ depth: realistic header parsing (includes

• pragma + namespace + enum + class + function), JSON roundtrip, enum-inside-namespace scoping, cross-language enum output (6 languages), combined namespace+class+enum pipeline, batch serialization verification, CompactAST names, self-hosting progress (simplified Whetstone header fragment parsed successfully).

Files created:

• editor/tests/step341_test.cpp — 8 integration tests

Key results:

• Phase 12d complete: all 5 steps pass (56/56 tests across steps 337–341)
• All 10 generators produce language-appropriate output for 6 new C++ node types
• C++ parser handles: preprocessor, enum class, namespace, type alias
• Self-hosting milestone: simplified Whetstone header fragment parses correctly
• Sprint 12 complete: all 4 phases pass (248/248 tests across steps 320–341)
• 56+ MCP tools, workflow engine, routing engine, review gates, C++ depth

---

Sprint 13 Progress — GUI Overhaul Phase 1

---

Step 351: Keybinding Registry

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Expanded the centralized keybinding registry so actions have stable bindings that can be displayed with symbols, matched from input state, and persisted to/from disk. This extends the earlier keybinding foundation with stronger runtime and persistence primitives for the upcoming command palette/menu work.

Files modified:

• editor/src/KeybindingRegistry.h — added:
  • KeyCombo::InputState and KeyCombo::matches(...) for key state matching
  • KeyCombo::keyToSymbol(...), normalizeKey(...), toSymbolsAuto(...)
  • KeybindingRegistry::getAll() alias for settings/UI consumption
  • KeybindingRegistry::processInput(...) -> optional<actionId>
  • KeybindingRegistry::saveToJson(path) and loadFromJsonFile(path)
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step351_test target

Files created:

• editor/tests/step351_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. bind + retrieve
  2. default bindings
  3. KeyCombo::toString
  4. mac-style symbol rendering
  5. input processing match
  6. input processing no-match
  7. file save/load roundtrip
  8. rebinding
  9. conflict detection
  10. display symbol retrieval
  11. modifier bitmask helpers
  12. exact match behavior + getAll

Verification run:

• step343_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step350_test — PASS (8/8) latest completed sprint checkpoint
• step351_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage

Step 352: Key Symbol Rendering

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implemented a headless key symbol rendering layer for menus/tooltips/command palette UI data. The renderer now builds styled key badge data, action rows with shortcut columns, and multi-key chord strings in both text and symbol forms.

Files modified:

• editor/src/KeySymbolRenderer.h — added/expanded:
  • renderKeySymbol(...) (text badge) + backward-compatible renderKeyBadge(...)
  • renderKeyBadgeSymbols(..., macOS) for symbol mode
  • renderActionWithKey(..., theme, category) with layout metadata
  • overload preserving previous call shape
  • renderKeyChord(...) + renderKeyChordSymbols(..., macOS)
  • badge styling fields (padding/radius) and menu overlap heuristic
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step352_test target

Files created:

• editor/tests/step352_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. single key badge rendering
  2. modifier+key rendering
  3. platform symbol output
  4. menu item label/shortcut layout data
  5. key chord text rendering
  6. badge background/border assignment
  7. theme color/font propagation
  8. empty binding behavior
  9. special key symbol mapping (Enter/Escape/Tab)
  10. long-label overlap check
  11. chord symbols rendering
  12. shouldRender behavior

Verification run:

• step351_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step352_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage

Step 353: Command Palette

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Extended the command palette into a richer step-353 foundation: stateful open/close, selection movement, execute-selected behavior, and broadened fuzzy search over labels, ids, categories, and aliases. Added population helpers that pull actions from KeybindingRegistry and panel toggles from PanelManager.

Files modified:

• editor/src/CommandPalette.h — added:
  • palette state APIs: open(), close(), isOpen(), setQuery(), selectedIndex()
  • command metadata: icon, aliases
  • registration helpers: registerFromKeybindings(...), registerPanelToggles(...)
  • expanded fuzzy search scoring across label/id/category/aliases
  • selection navigation: moveSelection(...)
  • execution helper: executeSelected(...) with recent-use tracking
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step353_test target

Files created:

• editor/tests/step353_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. open/close state
  2. fuzzy search by label
  3. fuzzy search by alias
  4. keybinding registry population
  5. panel toggle population
  6. execute selected action
  7. selection wrap behavior
  8. query reset behavior
  9. recent action ranking
  10. strict context filtering
  11. category-based matching
  12. no-match behavior

Verification run:

• step344_test — PASS (12/12) command palette integration regression
• step346_test — PASS (8/8) layout + palette integration regression
• step353_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage

Step 354: Menu Bar with Key Symbols

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a structured menu bar model with File/Edit/View/Tools/Workflow/Help menus, key-symbol metadata on actions, separator grouping, action selection handling, and submenu support for help/documentation. Menu action labels/shortcuts are derived from KeybindingRegistry and rendered via KeySymbolRenderer so the symbol display path is consistent with step 352.

Files created:

• editor/src/MenuBar.h — headless menu model:
  • MenuItem / Menu / MenuBar
  • buildDefaults(...) for the full menu set
  • selection API (openMenu, selectItem) with close-on-select behavior
  • submenu metadata support and separator counting helpers
• editor/tests/step354_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. core menus present
  2. File Save shortcut
  3. Edit Undo shortcut
  4. View panel toggle actions
  5. Tools pipeline action
  6. correct action execution id
  7. key symbol visibility
  8. menu close after selection
  9. separator grouping
  10. workflow action presence
  11. submenu metadata
  12. invalid selection handling

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step354_test target

Verification run:

• step352_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step353_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step354_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage

Step 355: Phase 13c Integration — Keyboard Shortcuts Help Panel

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Integrated a dedicated keyboard-shortcuts panel model and connected the end-to-end keyboard flow across the keybinding registry, command palette, and menu bar. This provides grouped/filterable shortcut rows plus refresh-on-rebind behavior and a full keyboard-driven command execution path.

Files created:

• editor/src/KeyboardShortcutsPanel.h — panel data model:
  • visibility state, filter text, grouped rows by category
  • row projection from KeybindingRegistry (label/category/symbols)
  • customize-request signal (requestCustomize / consumeCustomizeRequest)
• editor/tests/step355_test.cpp — 8 integration tests:
  1. defaults appear in shortcuts panel
  2. Ctrl+S resolves to save action
  3. Ctrl+P opens command palette
  4. command palette entries include key symbols
  5. menu entries include key symbols
  6. rebind propagates to shortcuts panel
  7. symbol rendering works for current platform mode
  8. keyboard workflow: Ctrl+P → query pipeline → execute run-pipeline

Files modified:

• editor/src/KeybindingRegistry.h — added keyboard-shortcuts action and default binding (Ctrl+Shift+?) to support help-panel keyboard access
• editor/src/CommandPalette.h — added symbols field on command entries and populated symbol strings from keybindings
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step355_test target

Verification run:

• step351_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step353_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step354_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step355_test — PASS (8/8) new integration coverage

Step 356: Breadcrumb Navigation

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implemented a breadcrumb bar model that tracks AST path from module root to cursor node, supports click-based navigation targets, and exposes sibling lists for dropdown navigation. The model uses compact node names (getNodeName) and theme-derived colors for consistent visual integration.

Files created:

• editor/src/panels/BreadcrumbBar.h — headless breadcrumb model:
  • buildBreadcrumbBar(...) path generation from module/cursor
  • clickable navigation helper (navigateBreadcrumbClick)
  • sibling dropdown helpers (breadcrumbSiblings, breadcrumbSiblingNames)
  • theme color wiring + overflow signal for deep paths
• editor/tests/step356_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. module name segment
  2. cursor-driven nested updates
  3. click navigation
  4. sibling dropdown population
  5. empty-file fallback
  6. deep path overflow handling
  7. theme color usage
  8. annotation nodes in path
  9. compact naming for class/method
  10. out-of-range click safety
  11. root sibling behavior
  12. foreign-node fallback to module-only

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step356_test target

Verification run:

• step354_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step355_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step356_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage

Step 357: Status Bar

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a status-bar data model that provides left/center/right sections for language/file, cursor+encoding+line-ending, and diagnostics/workflow/MCP state. The model includes theme-driven colors, overflow signaling, and a diagnostics focus target for click handling.

Files created:

• editor/src/panels/StatusBar.h — headless status model:
  • StatusBarInput + StatusBarModel
  • buildStatusBar(...) section construction and overflow check
  • language badge color mapping
  • diagnostics click target helper
• editor/tests/step357_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. language badge
  2. cursor position updates
  3. diagnostic summary counts
  4. workflow badge visibility/content
  5. diagnostics click target
  6. theme color usage
  7. language switch behavior
  8. encoding display
  9. normal-fit no-overflow case
  10. overflow flag on extreme content
  11. line-ending display
  12. MCP connected/offline indicator

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step357_test target

Verification run:

• step355_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step356_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step357_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage

Step 358: Go-to-Definition + Go-to-Symbol

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implemented headless navigation tooling for symbol discovery and jump resolution: file-level and project-level symbol lists, symbol filtering, icon/type metadata, and go-to-definition lookup with current-file preference and cross-file fallback.

Files created:

• editor/src/panels/NavigationTools.h — navigation model:
  • symbol collection (collectFileSymbols, collectProjectSymbols)
  • symbol filtering (filterSymbols)
  • F12-style definition lookup (goToDefinition)
  • no-match messaging (definitionStatusMessage)
  • line-order sorting and icon assignment
• editor/tests/step358_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. definition jump from function call
  2. file symbol listing
  3. project symbol listing
  4. icon presence by symbol type
  5. symbol filtering
  6. cross-file definition jump
  7. no-match message
  8. line-number sort order
  9. empty-query behavior
  10. case-insensitive filtering
  11. current-file definition preference
  12. null-call safety

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step358_test target

Verification run:

• step356_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step357_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step358_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage

Step 359: Find and Replace Improvements

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implemented a find/replace bar model with in-file match tracking, current-match navigation, replace-current/replace-all flows, and project-wide search results. Model behavior includes open/close modes, highlight state, and match counter text.

Files created:

• editor/src/panels/FindReplaceBar.h — find/replace model:
  • find/replace visibility + mode toggles
  • query + match indexing + counter text
  • next/previous match navigation
  • replace-current and replace-all operations
  • project-wide search result generation
• editor/tests/step359_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. open find
  2. query-to-match filtering
  3. highlight visibility
  4. match counter formatting
  5. next-match cycling
  6. replace mode open
  7. replace-current operation
  8. project search results
  9. close behavior
  10. empty-query clears highlights
  11. previous-match cycling
  12. replace-all behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step359_test target

Verification run:

• step357_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step358_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step359_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage

Step 360: Phase 13d Integration + Sprint 13 Summary

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Completed Phase 13d integration with end-to-end checks across keyboard navigation, go-to-definition, breadcrumb navigation, command palette search flows, status bar state transitions, key symbol visibility, and panel layout persistence.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step360_test.cpp — 8 integration tests:
  1. keyboard workflow + definition jump + breadcrumb back-navigation
  2. command palette find flow + project result navigation
  3. status bar response to buffer/language/cursor/diagnostic changes
  4. docked-panel invariant (no floating model state)
  5. theme consistency across navigation components
  6. key symbols in menu + palette + shortcuts panel
  7. layout snapshot/restore roundtrip
  8. sprint-level operational gates (docking/theme/keys/navigation)

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step360_test target

Verification run:

• step358_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step359_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step360_test — PASS (8/8) phase integration coverage

Key results:

• Phase 13d complete: all 5 steps pass (56/56 tests across steps 356–360)
• Sprint 13 complete: all phases pass (212/212 tests across steps 342–360)
• Navigation foundation in place: breadcrumbs, status model, symbol navigation, find/replace model, and full keyboard-centric integration path
• Key symbol consistency validated across all primary interaction surfaces
• Post-sprint architecture gate passed: refactored MenuBar::buildDefaults into helper functions to satisfy the max function length constraint (<=80 lines), with step354_test, step355_test, and step360_test revalidated

---

Sprint 14 Progress — Language Batch 1

Step 361: C Parser — Functions, Structs, Enums

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a standalone C parser (regex/text-based, no new tree-sitter dependency) that handles core C declarations and preprocessor constructs needed for the pipeline entry point in Sprint 14.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/CParser.h — C parser support:
  • parseC(...) and parseCWithDiagnostics(...)
  • preprocessor parsing: #include, #define (object/function-like), #pragma
  • header-guard shape recognition (#ifndef/#ifdef/#endif) into pragma-style nodes
  • C declarations: functions, structs, typedef-struct, enums (named + anonymous), top-level variables, function-pointer parameters
  • comment stripping for C line/block comments before declaration parsing
• editor/tests/step361_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. function parsing
  2. struct parsing
  3. typedef struct parsing
  4. enum parsing (named + anonymous)
  5. preprocessor directives
  6. static/extern qualifiers
  7. function-pointer parameter parsing
  8. pointer variable parsing
  9. multiple functions per file
  10. C++ parser backward compatibility
  11. C comment handling
  12. pipeline routing for "c" language + header-guard pattern

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Parser.h — include ast/CParser.h
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — add parse routing for language "c"
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step361_test target

Verification run:

• step361_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step360_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Step 362: C Generator

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a dedicated C generator and routed pipeline generation for "c". The generator emits C-oriented forms for structs, enums, typedefs, macros, includes, and method-name lowering for class-style methods.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/CGenerator.h — C generation support:
  • module emission including statements/classes/functions
  • ClassDeclaration -> typedef struct ...
  • MethodDeclaration -> ClassName_method(...) naming
  • C null literal output (NULL)
  • C preprocessor and enum/type-alias output
• editor/tests/step362_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. function generation
  2. struct output
  3. typedef output
  4. enum output
  5. preprocessor output
  6. pointer type output
  7. owner/manual annotation comment presence
  8. class-to-struct generation
  9. method-to-C function naming
  10. comment prefix
  11. string/null literal behavior
  12. pipeline "c" generation route

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Generator.h — include CGenerator.h
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — add generate routing for language "c"
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step362_test target

Verification run:

• step362_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step361_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step360_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Step 363: C Memory Annotation Mapping

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implemented C-specific memory and semantic annotation inference so C code now gets meaningful defaults and risk signals aligned with explicit-memory patterns.

Files created:

• editor/src/ProjectionAdaptation.h — extracted projection adaptation helpers:
  • C owner strategy adaptation for Rust targets (Manual -> Box, Transferred -> Moved)
  • pointer-type adaptation for Rust references (T* -> &T)

Files modified:

• editor/src/MemoryStrategyInference.h — C-specific memory inference:
  • module defaults: Owner(Manual), Lifetime(Scope), Reclaim(Explicit)
  • malloc/calloc detection: function-level owner/reclaim suggestions
  • pointer parameter inference: Owner(Borrowed)
  • pointer return inference by naming convention:
    • get*/borrow*/peek*/view* -> Owner(Borrowed)
    • otherwise -> Owner(Transferred)
  • local/static variable lifetime inference:
    • locals -> Lifetime(Scope)
    • static storage -> Lifetime(Static)
• editor/src/AnnotationInference.h — C pattern inference:
  • goto pattern -> Complexity(high) + Risk(medium)
  • unchecked array indexing -> BoundsCheck(unchecked)
  • void* usage -> Risk(high) + Ambiguity(medium)
  • header guard detection -> Synthetic(guard)
• editor/src/CrossLanguageProjector.h — uses ProjectionAdaptation helpers for ownership and pointer-type adaptation without exceeding header size limits
• editor/tests/step363_test.cpp — 12 tests covering defaults, C-specific rules, confidence bounds, header-guard synthesis, and C->Rust ownership adaptation
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step363_test target

Verification run:

• step363_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step362_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step361_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step360_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/CrossLanguageProjector.h remained under the 600-line cap after refactor by extracting target adaptation logic into editor/src/ProjectionAdaptation.h

Step 364: C Integration + Self-Hosting Prep

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Added phase-level integration coverage for the C pipeline and projection paths, including pipeline execution, C parser/generator roundtrip checks, ownership projection behavior, and MCP tool contract stability.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step364_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  1. C parse -> generate -> reparse declaration continuity
  2. C struct -> Python class-form generation
  3. Python class shape -> C struct + constructor-style method generation
  4. C manual ownership -> Rust Owner(Box) adaptation
  5. Pipeline.run(..., \"c\", \"cpp\") success path with generated output
  6. Combined C inference: malloc + pointer parameter + unchecked index access
  7. simplified dependency-style C header parsing
  8. MCP tools/list stability + run_pipeline language schema acceptance

Files modified:

• editor/src/CrossLanguageProjector.h — integration support:
  • copy classes and statements roles during projection
  • generic serialization fallback clone for unhandled declaration nodes
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step364_test target with parser-linked test deps

Verification run:

• step364_test — PASS (8/8) new step coverage
• step363_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step362_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step361_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step360_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/CrossLanguageProjector.h remains within header size limit (596 lines <= 600)

Step 365: WAT Parser

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a standalone WebAssembly text-format parser (wat/wasm) and wired it into the shared parsing pipeline.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/WatParser.h — WAT parser support:
  • parseWat(...) and parseWatWithDiagnostics(...)
  • balanced-expression scanning inside (module ...)
  • function parsing for params/results/locals
  • import/export/global/memory/table top-level mapping
  • instruction-shape mapping for i32.add, call, if, block, loop
  • line-comment stripping for ;; ...
• editor/tests/step365_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. module parsing
  2. function params/results
  3. locals
  4. exports
  5. imports
  6. globals
  7. i32.add mapping
  8. call mapping
  9. if mapping
  10. block/loop mapping
  11. empty module
  12. pipeline wat and wasm routing + type preservation

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Parser.h — include ast/WatParser.h
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — add parse routing for \"wat\" and \"wasm\"
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step365_test target

Verification run:

• step365_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step364_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step363_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/WatParser.h is within header size limit (231 lines)

Step 366: WAT Generator

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a dedicated WAT generator and integrated wat/wasm generation routing in the shared pipeline.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/WatGenerator.h — WAT generation support:
  • module emission in s-expression format
  • function emission with (param ...) / (result ...)
  • primitive type mapping to WAT types (i32, i64, f32, f64)
  • instruction emission for arithmetic, calls, if/else, and block constructs
  • import emission and pragma-driven memory/table/export output
  • annotation comment output using WAT prefix (;; )
• editor/tests/step366_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. function generation
  2. module s-expression formatting
  3. type mapping
  4. arithmetic lowering to stack ops
  5. if/else output
  6. function call output
  7. export output
  8. import output
  9. annotation comment prefix
  10. Python -> WAT pipeline route
  11. parse->generate->parse roundtrip
  12. balanced parentheses invariant

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Generator.h — include WatGenerator.h
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — add generate routing for \"wat\" and \"wasm\"
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step366_test target

Verification run:

• step366_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step365_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step364_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step363_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/WatGenerator.h is within header size limit (219 lines)

Step 367: WAT Annotation Mapping

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implemented WAT-specific annotation inference for execution model, linkage, and memory-layout signals, plus WAT memory-strategy defaults.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step367_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. function -> Exec(stack)
  2. memory operations -> Owner(Manual)
  3. export -> Visibility(public)
  4. import -> Link(import)
  5. WAT defaults (Owner(Manual), Reclaim(Explicit))
  6. table dispatch -> Shim(vtable)
  7. memory declaration -> Align + Layout(linear)
  8. confidence bounds
  9. annotation preservation through projection to C
  10. Semanno emit/parse roundtrip
  11. pipeline parse + inference integration
  12. WAT -> C -> WAT annotation roundtrip preservation

Files modified:

• editor/src/MemoryStrategyInference.h — WAT defaults and memory-op rule:
  • module defaults for wat/wasm
  • function memory-op detection (memory.*, *.load, *.store)
• editor/src/AnnotationInference.h — WAT-specific pattern inference:
  • function-level Exec(stack)
  • import/export mapping to Link/Visibility
  • table mapping to Shim(vtable)
  • memory mapping to Align + Layout(linear)
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step367_test target

Verification run:

• step367_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step366_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step365_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step364_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/AnnotationInference.h remains within header size limit (589 lines <= 600)

Step 368: WAT Cross-Language Projection

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added cross-language WAT projection coverage across pipeline and direct projection paths (Python/C/Rust/Java), including annotation and metadata preservation checks.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step368_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. Python -> WAT
  2. C -> WAT
  3. WAT -> Python
  4. WAT -> C
  5. WAT -> Rust
  6. Java -> WAT
  7. Python -> WAT -> Python identity check
  8. WAT <-> C annotation preservation
  9. import metadata preservation through projection
  10. multi-function WAT -> C output generation
  11. Semanno roundtrip on projected annotation data
  12. WAT-source pipeline run success

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step368_test target

Verification run:

• step368_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step367_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step366_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/tests/step368_test.cpp remains within project file-size guidance for test artifacts (162 lines)

Step 369: Phase 14b Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Added phase-level integration validation for WAT as both source and target, including compact AST coverage, malformed-source diagnostics, sidecar persistence, and MCP contract checks.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step369_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  1. parse WAT -> generate WAT validity
  2. C -> WAT -> C roundtrip path
  3. broad multi-language -> WAT pipeline targeting coverage
  4. WAT annotation completeness checks
  5. compact AST node coverage on WAT module
  6. malformed WAT diagnostic detection
  7. Semanno sidecar save/load on .wat path
  8. MCP whetstone_run_pipeline language-parameter compatibility

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/WatParser.h — parseWatWithDiagnostics(...) now reports:
  • unmatched/unbalanced parenthesis errors
  • missing module-form warning
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step369_test target

Verification run:

• step369_test — PASS (8/8) new step coverage
• step368_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step367_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step366_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/WatParser.h remains within header-size limit after diagnostic additions (248 lines <= 600)

Step 370: Common Lisp Parser

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a dedicated Common Lisp parser with S-expression parsing and direct mapping for core CL forms into the Whetstone AST, including CLOS and macro surface forms.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/CommonLispParser.h — Common Lisp parse support:
  • recursive S-expression reader with comment/string handling
  • top-level form conversion for defun, defmethod, defclass, defvar/defparameter, and defmacro
  • expression conversion for if, cond, let, lambda, loop forms, funcall/apply, quote, and values
  • convention handling for package-qualified symbols and *earmuff* dynamic-variable detection
  • (declare (type ...)) mapping to parameter type nodes
• editor/tests/step370_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. defun parsing
  2. defclass parsing
  3. lambda parsing
  4. let binding/scope mapping
  5. if/cond mapping
  6. loop/do/dotimes mapping
  7. defmacro mapping
  8. quote shorthand and @Meta(quoted) annotation mapping
  9. dynamic *earmuff* variable annotation
  10. deep nested S-expression parsing
  11. mixed top-level definitions in one source
  12. CLOS method parsing + pipeline language alias routing

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Parser.h — include ast/CommonLispParser.h
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — add parse routing for \"common-lisp\", \"commonlisp\", \"lisp\", and \"cl\"
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step370_test target

Verification run:

• step370_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step369_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step365_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/CommonLispParser.h is within header size limit (598 lines <= 600)

Step 371: Common Lisp Generator

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a dedicated Common Lisp generator and integrated target-language routing for Common Lisp aliases in the pipeline.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/CommonLispGenerator.h — Common Lisp generation support:
  • module/function emission as idiomatic S-expressions
  • defclass + defmethod output for CLOS class/method projection
  • typed parameter declarations via (declare (type ...))
  • let emission from block-scoped variable statements
  • macro emission via defmacro
  • function-level exception annotation mapping to handler-case wrappers
  • comment prefix alignment (;; ) with explicit owner annotation formatting
• editor/tests/step371_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. defun generation
  2. defclass output
  3. lambda output
  4. let binding emission
  5. S-expression shape / balanced output
  6. typed declare emission
  7. Python -> Common Lisp pipeline route
  8. Java -> Common Lisp pipeline route
  9. Semanno comment prefix (;;)
  10. parse -> generate -> parse roundtrip
  11. CLOS method dispatch output
  12. condition-system wrapper from exception annotation

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Generator.h — include CommonLispGenerator.h
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — add generate routing for \"common-lisp\", \"commonlisp\", \"lisp\", and \"cl\"
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step371_test target

Verification run:

• step371_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step370_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step369_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step366_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/CommonLispGenerator.h remains within header-size limit (267 lines <= 600)

Step 372: Lisp Annotation Mapping

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added Lisp-focused annotation inference coverage for macros, dynamic bindings, multi-value contracts, method dispatch signals, and optimize/declaration forms, plus Common Lisp memory-strategy defaults.

Files created:

• editor/src/AnnotationInferenceLisp.h — extracted Lisp-specific inference helpers:
  • macro inference (Meta(quoted) + Synthetic(macro))
  • dynamic vs lexical binding inference (Binding(dynamic|static))
  • CL form pattern checks for values, declare(type ...), and optimize
  • CLOS method synthetic hint inference
• editor/tests/step372_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. macro -> Meta(quoted)
  2. dynamic variable -> Binding(dynamic)
  3. values -> multi-value Contract
  4. tail-recursive function -> TailCall
  5. CLOS class -> Visibility(public)
  6. optimize declaration -> Policy(perf=critical, style=literal)
  7. Common Lisp GC defaults (Reclaim(Tracing), Owner(Shared_GC))
  8. confidence bounds and strong signals
  9. Binding(dynamic) preservation through CL -> Python projection
  10. Binding(dynamic) preservation through CL -> C++ projection
  11. declare(type ...) -> Complexity(declared-type)
  12. method synthetic hint for CLOS dispatch

Files modified:

• editor/src/AnnotationInference.h — integrate Lisp inference hooks while preserving architecture line limits
• editor/src/MemoryStrategyInference.h — add Common Lisp module defaults for GC
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step372_test target

Verification run:

• step372_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step371_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step370_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step369_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step367_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/AnnotationInference.h remains within header-size limit (599 lines <= 600)
• editor/src/MemoryStrategyInference.h remains within header-size limit (384 lines <= 600)

Step 373: Common Lisp Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Added phase-level integration validation for Common Lisp parse/generate roundtrips, cross-language projection paths, inference integration, and CL artifact compatibility with Semanno and compact AST tooling.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step373_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  1. Common Lisp parse -> generate -> parse roundtrip shape
  2. Python class -> Common Lisp CLOS generation path
  3. Common Lisp defclass retained through Python projection
  4. Common Lisp class hierarchy retained through Java projection
  5. Common Lisp annotation inference integration (macro/dynamic/tail-call)
  6. Semanno sidecar save/load roundtrip on .lisp path
  7. Pipeline.run() success with Common Lisp source
  8. compact AST node naming on Common Lisp module

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step373_test target

Verification run:

• step373_test — PASS (8/8) new step coverage
• step372_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step371_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step370_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step369_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/tests/step373_test.cpp remains within project file-size guidance for test artifacts (147 lines)

Step 374: Scheme Parser

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a dedicated Scheme parser with S-expression parsing and Scheme-specific form mapping into the Whetstone AST, including continuation and hygienic macro signals.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/SchemeParser.h — Scheme parse support:
  • recursive S-expression reader with Scheme comment and quote handling
  • top-level mapping for define (function/value) and define-syntax
  • expression mapping for lambda, let/let*/letrec, if, cond, do, begin, call-with-current-continuation/call/cc, quote, and values
  • continuation call mapping with Exec(mode=continuation) annotation
  • define-syntax mapping to MacroDefinition with hygienic Meta signal
• editor/tests/step374_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. define function parsing
  2. define variable parsing
  3. lambda parsing
  4. let variants mapping
  5. if/cond mapping
  6. do loop mapping
  7. call/cc continuation annotation mapping
  8. define-syntax hygienic macro mapping
  9. values contract mapping
  10. begin sequence mapping
  11. deep nesting parsing
  12. mixed forms + pipeline scheme/scm routing + malformed diagnostics

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Parser.h — include ast/SchemeParser.h
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — add parse routing for \"scheme\" and \"scm\"
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step374_test target

Verification run:

• step374_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step373_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step372_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step371_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step370_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/SchemeParser.h is within header size limit (461 lines <= 600)

Step 375: Scheme Generator

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a dedicated Scheme generator and pipeline generation routing for Scheme targets, with Scheme-specific output conventions and continuation/tail-call annotation handling.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/SchemeGenerator.h — Scheme generation support:
  • module/function/variable emission using define forms
  • Scheme-flavored block lowering (let / begin)
  • boolean/null mapping to #t, #f, and '()
  • continuation-aware call lowering to call/cc
  • record-style class projection output (define-record-type)
  • Scheme semanno comment output for owner/tail-call/exec annotations
• editor/tests/step375_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. define-function generation
  2. lambda output
  3. let binding output
  4. boolean mapping
  5. S-expression balance/formatting
  6. Python -> Scheme pipeline route
  7. Common Lisp -> Scheme pipeline route
  8. Scheme -> Python pipeline route
  9. semanno comment prefix behavior
  10. parse -> generate -> parse roundtrip
  11. tail-call annotation preservation in output
  12. continuation annotation mapping to call/cc

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Generator.h — include SchemeGenerator.h
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — add generate routing for \"scheme\" and \"scm\"
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step375_test target

Verification run:

• step375_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step374_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step373_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step372_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step371_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/SchemeGenerator.h is within header size limit (159 lines <= 600)

Step 376: Scheme-Specific Annotations + CL Differentiation

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added Scheme-specific inference signals and explicit Common Lisp vs Scheme differentiation rules in annotation inference, plus Scheme memory defaults in memory-strategy inference.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step376_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. Scheme tail recursion -> TailCall
  2. call/cc -> Exec(continuation)
  3. define-syntax -> Meta(hygienic)
  4. CL -> Scheme projection path
  5. Scheme -> CL projection path
  6. GC defaults for both Scheme and CL
  7. differentiated macro meta states (quoted vs hygienic)
  8. differentiated binding states (dynamic vs parameter)
  9. differentiated exception styles (condition vs guard)
  10. Scheme/CL annotation fidelity through projection
  11. tail-recursive loop idiom signal (Loop(tail-recursive))
  12. confidence bound checks

Files modified:

• editor/src/AnnotationInferenceLisp.h — add Lisp/Scheme-specific inference:
  • continuation detection (call/cc, call-with-current-continuation)
  • parameter-binding detection (make-parameter)
  • condition-vs-guard exception style differentiation
  • tail-recursive loop signal (LoopAnnotation: tail-recursive)
  • macro meta-state differentiation via existing hygienic/quoted metadata
• editor/src/MemoryStrategyInference.h — add Scheme defaults:
  • include scheme/scm in tracing-GC defaults
  • shared GC ownership default for Lisp-family modules
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step376_test target

Verification run:

• step376_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step375_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step374_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step373_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step372_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/AnnotationInference.h remains within header-size limit (599 lines <= 600)
• editor/src/MemoryStrategyInference.h remains within header-size limit (384 lines <= 600)
• editor/src/AnnotationInferenceLisp.h remains within header-size guidance (129 lines)

Step 377: Phase 14d Integration + Sprint 14 Summary

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Completed phase-level integration validation for Scheme and finalized Sprint 14 with cross-language interoperability checks across C, WAT, Common Lisp, and Scheme.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step377_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  1. all 14 language parse/generate route smoke checks
  2. C <-> WAT <-> Common Lisp <-> Scheme projection matrix
  3. Lisp-source -> WAT generation path
  4. C -> Common Lisp memory-default translation validation
  5. Semanno comment-prefix correctness across the 4 new languages
  6. language-appropriate annotation defaults across the 4 new languages
  7. Pipeline.run() success with each of the 4 new languages as source
  8. Sprint 14 route/matrix totals sanity checks

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step377_test target

Verification run:

• step377_test — PASS (8/8) new step coverage
• step376_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step375_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step374_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step373_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Sprint 14 completion snapshot (Steps 361-377):

• Phase 14a (C): complete
• Phase 14b (WAT): complete
• Phase 14c (Common Lisp): complete
• Phase 14d (Scheme): complete
• Sprint 14 integration: complete

Architecture gate check:

• editor/tests/step377_test.cpp remains within project file-size guidance for test artifacts (188 lines)

Step 378: Orchestrator Core Main Loop

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implemented Sprint 15 orchestration-loop core as a dedicated workflow engine that advances ready work items through routing, context assembly, execution, review, completion, and blocker reporting.

Files created:

• editor/src/WorkflowOrchestrator.h — orchestration core:
  • step() (advance one ready item one stage-set)
  • advance() (advance all currently ready items)
  • runToCompletion() (progress until no further non-blocked progress)
  • runUntil(predicate) (predicate-controlled progression)
  • getBlockers() with typed blockers: needs-human, needs-review, needs-external-model
  • event stream via OrchestratorEvent (routed, context-assembled, executed, auto-approved, sent-to-review, completed, blocked)
• editor/tests/step378_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. single deterministic/template completion in one step
  2. dependency cascade promotion
  3. human-task blocker classification
  4. agent-task external-model blocker classification
  5. runToCompletion() deterministic completion behavior
  6. stage event emission coverage
  7. review blocker reporting
  8. empty-workflow no-op behavior
  9. mixed workflow partial progress behavior
  10. runUntil(...) predicate stop behavior
  11. blocked-event detail payload includes blockers
  12. agent context payload preservation

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step378_test target

Verification run:

• step378_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step377_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step376_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step375_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step331_test — PASS (8/8) orchestration-foundation regression

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/WorkflowOrchestrator.h is within header size limit (231 lines <= 600)

Step 379: Parallel Dispatch + Batching

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Extended the orchestration engine with explicit batch advancement, shared project-context reuse, and batch-level progress accounting.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step379_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. independent tasks advancing in one batch
  2. shared project-context token savings
  3. blocked item accounting in batch results
  4. dependency waiting behavior in batch mode
  5. priority ordering in batch event stream
  6. empty-batch behavior
  7. single-item batch behavior
  8. mixed independent/dependent behavior
  9. advance() compatibility over batched events
  10. shared-context event marker emission
  11. review-path handling in batch mode
  12. runToCompletion() stop on blockers

Files modified:

• editor/src/WorkflowOrchestrator.h — add batch orchestration support:
  • BatchResult struct (events, itemsAdvanced, itemsBlocked, contextTokensSaved)
  • advanceBatch() for multi-item ready-queue advancement
  • shared project-context reuse path with token-savings accounting
  • advance() now returns advanceBatch().events for API continuity
  • event detail now indicates shared project-context reuse
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step379_test target

Verification run:

• step379_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step378_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step377_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step331_test — PASS (8/8) workflow-foundation regression
• step325_test — PASS (8/8) workflow-state regression

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/WorkflowOrchestrator.h remains within header-size limit (284 lines <= 600)

Step 380: Feedback Loop — Rejection Re-Routing

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implemented rejection-aware rerouting in the orchestration loop with attempt-history preservation, stepwise escalation, and feedback-aware context assembly for re-attempts.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step380_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. review rejection re-enters ready queue
  2. rejection feedback appears in next worker context bundle
  3. first escalation template/deterministic -> slm
  4. second escalation slm -> llm
  5. third escalation llm -> human
  6. rejection history metadata preservation
  7. multi-rejection accumulation
  8. reviewer feedback-hints (context=..., worker=...) applied
  9. context widening after rejection
  10. no escalation-level skipping across repeated rejections
  11. human rejection remains human-routed
  12. rejection count tracking + reject-state guard

Files modified:

• editor/src/WorkItem.h — add RejectionAttempt history on WorkItem, add first-class rejectionFeedback field, and JSON serialization/deserialization support for both
• editor/src/RoutingEngine.h — add routeWithHistory(...) and stepwise escalateWorker(...) policy that advances one level per rejection (template/deterministic -> slm -> llm -> human) without skipping
• editor/src/WorkflowOrchestrator.h — add rejectAndRequeue(...), preserve attempt metadata, apply reviewer feedback hints, and route with rejection history
• editor/src/ContextAssembler.h — include first-class rejection feedback in WorkerContext.feedbackFromRejection (with backward-compatible fallback)
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step380_test target

Verification run:

• step380_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step379_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step378_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/WorkflowOrchestrator.h within header-size limit (324 <= 600)
• editor/src/RoutingEngine.h within header-size limit (242 <= 600)
• editor/src/WorkItem.h within header-size limit (260 <= 600)
• editor/src/ContextAssembler.h within header-size limit (192 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step380_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (281 lines)

Step 381: Progress Tracking + ETA

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implemented a standalone workflow-progress tracker that consumes orchestrator events and produces progress snapshots with completion %, throughput, ETA, worker metrics, blockers, and timeline entries.

Files created:

• editor/src/WorkflowProgress.h — progress aggregation API:
  • WorkflowProgress::recordEvent(...)
  • WorkflowProgress::getSnapshot()
  • WorkflowProgress::getTimeline()
  • WorkflowProgress::getWorkerStats()
  • ProgressSnapshot, WorkerStats, TimelineEntry with JSON serialization
• editor/tests/step381_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. completion-percent accuracy
  2. throughput (itemsPerMinute) calculation
  3. ETA bound sanity for uniform completion cadence
  4. per-worker metric aggregation
  5. rejection-rate tracking
  6. timeline event recording
  7. empty-workflow snapshot behavior
  8. blocker propagation into snapshots
  9. snapshot JSON field coverage
  10. completion monotonicity across rejection events
  11. startedAt/lastActivityAt tracking
  12. total-item fallback via observed item IDs

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step381_test target

Verification run:

• step381_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step380_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step379_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/WorkflowProgress.h within header-size limit (303 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step381_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (196 lines)

Step 382: Orchestrator RPC + MCP

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added orchestrator control RPC methods and MCP tool bindings so a client can step/advance workflows, run deterministic items, inspect blockers/progress, and submit external model output back into the workflow loop.

Files created:

• editor/src/HeadlessOrchestratorRPC.h — extracted orchestrator RPC handling:
  • orchestrateStep
  • orchestrateAdvance
  • orchestrateRunDeterministic
  • getBlockers
  • getProgress
  • submitExternalResult
  • event/blocker JSON serialization helpers and buffer-context collection
• editor/tests/step382_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. orchestrateStep advances one task
  2. orchestrateAdvance processes batch
  3. orchestrateRunDeterministic stops at blockers
  4. getBlockers reports human blockers
  5. getProgress snapshot shape
  6. submitExternalResult accepts LLM output and advances lifecycle
  7. Linter role can read progress but cannot orchestrate
  8. MCP tool registration for all 6 orchestrator tools
  9. MCP whetstone_orchestrate_run_deterministic callback wiring
  10. combined deterministic + external-submit + progress flow
  11. submit-result worker-type guard
  12. no-workflow guard behavior

Files modified:

• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — delegated orchestrator-method handling to tryHandleHeadlessOrchestratorRPC(...)
• editor/src/HeadlessEditorState.h — add workflowProgress state
• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — permissions for new orchestrator methods (getProgress/getBlockers read-only, orchestration/submit methods write)
• editor/src/MCPServer.h — register orchestrator MCP tools:
  • whetstone_orchestrate_step
  • whetstone_orchestrate_advance
  • whetstone_orchestrate_run_deterministic
  • whetstone_get_blockers
  • whetstone_get_progress
  • whetstone_submit_result
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step382_test target

Verification run:

• step382_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step381_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step380_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step379_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/HeadlessOrchestratorRPC.h within header-size limit (287 <= 600)
• editor/src/WorkflowProgress.h within header-size limit (303 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step382_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (250 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers remain and should be split in follow-up:
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2623 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1652 > 600)

Step 383: Phase 15a Integration Tests

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Added end-to-end integration validation for Sprint 15a orchestration behavior: mixed deterministic/agent/human flows, dependency gating, rejection escalation, shared-context optimization, progress tracking, external-result submission, and MCP orchestration tool loop closure.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step383_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  1. mixed 5-item workflow partial deterministic completion profile
  2. dependency-chain progression constraints
  3. rejection escalation through deterministic -> slm -> llm
  4. shared project-context token-savings path
  5. progress snapshot updates during orchestration
  6. submitExternalResult completion path for agent-prepared task
  7. blocker-category surfacing (needs-human, needs-external-model)
  8. MCP end-to-end loop (run_deterministic -> submit_result -> get_progress)

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step383_test target

Verification run:

• step383_test — PASS (8/8) new integration coverage
• step382_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step381_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step380_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Sprint 15a completion snapshot (Steps 378-383):

• Step 378: orchestrator core loop
• Step 379: batching + shared-context optimization
• Step 380: rejection rerouting feedback loop
• Step 381: progress/ETA tracking
• Step 382: orchestrator RPC + MCP tools
• Step 383: phase integration coverage

Architecture gate check (end of Sprint 15a):

• editor/tests/step383_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (222 lines)
• editor/src/HeadlessOrchestratorRPC.h within header-size limit (287 <= 600)
• editor/src/WorkflowProgress.h within header-size limit (303 <= 600)
• Legacy oversized headers persist and need planned split before Sprint 15b+:
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2623 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1652 > 600)

Step 384: Workflow Session Protocol

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implemented a formal MCP workflow-session protocol model with explicit phases, transition validation, command-history tracking, workflow-state phase inference, and next-action guidance for clients.

Files created:

• editor/src/WorkflowProtocol.h — protocol model:
  • WorkflowSession (session metadata + command history)
  • ProtocolAction (phase + suggested command + reason)
  • phase helpers: workflowProtocolPhases, validateTransition, protocolPhaseForCommand, recordWorkflowCommand
  • workflow-aware helpers: detectProtocolPhaseFromWorkflow, getNextAction, getSessionSummary
• editor/tests/step384_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. phase-order transition validity
  2. invalid transition rejection
  3. per-phase next-action suggestions
  4. command-history tracking
  5. session-summary accuracy
  6. complete-phase auto-detection from workflow
  7. assist-phase auto-detection from workflow
  8. session JSON roundtrip persistence
  9. empty-project plan behavior
  10. unknown-phase guards
  11. monotonic phase advancement via command recording
  12. workflow-aware next-action override

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step384_test target

Verification run:

• step384_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step383_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step382_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/WorkflowProtocol.h within header-size limit (185 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step384_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (177 lines)

Step 385: Context Bundle Format

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Standardized the external-model context contract with a structured bundle, prompt rendering, JSON transport format, and token estimation utilities.

Files created:

• editor/src/ContextBundle.h — context bundle model:
  • ContextBundle + AttemptSummary
  • buildBundle(workItem, workerContext, routingDecision)
  • bundleToPrompt(bundle) (model-agnostic prompt rendering)
  • bundleToJson(bundle) / ContextBundle::fromJson(...)
  • estimateBundleTokens(bundle)
• editor/tests/step385_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. required bundle field population
  2. prompt structure readability
  3. rejection-history inclusion
  4. token-estimate reasonableness
  5. routing budget propagation
  6. annotation-constraint extraction
  7. intent propagation
  8. empty-field handling
  9. JSON roundtrip
  10. model-agnostic prompt format
  11. output-format policy (code-only vs code-with-explanation)
  12. previous-attempt ordering

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step385_test target

Verification run:

• step385_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step384_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step383_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ContextBundle.h within header-size limit (168 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step385_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (192 lines)

Step 386: Result Acceptance Protocol

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a standardized acceptance pipeline for external model submissions: syntax/annotation validation, diagnostic accounting, review-gate decisioning, structured acceptance output, dependency cascade on acceptance, and requeue on validation failure.

Files created:

• editor/src/ResultAcceptance.h — acceptance primitives:
  • ResultSubmission
  • ResultAcceptance
  • validateSuggestedAnnotations(...)
  • evaluateResultSubmission(...)
• editor/tests/step386_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. valid code acceptance
  2. syntax rejection with feedback
  3. malformed suggested-annotation rejection
  4. diagnostics preventing auto-approval
  5. low-confidence review path
  6. suggested-annotation payload carry-through
  7. aggregated diagnostic counts across validation stages
  8. partial acceptance (valid + review required)
  9. multiple-submission latest-wins behavior
  10. dependency cascade on acceptance
  11. acceptance payload in RPC response
  12. non-agent worker submission guard

Files modified:

• editor/src/HeadlessOrchestratorRPC.h — submitExternalResult now uses evaluateResultSubmission(...), emits acceptance metadata, supports review resubmission, and requeues invalid submissions with validator feedback
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step386_test target

Verification run:

• step386_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step385_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step384_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ResultAcceptance.h within header-size limit (125 <= 600)
• editor/src/HeadlessOrchestratorRPC.h within header-size limit (309 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step386_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (269 lines)

Step 387: Orchestrator Event Stream

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a versioned event stream for orchestration telemetry and exposed polling APIs through RPC + MCP for client-side visualization and progress UIs.

Files created:

• editor/src/EventStream.h — versioned stream:
  • emit(OrchestratorEvent)
  • poll(sinceVersion)
  • subscribe(callback)
  • getVersion()
  • getRecent(count)
  • stream-event JSON serialization
• editor/tests/step387_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. emit/poll baseline
  2. since-version filtering
  3. version tracking
  4. subscriber callback firing
  5. normalized orchestration event-type emission
  6. recent-event ordering/count
  7. empty stream behavior
  8. no-duplicate polling under frequent reads
  9. event JSON structure
  10. MCP event-stream tool registration
  11. getEventStream since-version behavior
  12. getRecentEvents count behavior

Files modified:

• editor/src/HeadlessEditorState.h — add EventStream eventStream
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — emit workflow.created event on workflow init
• editor/src/HeadlessOrchestratorRPC.h — event emission mapping and new RPC methods:
  • getEventStream
  • getRecentEvents
  • mapped event names (task.*, workflow.*) and workflow.progress/complete emission
• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — read permissions for getEventStream / getRecentEvents
• editor/src/MCPServer.h — MCP tools:
  • whetstone_get_event_stream
  • whetstone_get_recent_events
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step387_test target

Verification run:

• step387_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step386_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step382_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/EventStream.h within header-size limit (68 <= 600)
• editor/src/HeadlessOrchestratorRPC.h within header-size limit (374 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step387_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (204 lines)
• Legacy oversized header persists:
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)

Step 388: Phase 15b Integration — Full Protocol Test

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Added end-to-end protocol integration coverage connecting session protocol, orchestrator/event-stream RPC, context bundles, acceptance pipeline, and progress tracking into one executable workflow path.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step388_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  1. full protocol walkthrough to completion
  2. event stream transition capture
  3. context bundle core-field integrity
  4. acceptance behavior by worker type (deterministic vs llm)
  5. rejection -> reroute -> improved submission -> acceptance
  6. progress snapshot monotonic advancement
  7. getNextAction protocol guidance
  8. workflow-session persistence/resume

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step388_test target

Verification run:

• step388_test — PASS (8/8) new integration coverage
• step387_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step386_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step385_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Phase 15b completion snapshot (Steps 384-388):

• Step 384: workflow session protocol
• Step 385: context bundle format
• Step 386: result acceptance protocol
• Step 387: orchestrator event stream + RPC/MCP exposure
• Step 388: full protocol integration

Architecture gate check (end of Phase 15b):

• editor/tests/step388_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (224 lines)
• editor/src/WorkflowProtocol.h within header-size limit (185 <= 600)
• editor/src/ContextBundle.h within header-size limit (168 <= 600)
• editor/src/ResultAcceptance.h within header-size limit (125 <= 600)
• editor/src/EventStream.h within header-size limit (68 <= 600)
• editor/src/HeadlessOrchestratorRPC.h within header-size limit (374 <= 600)
• Legacy oversized header persists:
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)

Phase 15c: Advanced Routing + Optimization

Step 389: Routing Rules Engine

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Configurable, composable routing rules engine. Rules have conditions (AND-combined) and actions. First matching rule wins. Default rules encode same logic as the hardcoded RoutingEngine cascade.

Files created:

• editor/src/RoutingRules.h — RuleCondition, RoutingAction, RoutingRule structs; RulesEngine class with addRule, evaluate, getDefaultRules, loadRules/saveRules; 7 condition types: annotation, complexity, contextWidth, nodeType, rejectionCount, language, pattern
• editor/tests/step389_test.cpp — 12 tests covering first-match wins, AND conditions, annotation match, complexity threshold, pattern matching, defaults, custom override, fallthrough, priority ordering, JSON persistence, budget multiplier, rejection escalation

Step 390: Cost Estimation + Optimization

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Token cost estimation and optimization suggestions before executing a workflow. Estimates context/output tokens per worker type with rough USD cost projection.

Files created:

• editor/src/CostEstimator.h — OptimizationSuggestion, CostEstimate structs; CostEstimator class with estimate() and suggest(); collectAllItems() helper; 3 suggestion types: use-template, narrow-context, batch
• editor/tests/step390_test.cpp — 12 tests covering token counts, deterministic zero cost, suggestions, getter detection, context narrowing, batching, empty workflow, large workflow, JSON serialization, worker breakdown, completed exclusion, cost proportionality

Step 391: Workflow Templates

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

5 pre-built workflow templates for common project patterns. Each creates a populated WorkflowState with work items, routing hints, and dependencies.

Files created:

• editor/src/WorkflowTemplates.h — TemplateInfo, TemplateParams structs; WorkflowTemplates class with getTemplates(), applyTemplate(), isValidTemplate(); Templates: crud-api, module-refactor, cross-language-port, test-suite, legacy-modernization
• editor/tests/step391_test.cpp — 12 tests covering template count, CRUD skeleton, cross-language routing, param validation, test generation, valid WorkflowState, refactor template, descriptions, default params, modernization, dependencies, function count defaults

Step 392: Dependency Graph Data

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Export workflow dependency graph as structured data for Sprint 19's GUI visualization. Computes critical path (longest dependency chain).

Files created:

• editor/src/DependencyGraph.h — GraphNode, GraphEdge, GraphData structs; buildDependencyGraph(), graphToJson(), getCriticalPath() functions
• editor/tests/step392_test.cpp — 12 tests covering node count, edge matching, critical path, status match, worker type, JSON serialization, empty graph, single node, diamond dependencies, update after completion, labels, 5-chain path

Step 393: Phase 15c Integration + Sprint 15 Summary

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

End-to-end Sprint 15c validation connecting routing rules, cost estimation, workflow templates, dependency graph, event stream, and protocol phases.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step393_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  1. custom routing rules override
  2. cost estimation with optimization suggestions for 10-function workflow
  3. CRUD template → route → deterministic execution
  4. dependency graph 5-function chain critical path
  5. event stream captures workflow transitions
  6. full protocol phase validation
  7. optimization reduces cost (narrow context)
  8. Sprint 15 totals verification

Sprint 15 completion snapshot (Steps 378-393):

• Phase 15a (378-383): Orchestrator core, parallel dispatch, feedback, progress, RPC
• Phase 15b (384-388): MCP protocol, context bundles, result acceptance, event stream
• Phase 15c (389-393): Rules engine, cost estimation, templates, dependency graph

Sprint 15 totals:

• Steps: 16 (378-393)
• Tests: ~180 (68 + 56 + 56)
• New headers: 9 (Orchestrator, WorkflowProgress, WorkflowProtocol, ContextBundle, EventStream, RoutingRules, CostEstimator, WorkflowTemplates, DependencyGraph)

Architecture gate check (end of Sprint 15):

• editor/src/RoutingRules.h within header-size limit (276 <= 600)
• editor/src/CostEstimator.h within header-size limit (227 <= 600)
• editor/src/WorkflowTemplates.h within header-size limit (220 <= 600)
• editor/src/DependencyGraph.h within header-size limit (175 <= 600)
• Legacy oversized header persists:
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)

Sprint 16 Progress — C++ Depth + Self-Hosting Phase 1

Phase 16a: C++ Type System Depth

Step 394: TypeAlias + Nested Type Access

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Verified TypeAlias parsing (using/typedef), nested qualified names (Foo::Bar::Baz), and CppQualifiers detection helpers.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/CppAdvancedNodes.h — CppQualifiers struct (const/constexpr/static/mutable/ smartPointerKind), AutoType node, CastExpression node, detection helpers (detectSmartPointerKind, extractSmartPointerInner, detectQualifiers, isAutoType, isConstMethod, detectCastKind, smartPointerOwnership, castRiskLevel)
• editor/tests/step394_test.cpp — 12 tests covering using/typedef parsing, nested types, construction, multiple aliases, generator format, qualified names, namespaces, span tracking, template targets, pointer typedefs, qualifier detection

Step 395: Static Members + Const/Constexpr

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Tests for const, constexpr, static, and mutable qualifier detection on methods, variables, and class members. MethodDeclaration already supports isStatic/isVirtual/ isOverride flags.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step395_test.cpp — 12 tests covering const/constexpr/static detection, trailing const methods, static method parsing, virtual/override, CppQualifiers JSON roundtrip, field declarations, combined qualifiers, mutable detection

Step 396: Smart Pointer Patterns

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Recognition of unique_ptr/shared_ptr/weak_ptr, inner type extraction, ownership annotation mapping (Unique/Shared_ARC/Weak), and cross-language projection concept.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step396_test.cpp — 12 tests covering detection of each smart pointer type, inner type extraction, ownership mapping, parser integration with smart pointer params/returns, no false positives, make_unique, cross-language mapping, new/delete expressions

Step 397: Auto Type Deduction

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

AutoType AST node for deferred type resolution. Parser handles auto, auto*, auto&, const auto&, trailing return types, and C++20 abbreviated templates.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step397_test.cpp — 12 tests covering AutoType construction, modifiers, isAutoType detection, auto return types, auto variables, auto pointers, const auto refs, trailing return types, auto parameters, span tracking

Step 398: Cast Expressions

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

CastExpression AST node with castKind (static/dynamic/reinterpret/const), targetType, and operand child. Risk level annotations: reinterpret_cast=high, dynamic/const=medium, static=low.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step398_test.cpp — 12 tests covering construction, detection of all 4 cast kinds, risk levels, parser integration with cast expressions, operand children, multiple casts, span tracking, risk annotation mapping

Step 399: Phase 16a Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

End-to-end Phase 16a validation combining all new C++ constructs.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step399_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  1. Parse Whetstone-style header with type alias, class, smart pointers
  2. Roundtrip parse → generate → parse
  3. Qualifier detection on mixed code
  4. Smart pointer ownership mapping
  5. Cast risk assessment
  6. Auto type detection
  7. Complex class with static/virtual/const methods
  8. Pipeline integration (C++ parse + infer + validate + generate)

Phase 16a completion snapshot (Steps 394-399):

• Step 394: TypeAlias + nested type access (12 tests)
• Step 395: Static/const/constexpr qualifiers (12 tests)
• Step 396: Smart pointer patterns (12 tests)
• Step 397: Auto type deduction (12 tests)
• Step 398: Cast expressions (12 tests)
• Step 399: Phase 16a integration (8 tests)

Architecture gate check (end of Phase 16a):

• editor/src/ast/CppAdvancedNodes.h within header-size limit (156 <= 600)
• Legacy oversized header persists:
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)

Phase 16b: Self-Hosting Phase 1

Step 400: Self-Hosting Test Harness

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a reusable self-hosting harness for parsing real project headers, checking expected structure, and reporting construct coverage with opaque tracking for graceful degradation.

Files created:

• editor/src/SelfHostHarness.h — parseFile/parseSource helpers, expected structure checks, coverage tracking, coverage report output
• editor/tests/step400_test.cpp — 12 tests for parsing, coverage accounting, graceful degradation, and report formatting

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step400_test target

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SelfHostHarness.h within header-size limit (308 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step400_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (256 lines)

Step 401: Parse AnnotationConflictExtended.h

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Validated self-hosting against a real project header (AnnotationConflictExtended.h): struct and free-function capture, parameter/body extraction, field-name fidelity, coverage reporting, and graceful degradation on missing expected constructs.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step401_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. parse real header file from disk
  2. CrossTypeConflict struct capture
  3. collectCrossTypeConflicts signature capture
  4. expected-structure 100% coverage
  5. struct field count
  6. struct field-name preservation
  7. function parameter extraction
  8. function body presence
  9. coverage report content checks
  10. lambda-heavy header pattern parse stability
  11. STL-heavy type pattern parse stability
  12. graceful degradation via opaque coverage accounting

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step401_test target

Verification run:

• step401_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step400_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step399_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/tests/step401_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (231 lines)
• editor/src/SelfHostHarness.h remains within header-size limit (308 <= 600)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2623 > 600)

Step 402: Parse AnnotationValidatorExtended.h

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Validated self-hosting parse coverage for a class-heavy production header (AnnotationValidatorExtended.h): class/method extraction, static helper method recognition, validator-style cast-pattern helper checks, complexity inference on parsed AST, and graceful degradation accounting.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step402_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. parse real header file from disk
  2. AnnotationValidatorExtended class capture
  3. class method extraction
  4. public validate signature capture
  5. private helper method capture (validateNode, validateAnnotation)
  6. static helper method parsing (isPowerOf2, isOneOf)
  7. expected-structure 100% coverage
  8. validator-style static_cast detection helper checks
  9. complexity inference execution on parsed AST
  10. static-helper class snippet parse stability
  11. coverage report content checks
  12. graceful degradation via opaque coverage accounting

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step402_test target

Verification run:

• step402_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step401_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step400_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/tests/step402_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (239 lines)
• editor/src/AnnotationValidatorExtended.h within header-size limit (349 <= 600)
• editor/src/SelfHostHarness.h remains within header-size limit (308 <= 600)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2623 > 600)

Step 403: Annotate + Generate from Self-Hosted AST

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added self-hosting coverage for inference + generation workflows over real project headers (AnnotationConflictExtended.h and AnnotationValidatorExtended.h), including pipeline execution and Semanno roundtrip checks from inferred complexity metadata.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step403_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. parse both self-host headers
  2. inference output on conflict AST
  3. complexity inference on validator AST
  4. C++ generation from conflict AST
  5. C++ generation from validator AST
  6. conflict parse/generate/parse roundtrip
  7. validator parse/generate/parse roundtrip
  8. Pipeline.run() success for conflict header
  9. Pipeline.run() success for validator header
  10. Semanno emit/parse roundtrip for inferred ComplexityAnnotation
  11. regenerated output parseability check
  12. combined generated-source parseability check

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step403_test target

Verification run:

• step403_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step402_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step401_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/tests/step403_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (236 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2623 > 600)

Step 404: Self-Hosting Progress Report + Phase Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Completed Phase 16b integration reporting with aggregate self-host coverage, pipeline execution checks over both target headers, Semanno roundtrip checks from inferred complexity metadata, and explicit gap-reporting behavior.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step404_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  1. per-file self-host coverage metrics
  2. baseline per-file coverage ratios
  3. aggregate phase coverage accounting
  4. Pipeline.run() success for both target headers
  5. gap-reporting path for opaque construct deficits
  6. Semanno emit/parse check for inferred complexity
  7. report formatting (file identity + parse status)
  8. phase artifact sanity (step400-404 test files present)

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step404_test target

Verification run:

• step404_test — PASS (8/8) new integration coverage
• step403_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step402_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Phase 16b completion snapshot (Steps 400-404):

• Step 400: Self-hosting harness + coverage tracking (12 tests)
• Step 401: Parse AnnotationConflictExtended.h (12 tests)
• Step 402: Parse AnnotationValidatorExtended.h (12 tests)
• Step 403: Inference + generation on self-hosted ASTs (12 tests)
• Step 404: Coverage report + phase integration (8 tests)

Sprint 16 completion snapshot (Steps 394-404):

• Phase 16a complete (Steps 394-399, 68 tests)
• Phase 16b complete (Steps 400-404, 56 tests)
• Sprint 16 total: 11 steps, 124 tests

Architecture gate check (end of Sprint 16):

• editor/tests/step404_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (219 lines)
• editor/tests/step403_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (236 lines)
• editor/tests/step402_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (239 lines)
• editor/src/SelfHostHarness.h within header-size limit (308 <= 600)
• editor/src/AnnotationValidatorExtended.h within header-size limit (349 <= 600)
• Legacy oversized headers persist and remain queued for split work:
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2623 > 600)

Sprint 17 Progress — Language Batch 2

Phase 17a: F# Parser + Generator

Step 405: F# Parser

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a standalone F# parser covering core functional declarations and routing. Parses top-level let function forms, mutable variables, discriminated unions, record types, module declarations, async computation expressions, match markers, and pipe-operator chains.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/FSharpParser.h — F# parse support:
  • parseFSharp(...) and parseFSharpWithDiagnostics(...)
  • let name params = ... → Function
  • let mutable x = ... → Variable + MutAnnotation
  • type Name = | Case... (single-line/multi-line) → EnumDeclaration
  • type Name = { field: Type; ... } → ClassDeclaration with field children
  • module Name → NamespaceDeclaration
  • match ... with marker → IfStatement
  • |> pipeline chains → FunctionCall markers
  • indentation-aware top-level handling for significant-whitespace behavior
• editor/tests/step405_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. let function parsing
  2. mutable variable parsing
  3. discriminated union parsing
  4. record type parsing
  5. match mapping marker
  6. async computation parsing
  7. module/namespace parsing
  8. pipeline operator chain parsing
  9. significant-whitespace top-level behavior
  10. diagnostics entry point
  11. mixed top-level forms
  12. pipeline parse routing for fsharp / f# / fs

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Parser.h — include ast/FSharpParser.h
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — parse routing for fsharp, f#, fs
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step405_test target

Verification run:

• step405_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step404_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step403_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/FSharpParser.h within header-size limit (265 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step405_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (220 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2623 > 600)

Step 406: F# Generator

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a dedicated F# generator with Semanno annotation emission support and pipeline generate-route aliases (fsharp, f#, fs). Outputs functional let forms, async computation expressions, discriminated-union style enum output, record-style class output, and F#-style type mappings.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/FSharpGenerator.h — F# generation support:
  • module/function/variable generation using let
  • mutable variable output from MutAnnotation
  • async output: let name = async { ... }
  • namespace/module output (module Name)
  • union output (type Name = | Case...)
  • record output (type Name = { field: obj; ... })
  • pipeline marker generation (|> pipeline)
  • type mapping for int, float, string, bool, unit, option, result
  • Semanno output for subject 1 and extended annotation families
• editor/tests/step406_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. let function generation
  2. mutable variable generation
  3. discriminated union generation
  4. record/class generation
  5. async function generation
  6. module namespace generation
  7. if-statement generation
  8. pipeline marker generation
  9. type mapping behavior
  10. comment prefix (// )
  11. Semanno annotation output
  12. pipeline generate routing for fsharp / f# / fs

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Generator.h — include FSharpGenerator.h
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — generate routing for fsharp, f#, fs
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step406_test target

Verification run:

• step406_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step405_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step404_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/FSharpGenerator.h within header-size limit (348 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step406_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (205 lines)
• editor/src/Pipeline.h within header-size limit (240 <= 600)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2623 > 600)

Step 407: VB.NET Parser

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a standalone VB.NET parser with case-insensitive keyword handling for core block forms and declarations. Covers Sub/Function, Class, Interface, Module, Dim, If...Then, and For Each...In recognition.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/VBNetParser.h — VB.NET parse support:
  • parseVBNet(...) and parseVBNetWithDiagnostics(...)
  • Sub and Function signature extraction
  • Class and Interface declaration extraction
  • Module mapping to NamespaceDeclaration
  • Dim ... As ... variable extraction
  • If ... Then marker to IfStatement
  • For Each ... In ... marker to ForLoop with iterator extraction
  • case-insensitive token matching helpers
• editor/tests/step407_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. Sub parsing
  2. Function parsing
  3. class parsing
  4. interface parsing
  5. module/namespace parsing
  6. Dim variable parsing
  7. If...Then mapping
  8. For Each...In mapping
  9. case-insensitive keyword handling
  10. diagnostics entry point
  11. mixed-file parsing
  12. pipeline parse routing for vbnet / vb / vb.net

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Parser.h — include ast/VBNetParser.h
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — parse routing for vbnet, vb, vb.net
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step407_test target

Verification run:

• step407_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step406_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step405_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/VBNetParser.h within header-size limit (184 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step407_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (205 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2623 > 600)

Step 408: VB.NET Generator

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a dedicated VB.NET generator and pipeline generation routing aliases. Outputs VB-style Sub/Function blocks, Dim declarations, If...Then...End If, For Each...Next, and .NET type-name mappings.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/VBNetGenerator.h — VB.NET generation support:
  • module/function/class/interface/module-namespace generation
  • Sub vs Function ... As Type emission
  • Dim name As Type = value variable emission
  • If ... Then ... End If and For Each ... In ... Next
  • .NET type mapping (Integer, Double, String, Boolean, Object)
  • Semanno output with VB comment prefix (' )
• editor/tests/step408_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. Sub generation
  2. Function generation with return type
  3. class generation
  4. interface generation
  5. module/namespace generation
  6. Dim variable generation
  7. If generation
  8. For Each generation
  9. type mapping
  10. comment prefix
  11. Semanno annotation output
  12. pipeline generate routing for vbnet / vb / vb.net

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Generator.h — include VBNetGenerator.h
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — generate routing for vbnet, vb, vb.net
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step408_test target

Verification run:

• step408_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step407_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step406_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/VBNetGenerator.h within header-size limit (261 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step408_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (186 lines)
• editor/src/Pipeline.h within header-size limit (247 <= 600)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2623 > 600)

Step 409: .NET Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Added phase-level .NET integration validation across C#, F#, and VB.NET parse and generation routes, including cross-language projection checks and shared Semanno annotation behavior across all 3 .NET-targeted outputs.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step409_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  1. C# -> F# generation path
  2. F# -> C# generation path
  3. C# -> VB.NET generation path
  4. VB.NET -> F# generation path
  5. Python -> F# generation path
  6. parse alias routing (f#, fs, vb, vb.net)
  7. shared type-annotation Semanno emission across C#/F#/VB targets
  8. Pipeline.run() success for both new languages as source/target

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step409_test target

Verification run:

• step409_test — PASS (8/8) new integration coverage
• step408_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step407_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Phase 17a completion snapshot (Steps 405-409):

• Step 405: F# parser (12 tests)
• Step 406: F# generator (12 tests)
• Step 407: VB.NET parser (12 tests)
• Step 408: VB.NET generator (12 tests)
• Step 409: .NET integration (8 tests)

Architecture gate check (end of Phase 17a):

• editor/tests/step409_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (153 lines)
• editor/src/ast/VBNetGenerator.h within header-size limit (261 <= 600)
• editor/src/ast/VBNetParser.h within header-size limit (184 <= 600)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2623 > 600)

Phase 17b: SQL Dialect Support

Step 410: SQL AST Nodes

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added first-class SQL AST node types and wired JSON serialization/deserialization and compact-node naming support so SQL structures can participate in existing pipeline tooling.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/SqlNodes.h — SQL node definitions:
  • TableDeclaration
  • ColumnDefinition
  • SelectQuery
  • InsertStatement
  • UpdateStatement
  • DeleteStatement
  • JoinClause
  • WhereClause
  • IndexDefinition
• editor/tests/step410_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. table construction
  2. column construction
  3. select query + clause children
  4. insert statement construction
  5. update statement construction
  6. delete statement construction
  7. index construction
  8. table+columns+index JSON roundtrip
  9. select query JSON roundtrip
  10. compact AST naming for SQL nodes
  11. createNode SQL concept dispatch
  12. full query graph roundtrip

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Serialization.h — SQL node property serialization, createNode mapping, and deserialization
• editor/src/CompactAST.h — SQL node name mapping in getNodeName
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step410_test target

Verification run:

• step410_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step409_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step408_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/SqlNodes.h within header-size limit (112 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step410_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (202 lines)
• editor/src/CompactAST.h at header-size limit (600 <= 600)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2623 > 600)

Step 411: PostgreSQL Parser

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a standalone PostgreSQL parser with SQL-statement extraction and mapping to the new SQL AST nodes. Covers DDL/DML basics plus PostgreSQL-specific type and procedural patterns.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/PostgreSQLParser.h — PostgreSQL parse support:
  • parsePostgreSQL(...) and parsePostgreSQLWithDiagnostics(...)
  • statement splitting with $$ ... $$ block awareness
  • CREATE TABLE -> TableDeclaration + ColumnDefinition
  • SELECT -> SelectQuery with from/joins/where and distinct
  • INSERT/UPDATE/DELETE mappings
  • CREATE INDEX/CREATE UNIQUE INDEX -> IndexDefinition
  • DO $$ and CREATE FUNCTION markers -> Function nodes
• editor/tests/step411_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. CREATE TABLE parse
  2. SELECT parse
  3. INSERT parse
  4. UPDATE parse
  5. DELETE parse
  6. JOIN + WHERE parse
  7. PostgreSQL types (SERIAL, JSONB, TEXT[])
  8. schema-qualified table names
  9. CREATE UNIQUE INDEX parse
  10. DO block + PL/pgSQL function marker parse
  11. diagnostics entry point
  12. pipeline parse routing aliases (postgresql, postgres)

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Parser.h — include ast/PostgreSQLParser.h
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — parse routing for postgresql, postgres
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step411_test target

Verification run:

• step411_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step410_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step409_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/PostgreSQLParser.h within header-size limit (288 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step411_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (185 lines)
• editor/src/Pipeline.h within header-size limit (251 <= 600)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2623 > 600)

Step 412: PostgreSQL Generator

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a dedicated PostgreSQL generator and end-to-end generation coverage over the SQL AST nodes introduced in Step 410 and parsed in Step 411.

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/PostgreSQLGenerator.h — PostgreSQL code generation support:
  • SQL DDL/DML emitters for:
    • TableDeclaration
    • ColumnDefinition
    • SelectQuery
    • InsertStatement
    • UpdateStatement
    • DeleteStatement
    • JoinClause
    • WhereClause
    • IndexDefinition
  • module/function support for SQL-oriented output
  • annotation output via Semanno mixin with PostgreSQL comment prefix (-- )
• editor/tests/step412_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. CREATE TABLE generation with columns
  2. SELECT DISTINCT + JOIN + WHERE generation
  3. INSERT generation with columns and values
  4. UPDATE generation with SET and WHERE
  5. DELETE generation
  6. UNIQUE INDEX generation
  7. module-level SQL statement emission
  8. WHERE clause passthrough behavior
  9. PostgreSQL comment prefix + semanno annotation output
  10. pipeline generate routing aliases (postgresql, postgres)
  11. parser-to-generator flow for CREATE TABLE
  12. edge case: empty SELECT defaults to SELECT *;

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/ProjectionGenerator.h — SQL visitor hooks and dispatch branches
• editor/src/ast/Generator.h — include PostgreSQLGenerator.h
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — generate routing for postgresql, postgres
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step412_test target

Verification run:

• step412_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step411_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step410_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/PostgreSQLGenerator.h within header-size limit (412 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step412_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (203 lines)
• editor/src/Pipeline.h within header-size limit (254 <= 600)
• editor/src/ast/ProjectionGenerator.h within header-size limit (408 <= 600)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2629 > 600)

Step 413: T-SQL Parser + Generator

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added Microsoft SQL Server (T-SQL) dialect support with parser and generator coverage for dialect-specific constructs (TOP, IDENTITY, NVARCHAR, DECLARE/SET/PRINT, stored procedures).

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/TSQLParser.h — T-SQL parse support:
  • parseTSQL(...) and parseTSQLWithDiagnostics(...)
  • CREATE TABLE, CREATE INDEX, SELECT, INSERT, UPDATE, DELETE
  • SELECT TOP n captured via SelectQuery child "top"
  • CREATE PROCEDURE ... AS BEGIN ... END mapped to Function markers
  • DECLARE, SET, PRINT mapped to Variable, Assignment, and ExpressionStatement(FunctionCall)
• editor/src/ast/TSQLGenerator.h — T-SQL generation support:
  • SELECT TOP n emission
  • CREATE PROCEDURE ... AS BEGIN ... END
  • DECLARE / SET / PRINT statements
  • T-SQL-oriented primitive type mapping (INT, FLOAT, NVARCHAR(MAX), BIT)
• editor/tests/step413_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. CREATE TABLE with IDENTITY and NVARCHAR parse
  2. SELECT TOP + WHERE parse
  3. CREATE PROCEDURE parse marker
  4. DECLARE parse
  5. SET parse
  6. PRINT parse
  7. SELECT TOP generation
  8. CREATE TABLE with IDENTITY generation
  9. PROCEDURE BEGIN/END generation
  10. DECLARE/SET/PRINT generation
  11. pipeline parse/generate alias routing (tsql, sqlserver, mssql)
  12. parser-to-generator T-SQL flow

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Parser.h — include ast/TSQLParser.h
• editor/src/ast/Generator.h — include TSQLGenerator.h
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — parse + generate routing for tsql, sqlserver, mssql
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step413_test target

Verification run:

• step413_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step412_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step411_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/TSQLParser.h within header-size limit (377 <= 600)
• editor/src/ast/TSQLGenerator.h within header-size limit (161 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step413_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (213 lines)
• editor/src/Pipeline.h within header-size limit (261 <= 600)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2629 > 600)

Step 414: MySQL Parser + Generator

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added MySQL/MariaDB dialect support with parser + generator behavior for dialect-specific features (AUTO_INCREMENT, backtick identifiers, ENGINE=InnoDB, LIMIT, GROUP_CONCAT).

Files created:

• editor/src/ast/MySQLParser.h — MySQL parse support:
  • parseMySQL(...) and parseMySQLWithDiagnostics(...)
  • CREATE TABLE, CREATE INDEX, SELECT, INSERT, UPDATE, DELETE
  • backtick identifier normalization
  • table engine extraction via TableDeclaration child "engine"
  • LIMIT extraction via SelectQuery child "limit"
  • GROUP_CONCAT(...) projection marker via FunctionCall
• editor/src/ast/MySQLGenerator.h — MySQL generation support:
  • backtick quoting for table/column identifiers
  • CREATE TABLE ... ENGINE=... emission
  • MySQL select generation with LIMIT
  • GROUP_CONCAT(*) generation path
  • MySQL alias support in DML emitters
• editor/tests/step414_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. CREATE TABLE parse with AUTO_INCREMENT and engine
  2. SELECT LIMIT parse
  3. GROUP_CONCAT projection parse marker
  4. INSERT/UPDATE/DELETE parse coverage
  5. diagnostics entrypoint
  6. CREATE TABLE generation with backticks + engine
  7. SELECT generation with LIMIT
  8. GROUP_CONCAT generation
  9. INSERT generation with backticks
  10. UPDATE/DELETE generation with backticks
  11. pipeline parse + generate alias routing (mysql, mariadb)
  12. parser-to-generator MySQL flow

Files modified:

• editor/src/ast/Parser.h — include ast/MySQLParser.h
• editor/src/ast/Generator.h — include MySQLGenerator.h
• editor/src/Pipeline.h — parse + generate routing for mysql, mariadb
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step414_test target

Verification run:

• step414_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step413_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step412_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/MySQLParser.h within header-size limit (331 <= 600)
• editor/src/ast/MySQLGenerator.h within header-size limit (178 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step414_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (209 lines)
• editor/src/Pipeline.h within header-size limit (268 <= 600)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2629 > 600)

Step 415: SQL Annotation Mapping

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added SQL-specific semantic annotation mapping focused on risk, complexity, bounds checks, index contracts, and cross-stack ORM<->schema consistency.

Files created:

• editor/src/SqlAnnotationMapper.h — SQL annotation inference/mapping support:
  • module-level AST inference for:
    • RiskAnnotation on destructive SQL patterns (DELETE without WHERE, UPDATE without WHERE)
    • ComplexityAnnotation from JOIN depth + subquery hints
    • BoundsCheckAnnotation from LIMIT/TOP clauses
    • ContractAnnotation precondition for index-dependent queries
  • text-level SQL inference for DROP TABLE and bounds clause patterns
  • cross-stack mapping for Python ORM class fields vs SQL table columns
  • inferred-annotation application helper to attach generated annotations to AST nodes
• editor/tests/step415_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. high risk on DELETE without WHERE
  2. no high-risk false positive on DELETE with WHERE
  3. high risk on DROP TABLE text
  4. complexity from multi-join depth
  5. complexity from subquery nesting hint
  6. bounds check inference from LIMIT
  7. bounds check inference from TOP
  8. no bounds-check false positive without LIMIT/TOP
  9. index precondition contract inference
  10. cross-stack ORM<->SQL contract mapping
  11. cross-stack schema mismatch risk mapping
  12. inferred-annotation application to AST nodes

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step415_test target

Verification run:

• step415_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step414_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step413_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SqlAnnotationMapper.h within header-size limit (246 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step415_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (230 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2629 > 600)

Step 416: Phase 17b Integration + Sprint Summary

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Added Phase 17b integration validation across the 3 SQL dialect paths, the SQL annotation mapper, and cross-stack class-to-SQL flow checkpoints.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step416_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  1. SQL dialect parse routes (postgresql, tsql/sqlserver, mysql/mariadb)
  2. SQL dialect generate route behavior differences
  3. high-risk SQL inference (DELETE without WHERE)
  4. SQL complexity inference from JOIN depth
  5. bounds-check inference from LIMIT/TOP
  6. cross-stack flow checkpoint (Python class parse + C# class generation + SQL table DDL)
  7. ORM-schema contract mapping inference
  8. Sprint 17 totals verification checkpoint (F#, VB.NET, and 3 SQL dialects available)

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step416_test target

Verification run:

• step416_test — PASS (8/8) new step coverage
• step415_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step414_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Phase 17b completion snapshot (Steps 410-416):

• Step 410: SQL AST nodes + serialization
• Step 411: PostgreSQL parser
• Step 412: PostgreSQL generator
• Step 413: T-SQL parser + generator
• Step 414: MySQL parser + generator
• Step 415: SQL annotation mapping
• Step 416: phase integration + summary

Sprint 17 completion snapshot (Steps 405-416):

• Phase 17a complete (Steps 405-409, 56 tests)
• Phase 17b complete (Steps 410-416, 80 tests)
• Sprint 17 total: 12 steps, 136 tests

Architecture gate check (end of Sprint 17):

• editor/tests/step416_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (181 lines)
• editor/src/SqlAnnotationMapper.h within header-size limit (246 <= 600)
• editor/src/ast/PostgreSQLGenerator.h within header-size limit (412 <= 600)
• editor/src/ast/TSQLParser.h within header-size limit (377 <= 600)
• editor/src/ast/MySQLParser.h within header-size limit (331 <= 600)
• editor/src/Pipeline.h within header-size limit (268 <= 600)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2629 > 600)

Sprint 18 Progress — Claude Code Plugin + MCP Workflow Tools

Phase 18a: Claude Code Integration

Step 417: MCP Server Configuration + Discovery

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added MCP server discovery/configuration utilities for plugin-style client setup. This provides a concrete path toward .mcp.json generation and manifest inspection without adding a custom plugin binary.

Files created:

• editor/src/MCPServerConfig.h — MCP config/discovery support:
  • binary path resolution (whetstone_mcp) from explicit candidates, common build locations, and PATH fallback
  • workspace-root detection (walk-up for .git, CMakeLists.txt, progress.md)
  • primary-language detection from workspace extension frequency
  • .mcp.json config JSON construction and file writing
  • server manifest generation from MCPServer::getTools() with category grouping
  • unified discovery snapshot with binary path, workspace root, language, tool count, and per-category counts
• editor/tests/step417_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. explicit candidate binary path resolution
  2. default binary path resolution
  3. workspace root detection
  4. primary-language detection (C++ majority)
  5. primary-language detection (Python majority)
  6. .mcp.json structure generation
  7. workspace/language arg generation
  8. .mcp.json write-out
  9. manifest tool-count threshold (68+)
  10. required category presence
  11. tool-name categorization mapping
  12. end-to-end discovery snapshot

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step417_test target

Verification run:

• step417_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step416_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step415_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/MCPServerConfig.h within header-size limit (246 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step417_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (159 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2629 > 600)

Step 418: Workflow Prompt Templates

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added workflow-specific MCP prompt templates aligned to Sprint 18a's named flows (architect_project, modernize_module, port_to_language, add_feature, review_pending) with explicit tool references and rendering.

Files created:

• editor/src/MCPWorkflowPrompts.h — workflow prompt-template support:
  • canonical template catalog (5 templates)
  • parameterized prompt rendering ({{...}} substitution)
  • template validation (protocol section + required tool mentions)
  • JSON manifest export for client/tooling discovery
  • prompt-file writer for emitting portable .prompt files
• editor/tests/step418_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. required template-name presence
  2. architect_project tool references
  3. modernize_module tool references
  4. port_to_language source/target substitution
  5. add_feature progress workflow references
  6. review_pending review queue/context/approve/reject references
  7. parameter substitution behavior
  8. unresolved placeholder behavior when param omitted
  9. validation failure on empty tool list
  10. manifest structure and template count
  11. template-file write-out
  12. validation success for all shipped templates

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step418_test target

Verification run:

• step418_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step417_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step416_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/MCPWorkflowPrompts.h within header-size limit (159 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step418_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (146 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2629 > 600)

Step 419: Agent Workflow Loop

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a concrete MCP-driven agent loop wrapper that executes the Phase 18a sequence across real MCP tool calls and handles external-result submission for blocker items.

Files created:

• editor/src/MCPAgentWorkflowLoop.h — workflow-loop support:
  • required-tool gate for:
    • whetstone_infer_annotations
    • whetstone_create_skeleton
    • whetstone_create_workflow
    • whetstone_orchestrate_run_deterministic
    • whetstone_get_blockers
    • whetstone_submit_result
    • whetstone_get_progress
  • MCP tools/call execution wrapper with JSON result parsing
  • blocker parsing support (itemId and id aliases)
  • orchestrated run sequence with configurable project/skeleton metadata
  • loop report with call trace, blocker count, and final progress snapshot
• editor/tests/step419_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. baseline loop order without blockers
  2. single-blocker submit flow
  3. multi-blocker submit flow
  4. config propagation to skeleton/workflow creation calls
  5. blocker parsing (itemId)
  6. blocker parsing (id alias)
  7. invalid blocker filtering
  8. report call-order tracking
  9. agent handler payload delivery
  10. submit payload shape (code + confidence)
  11. final progress propagation into report
  12. required MCP tool presence check

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step419_test target

Verification run:

• step419_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step418_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step417_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/MCPAgentWorkflowLoop.h within header-size limit (137 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step419_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (299 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1679 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2629 > 600)

Step 420: Human Review Interface via MCP

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added human-review MCP capabilities so review-required items can be listed, inspected with readable context, and explicitly approved/rejected through the headless JSON-RPC path.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step420_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. MCP review tools are registered
  2. tool-to-RPC mapping for whetstone_get_review_queue
  3. review queue returns review items
  4. review queue empty behavior
  5. review context includes human-readable summary
  6. review context missing-item error
  7. approve path marks item complete
  8. approve wrong-status error
  9. reject requires feedback
  10. reject moves item back to ready
  11. reject wrong-status error
  12. MCP end-to-end queue+approve flow

Files modified:

• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h — added review RPC permissions:
  • read: getReviewQueue, getReviewContext
  • mutate: approveReviewItem, rejectReviewItem
• editor/src/MCPServer.h — added review MCP tools and handlers:
  • whetstone_get_review_queue -> getReviewQueue
  • whetstone_get_review_context -> getReviewContext
  • whetstone_approve_item -> approveReviewItem
  • whetstone_reject_item -> rejectReviewItem
• editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h — implemented review RPC methods:
  • getReviewQueue
  • getReviewContext (includes humanSummary)
  • approveReviewItem
  • rejectReviewItem
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step420_test target

Verification run:

• step420_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step419_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step418_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/AgentPermissionPolicy.h within header-size limit (128 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step420_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (204 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1735 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Step 421: Workspace Onboarding Flow

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added one-call MCP workspace onboarding so a client can bootstrap workflow state on a new repo by indexing files, selecting key source files, running annotation inference, saving sidecars, and creating .whetstone metadata.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step421_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. whetstone_onboard_workspace tool registration
  2. index/list call sequencing
  3. root forwarding to indexWorkspace
  4. maxFiles processing cap
  5. ignored/non-source path filtering
  6. language-count aggregation
  7. inference + sidecar aggregate counters
  8. open-file failure warning/continue behavior
  9. infer failure warning/continue behavior
  10. index failure hard-stop behavior
  11. .whetstone/README.md bootstrap + workflow suggestion payload
  12. headless end-to-end onboarding against a temp workspace

Files modified:

• editor/src/MCPServer.h — added Step 421 onboarding support:
  • whetstone_onboard_workspace tool registration
  • composite onboarding execution (runWorkspaceOnboarding) with:
    • indexWorkspace
    • workspaceList
    • candidate source-file selection + language detection
    • openFile + inferAnnotations + saveAnnotatedAST loop
    • .whetstone/README.md bootstrap via fileCreate
    • warning collection and next-tool workflow suggestion
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step421_test target

Verification run:

• step421_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step420_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step419_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/tests/step421_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (355 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Step 422: Phase 18a Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Added Sprint 18a integration coverage validating the end-to-end MCP protocol path: config readiness, onboarding, skeleton/workflow setup, deterministic orchestration handoff, external-result submission, human review, and completion.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step422_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  1. MCP config structure for Phase 18a
  2. 75+ tool inventory + required Phase 18a tool presence
  3. workflow prompt-template availability (MCPWorkflowPrompts)
  4. onboard -> skeleton -> workflow tool sequence (mocked backend)
  5. orchestrate -> blocker -> submit -> review -> progress flow (mocked)
  6. full Phase 18a protocol end-to-end (mocked state machine)
  7. real headless review completion via MCP review tools
  8. real headless onboarding smoke with .whetstone bootstrap

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step422_test target

Verification run:

• step422_test — PASS (8/8) new phase-integration coverage
• step421_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step420_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Phase 18a completion snapshot (Steps 417-422):

• Step 417: MCP configuration/discovery
• Step 418: workflow prompt templates
• Step 419: agent workflow loop
• Step 420: human review MCP interface
• Step 421: workspace onboarding tool
• Step 422: end-to-end integration coverage

Architecture gate check (end of Phase 18a):

• editor/tests/step422_test.cpp within integration-test size guidance (316 lines)
• editor/tests/step421_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (355 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Phase 18b: Multi-Model Dispatch

Step 423: Model Profile Registry

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a model-profile registry for mapping workflow worker classes (slm, llm, deterministic/template) to concrete model profiles with context-window and cost metadata, including .whetstone/config.json-style override support.

Files created:

• editor/src/ModelProfileRegistry.h — model profile support:
  • ModelProfile schema (name, contextWindow, cost rates, speed class, capabilities)
  • default profile set:
    • claude-opus
    • claude-sonnet
    • claude-haiku
    • local-slm
  • default worker mappings:
    • llm -> claude-sonnet
    • slm -> claude-haiku
    • deterministic/template -> local-slm
  • profile registration/listing/lookup
  • worker mapping override API
  • JSON/file override loading for profiles and worker mappings
  • manifest export (toJson)
• editor/tests/step423_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. default profile presence
  2. default llm mapping
  3. default slm mapping
  4. worker-to-profile resolution
  5. custom profile registration
  6. mapping validation for missing profiles
  7. mapping override behavior
  8. profile override via JSON payload
  9. worker-mapping override via JSON payload
  10. file-based override loading
  11. invalid JSON error path
  12. registry JSON export shape

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step423_test target

Verification run:

• step423_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step422_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step421_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ModelProfileRegistry.h within header-size limit (172 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step423_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (169 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Step 424: Context Window Optimization

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added context-window-aware bundle optimization so routing profiles can adapt prompt/context scope to the selected model budget (local, file, project) with deterministic truncation behavior.

Files created:

• editor/src/ContextWindowOptimizer.h — context optimization support:
  • token estimation heuristic
  • usable-input budget derivation from model context window
  • scope selection:
    • small window -> local
    • medium window -> file
    • large window -> project
  • worker-aware optimization via ModelProfileRegistry mapping
  • truncation marker + budget clamp behavior
• editor/tests/step424_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. token estimation baseline
  2. empty-input token estimate edge case
  3. budget floor behavior
  4. small-model local scope
  5. medium-model file scope
  6. large-model project scope
  7. instruction-prefix preservation
  8. truncation path under hard budget pressure
  9. token estimate budget adherence
  10. worker-mapping optimization path
  11. unknown-worker fallback behavior
  12. project-scope composition includes file/local sections

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step424_test target

Verification run:

• step424_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step423_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step422_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ContextWindowOptimizer.h within header-size limit (115 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step424_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (156 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Step 425: Batch Submission for Agent Tasks

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added batching utilities for external agent tasks to reduce duplicated context tokens by grouping requests with shared worker/language/file context.

Files created:

• editor/src/BatchTaskSubmitter.h — task batching support:
  • AgentTaskRequest / AgentTaskBatch / BatchPlan types
  • deterministic grouping key (workerType|language|bufferId)
  • stable item ordering within batches
  • max batch size splitting
  • token-cost estimation for individual vs batched plans
  • estimated savings percentage reporting
• editor/tests/step425_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. grouping by worker/language/buffer
  2. worker-type separation
  3. language separation
  4. max batch size enforcement
  5. shared-context carryover in batch payload
  6. batch JSON task payload shape
  7. deterministic in-batch ordering
  8. empty-input edge case
  9. max-size floor behavior
  10. batched token estimate <= individual
  11. positive savings for shared-context groups
  12. multi-group savings computation stability

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step425_test target

Verification run:

• step425_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step424_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step423_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/BatchTaskSubmitter.h within header-size limit (123 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step425_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (194 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Step 426: Cost Tracking + Reporting

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added workflow cost-accounting primitives to track estimated vs actual token usage and compute cost rollups by worker/profile for model-dispatch reporting.

Files created:

• editor/src/WorkflowCostTracker.h — cost tracking support:
  • per-item CostRecord (estimated + actual token usage)
  • model-profile resolution through ModelProfileRegistry
  • estimate/actual recording API
  • aggregated CostSummary (token totals, cost totals, variance)
  • cost bucket rollups by worker and profile
  • JSON report export
• editor/tests/step426_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. estimate record creation
  2. actual record update path
  3. actual-only record creation
  4. worker-to-profile resolution
  5. explicit profile override
  6. summary token totals
  7. non-negative cost totals
  8. cost-by-worker buckets
  9. cost-by-profile buckets
  10. positive variance when actual > estimate
  11. report JSON core fields
  12. no-registry zero-cost edge case

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step426_test target

Verification run:

• step426_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step425_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step424_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/WorkflowCostTracker.h within header-size limit (150 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step426_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (174 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Step 427: Phase 18b Integration + Sprint Summary

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Added Phase 18b integration coverage validating that model-profile selection, context optimization, batch planning, and cost accounting compose into a coherent dispatch pipeline.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step427_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  1. profile -> context -> batch -> cost pipeline composition
  2. profile mapping impact on context scope selection
  3. batching token-savings behavior
  4. cost report worker/profile breakdowns
  5. budget alignment across profile sizes
  6. cost variance tracking for estimate drift
  7. deterministic multi-group batching
  8. expected default worker/profile mappings

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step427_test target

Verification run:

• step427_test — PASS (8/8) new phase-integration coverage
• step426_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step425_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Phase 18b completion snapshot (Steps 423-427):

• Step 423: model profile registry + configurable worker mapping
• Step 424: context-window optimization by model budget
• Step 425: batch task submission planning + savings estimates
• Step 426: token/cost tracking and reporting
• Step 427: end-to-end integration across 18b components

Sprint 18 completion snapshot (Steps 417-427):

• Phase 18a complete (Steps 417-422, 68 tests)
• Phase 18b complete (Steps 423-427, 56 tests)
• Sprint 18 total: 11 steps, 124 tests

Architecture gate check (end of Sprint 18):

• New Sprint 18b headers within header-size limit:
  • editor/src/ModelProfileRegistry.h (172 <= 600)
  • editor/src/ContextWindowOptimizer.h (115 <= 600)
  • editor/src/BatchTaskSubmitter.h (123 <= 600)
  • editor/src/WorkflowCostTracker.h (150 <= 600)
• New Sprint 18b tests within file-size guidance:
  • editor/tests/step423_test.cpp (169 lines)
  • editor/tests/step424_test.cpp (156 lines)
  • editor/tests/step425_test.cpp (194 lines)
  • editor/tests/step426_test.cpp (174 lines)
  • editor/tests/step427_test.cpp (164 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Sprint 19 Progress — GUI Phase 2: Workflow Visualization

Phase 19a: Task Board Panel

Step 428: Kanban-Style Task Board

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a task-board model layer for workflow visualization with canonical Kanban columns, card metadata, filtering, and manual column reassignment semantics.

Files created:

• editor/src/WorkflowTaskBoard.h — task-board support:
  • 5 canonical columns: pending, ready, in-progress, review, complete
  • status normalization (assigned/in-progress collapse, rejected->pending view)
  • card projection with worker icon, priority, language/file metadata, tags
  • board filters: worker type, priority, language, file substring
  • deterministic card sorting (priority then item ID)
  • manual move API (moveItem) for board-driven reassignment
• editor/tests/step428_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. board column presence
  2. status-to-column mapping
  3. assigned->in-progress normalization
  4. worker filter
  5. priority filter
  6. language filter
  7. file filter
  8. worker icon + tag payloads
  9. move item across columns
  10. invalid-column move rejection
  11. missing-item move rejection
  12. deterministic ready-column sort

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step428_test target

Verification run:

• step428_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step427_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step426_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/WorkflowTaskBoard.h within header-size limit (154 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step428_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (186 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Step 429: Task Detail View

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a task-detail model layer with review actions so board-selected items can surface skeleton/result context, routing rationale, diff summary, and approval/ rejection operations in one consistent view model.

Files created:

• editor/src/WorkflowTaskDetail.h — task-detail support:
  • detail projection (TaskDetailView) for one work item
  • skeleton stub generation based on file language
  • generated-code and line-delta diff summary
  • routing explanation synthesis
  • annotation-tag extraction from work-item semantics
  • review actions:
    • approve (review -> complete)
    • reject (review -> ready, feedback required)
• editor/tests/step429_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. detail build for existing item
  2. missing-item handling
  3. skeleton/generated payload inclusion
  4. diff summary inclusion
  5. routing explanation inclusion
  6. annotation tag inclusion
  7. rejection-history inclusion
  8. approve transition behavior
  9. approve invalid-status rejection
  10. reject transition + feedback persistence
  11. reject feedback-required validation
  12. reject invalid-status rejection

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step429_test target

Verification run:

• step429_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step428_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step427_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/WorkflowTaskDetail.h within header-size limit (121 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step429_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (169 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Step 430: Dependency Graph Visualization

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a dependency-graph visualization adapter that projects workflow dependencies into render-ready node/edge view data, including status-based color coding, critical-path highlighting, hover details, and click navigation IDs.

Files created:

• editor/src/WorkflowDependencyView.h — dependency-view support:
  • node/edge view structs for DAG rendering
  • status->color mapping:
    • complete: green
    • in-progress/assigned: blue
    • pending/ready: gray
    • review/rejected: red
  • critical path integration from DependencyGraph.h
  • critical-edge tagging
  • hover payload synthesis and task-navigation mapping
• editor/tests/step430_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. graph node/edge projection counts
  2. complete color mapping
  3. in-progress color mapping
  4. pending/ready color mapping
  5. review color mapping
  6. critical-path detection on chain
  7. critical-path node tagging
  8. critical-path edge tagging
  9. hover payload content
  10. node->task navigation ID mapping
  11. missing-node navigation edge case
  12. re-render update after status change

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step430_test target

Verification run:

• step430_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step429_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step428_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/WorkflowDependencyView.h within header-size limit (94 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step430_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (155 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Step 431: Progress Dashboard

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a progress-dashboard model adapter that composes workflow stats, progress/timeline metrics, blocker summaries, worker distribution, and cost tracking into a panel-ready snapshot.

Files created:

• editor/src/WorkflowProgressDashboard.h — dashboard support:
  • completion metrics passthrough (percent, throughput, ETA)
  • throughput series derivation from timeline events
  • worker-breakdown slices with percentage normalization
  • blocker-summary projection for action surfaces
  • optional cost integration (WorkflowCostTracker) with remaining-cost estimate
• editor/tests/step431_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. completion metric passthrough
  2. throughput-series length from timeline
  3. completed-count progression in throughput series
  4. worker-slice presence
  5. worker-percent normalization
  6. blocker-summary projection
  7. populated cost fields with tracker
  8. remaining-cost estimate path
  9. zero-cost behavior without tracker
  10. empty-timeline edge case
  11. ETA passthrough
  12. zero-total workflow edge case

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step431_test target

Verification run:

• step431_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step430_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step429_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/WorkflowProgressDashboard.h within header-size limit (112 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step431_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (202 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Step 432: Phase 19a Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Added Phase 19a integration coverage ensuring task board, task detail actions, dependency view, and progress dashboard stay synchronized across workflow state changes and review lifecycle transitions.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step432_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  1. task board state sync
  2. dependency graph update after completion
  3. progress dashboard timeline/blocker sync
  4. review approve flow updates board+detail
  5. review reject flow requeues on board
  6. dependency-node click to detail navigation
  7. board filter/detail consistency
  8. end-to-end visible flow (route -> execute -> review -> complete)

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step432_test target

Verification run:

• step432_test — PASS (8/8) new phase-integration coverage
• step431_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step430_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Phase 19a completion snapshot (Steps 428-432):

• Step 428: task board model (kanban columns, filters, moves)
• Step 429: task detail model (skeleton/result/diff/routing/review actions)
• Step 430: dependency graph visualization adapter
• Step 431: progress dashboard model
• Step 432: integration across board/detail/graph/dashboard

Architecture gate check (end of Phase 19a):

• New Phase 19a headers within header-size limit:
  • editor/src/WorkflowTaskBoard.h (154 <= 600)
  • editor/src/WorkflowTaskDetail.h (121 <= 600)
  • editor/src/WorkflowDependencyView.h (94 <= 600)
  • editor/src/WorkflowProgressDashboard.h (112 <= 600)
• New Phase 19a tests within file-size guidance:
  • editor/tests/step428_test.cpp (186 lines)
  • editor/tests/step429_test.cpp (169 lines)
  • editor/tests/step430_test.cpp (155 lines)
  • editor/tests/step431_test.cpp (202 lines)
  • editor/tests/step432_test.cpp (182 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Phase 19b: Code Annotation Overlay

Step 433: Inline Annotation Badges

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added an inline-annotation badge model for editor gutter overlays, including type-specific icon/color mapping, stacked line badges, and expandable detail text.

Files created:

• editor/src/CodeAnnotationBadges.h — inline badge support:
  • annotation input -> badge projection
  • type->icon mapping (intent/complexity/risk/contract/review/priority)
  • type->color mapping for visual encoding
  • deterministic line/type sorting
  • line-based stacking for multiple annotations on one line
  • expandable detail formatter
• editor/tests/step433_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. input->badge count preservation
  2. sort stability by line/type
  3. known icon mapping
  4. known color mapping
  5. unknown-type fallback icon/color
  6. multi-badge same-line stacking
  7. stack ordering by line
  8. expanded detail payload content
  9. line/node identity preservation
  10. empty input edge case
  11. empty stack edge case
  12. review-annotation icon mapping

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step433_test target

Verification run:

• step433_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step432_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step431_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/CodeAnnotationBadges.h within header-size limit (88 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step433_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (141 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Step 434: Annotation Heatmap

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a heatmap projection for code annotations to support line-level intensity visualization in workflow overlays, including category weighting and color mapping.

Files created:

• editor/src/CodeAnnotationHeatmap.h — heatmap support:
  • annotation input -> per-line heat cells
  • category weighting (complexity/risk/review/priority/intent/contract)
  • deterministic score accumulation per line
  • score-to-color mapping (cool blue -> green -> orange -> red)
  • range filtering for out-of-bounds annotations
• editor/tests/step434_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. one cell per line generation behavior
  2. disabled heatmap returns empty output
  3. invalid max-line boundary handling
  4. complexity weight mapping
  5. risk weight mapping
  6. review weight mapping
  7. low-score cool-blue color mapping
  8. low-mid cool-green color mapping
  9. mid-high orange color mapping
  10. high-score red color mapping
  11. multi-annotation score accumulation
  12. out-of-range annotation filtering

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step434_test target

Verification run:

• step434_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step433_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step432_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/CodeAnnotationHeatmap.h within header-size limit (50 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step434_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (126 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Step 435: Workflow Status Overlay

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a workflow status overlay model to project per-function/class lifecycle state into editor views, with status icon/color mapping and task-detail routes.

Files created:

• editor/src/WorkflowStatusOverlay.h — overlay marker support:
  • work-item -> status marker projection
  • optional buffer filter for multi-file views
  • node-id -> line mapping with safe fallback
  • status -> icon mapping (outline/spinner/eye/check)
  • status -> color mapping aligned with board states
  • status -> task-board column normalization
  • click route helper to task-detail URI
  • stable sorting by file/line/item for deterministic rendering
• editor/tests/step435_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. marker generation count parity with work items
  2. file-scope buffer filtering behavior
  3. missing node-line fallback behavior
  4. pending icon mapping
  5. in-progress icon mapping
  6. review icon mapping
  7. complete icon mapping
  8. color mapping for review/complete
  9. board-column mapping for assigned/in-progress
  10. task-detail click route format
  11. node-name display preference
  12. deterministic sorting by file then line

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step435_test target

Verification run:

• step435_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step434_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step433_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/WorkflowStatusOverlay.h within header-size limit (94 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step435_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (155 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Step 436: Review Comparison View

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Added a review-comparison model that produces side-by-side diff rows and integrates approve/reject actions with keyboard shortcut metadata.

Files created:

• editor/src/ReviewComparisonView.h — review diff model support:
  • workflow item -> comparison model projection
  • skeleton/generated side labels
  • line-oriented diff rows (added/removed/modified/unchanged)
  • contextual change notes (routing, feedback, annotations)
  • action availability flags keyed to review status
  • approve/reject wrappers delegated to workflow detail logic
  • keyboard shortcut constants (Ctrl+Shift+A, Ctrl+Shift+R)
• editor/tests/step436_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. model generation for existing item
  2. missing-item null handling
  3. modified-line diff detection
  4. review-state action enablement
  5. shortcut constant mapping
  6. shortcut propagation into model
  7. routing note inclusion
  8. rejection-feedback note inclusion
  9. approve transition to complete
  10. reject transition to ready
  11. reject-feedback requirement
  12. non-review action disablement

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step436_test target

Verification run:

• step436_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step435_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step434_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ReviewComparisonView.h within header-size limit (118 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step436_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (173 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Step 437: Phase 19b Integration + Sprint Summary

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Added Phase 19b integration coverage validating that annotation overlays, workflow status overlays, and review comparison views work together in a single visual workflow path.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step437_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  1. inline annotation badge visibility on annotated code
  2. heatmap emphasis for complex regions
  3. workflow status overlay projection from live state
  4. code-overlay status click -> review comparison access
  5. task-board review selection -> comparison access
  6. approve flow updates board + overlay state
  7. reject flow requeues and reflects overlay status
  8. end-to-end visualization stack operability (badges/heatmap/overlay/review/dashboard)

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step437_test target

Verification run:

• step437_test — PASS (8/8) new integration coverage
• step436_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step435_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step434_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Sprint 19 completion snapshot (Steps 428-437):

• Phase 19a (428-432): task board, task detail, dependency graph, progress dashboard, integration
• Phase 19b (433-437): annotation badges, heatmap, workflow status overlay, review comparison, integration
• Result: workflow visualization stack operational end-to-end across board, code overlays, and review flow

Architecture gate check (end of Sprint 19):

• New Sprint 19 headers within header-size limit:
  • editor/src/WorkflowTaskBoard.h (154 <= 600)
  • editor/src/WorkflowTaskDetail.h (121 <= 600)
  • editor/src/WorkflowDependencyView.h (94 <= 600)
  • editor/src/WorkflowProgressDashboard.h (112 <= 600)
  • editor/src/CodeAnnotationBadges.h (88 <= 600)
  • editor/src/CodeAnnotationHeatmap.h (50 <= 600)
  • editor/src/WorkflowStatusOverlay.h (94 <= 600)
  • editor/src/ReviewComparisonView.h (118 <= 600)
• New Sprint 19 tests within file-size guidance:
  • editor/tests/step428_test.cpp (186 lines)
  • editor/tests/step429_test.cpp (169 lines)
  • editor/tests/step430_test.cpp (155 lines)
  • editor/tests/step431_test.cpp (202 lines)
  • editor/tests/step432_test.cpp (182 lines)
  • editor/tests/step433_test.cpp (141 lines)
  • editor/tests/step434_test.cpp (126 lines)
  • editor/tests/step435_test.cpp (155 lines)
  • editor/tests/step436_test.cpp (173 lines)
  • editor/tests/step437_test.cpp (208 lines)
• Legacy oversized headers persist:
  • editor/src/ast/Serialization.h (1427 > 600)
  • editor/src/MCPServer.h (1940 > 600)
  • editor/src/HeadlessAgentRPCHandler.h (2768 > 600)

Post-Sprint Stabilization: Build + Startup Usability

Hotfix A: Keybinding type collision blocking editor build

Status: PASS (build restored)

Resolved a compile-breaking global type collision between legacy keybinding code and the newer registry by namespacing the legacy combo type.

Files modified:

• editor/src/KeybindingManager.h — renamed legacy KeyCombo to LegacyKeyCombo
• editor/src/main.cpp — updated shortcut dispatch type usage
• editor/src/ShortcutReference.h — updated shortcut panel type usage
• editor/tests/step54_test.cpp — updated test references

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target whetstone_editor — PASS
• step54_test — PASS (10/10) regression coverage

Hotfix B: startup usability (editable buffer + dismissible side panel)

Status: PASS (build restored, UX defaults improved)

Adjusted startup defaults so users can type immediately and hide optional side panels cleanly.

Files modified:

• editor/src/state/UIFlags.h — added showMemoryStrategies flag (default false)
• editor/src/panels/SidePanels.h — made Memory Strategies panel conditional and closable
• editor/src/panels/MenuBarPanel.h — added View menu toggle for Memory Strategies panel
• editor/src/main.cpp — auto-create untitled text buffer when startup/session has no buffers; set editor focus

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target whetstone_editor — PASS
• step54_test — PASS (10/10) regression coverage
• step437_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Build health check cadence (to run after each sprint step cluster):

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target whetstone_editor -j4
• ./editor/build-native/step54_test
• ./editor/build-native/step437_test

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/main.cpp within main-file limit (587 <= 1500)
• editor/src/KeybindingManager.h within header-size limit (276 <= 600)
• editor/src/panels/SidePanels.h within header-size limit (308 <= 600)
• editor/src/panels/MenuBarPanel.h within header-size limit (268 <= 600)
• editor/src/state/UIFlags.h within header-size limit (33 <= 600)

Hotfix C: completion helper dismiss behavior in text mode

Status: PASS (helper popup now dismisses reliably)

Fixed sticky completion helper behavior where popup reappeared immediately after dismiss, especially noticeable in text-mode editing.

Files modified:

• editor/src/EditorState.h — added completionDismissed state
• editor/src/panels/EditorPanel.h — completion popup behavior updates:
  • preserve dismissal until next text-change trigger
  • close on Esc and mark dismissed
  • close on click outside popup and mark dismissed
  • reset dismissal on new edits
  • avoid forcing popup visible every frame when results exist

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target whetstone_editor — PASS
• step54_test — PASS (10/10) regression coverage
• step437_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/EditorState.h remains within header-size limit (634 > 600) — existing oversize file prior to this hotfix
• editor/src/panels/EditorPanel.h remains within header-size limit (850 > 600) — existing oversize file prior to this hotfix

Hotfix D: completion selection bounds hardening (stability)

Status: PASS (build stable)

Hardened completion popup selection handling to prevent stale-selection indexing when the candidate list shrinks between frames (e.g., while typing quickly and confirming with Enter/Tab).

Files modified:

• editor/src/panels/EditorPanel.h — clamped completionSelected before navigation and before selection accept

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target whetstone_editor — PASS
• step54_test — PASS (10/10) regression coverage
• step437_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Hotfix E: inline completion helper default-off + toggle

Status: PASS (helper now opt-in)

Changed inline completion helper to default OFF and only appear when explicitly enabled by the user.

Files modified:

• editor/src/state/UIFlags.h — added showCompletionHelper UI flag (default false)
• editor/src/SettingsManager.h — added persisted showCompletionHelper setting
• editor/src/BufferOps.h — synced showCompletionHelper with settings load/save
• editor/src/panels/MenuBarPanel.h — View toggle: Inline Completion Helper
• editor/src/panels/SettingsPanel.h — Settings checkbox and cleanup on disable
• editor/src/panels/EditorPanel.h — gated completion requests/rendering behind toggle

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target whetstone_editor — PASS
• step54_test — PASS (10/10) regression coverage
• step437_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Hotfix F: context-aware include completion filtering

Status: PASS (relevance improved for #include workflows)

Improved completion relevance in C/C++ preprocessor include contexts to avoid noisy unrelated suggestions (for example std::* symbols when typing #inc).

Files modified:

• editor/src/CompletionUtils.h:
  • added completion context detection (General, CppInclude)
  • added include-context filtering for LSP items
  • added include-focused snippet suggestions (include, <string>, <vector>, <iostream>, <memory>)
• editor/src/panels/EditorPanel.h:
  • passed runtime completion context into completion builder

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target whetstone_editor — PASS
• step54_test — PASS (10/10) regression coverage
• step437_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Sprint 20 Kickoff (MCP Trial)

Step 438 kickoff via whetstone_mcp tool path

Status: PASS (MCP tool chain works for basic edit operations)

Ran a real stdio MCP session against whetstone_mcp using framed Content-Length JSON-RPC requests and verified tool execution.

MCP calls executed:

1. initialize
2. tools/list
3. tools/call -> whetstone_workspace_list (glob=sprint20*)
4. tools/call -> whetstone_file_write

File created through MCP tool call:

• editor/src/LegacyIdiomDetector.h (Step 438 scaffold)

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target whetstone_editor — PASS

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/LegacyIdiomDetector.h within header-size limit (8 <= 600)

Step 438: Code Age + Idiom Detection

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implemented legacy idiom/code-age detection with per-file and per-function reporting, plus language-version heuristics and bounded 0-10 legacy scoring.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step438_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. K&R declaration detection
  2. goto-heavy flow detection
  3. deprecated gets detection
  4. deprecated sprintf detection
  5. deprecated strcpy detection
  6. pointer arithmetic detection
  7. manual memory management detection
  8. C89 detection heuristic
  9. C99 detection heuristic
  10. C++11 detection heuristic
  11. score range clamp (0-10)
  12. per-function findings include function name

Files modified:

• editor/src/LegacyIdiomDetector.h — full detector model implementation:
  • idiom finding/report structs
  • file analysis entrypoint
  • per-function findings summary
  • language version inference (C/C++/Python heuristics)
  • legacy score normalization/clamping
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step438_test target

MCP queue trial for this step (human-in-the-loop simulation):

• Created workflow tasks via MCP:
  • write_detector_tests (deterministic, critical)
  • implement_legacy_detector (template, high)
• Pulled queue items via whetstone_get_ready_tasks and confirmed task metadata/IDs.
• Routed queue with whetstone_route_all_ready.
• Note: workflow state in whetstone_mcp is session-scoped; execute/get_work_item must run in the same long-lived MCP session.
• Experiment outcome: MCP task flow is functional, but current execution overhead (session management + transport framing + state locality) is still higher than direct text-editing workflow for implementation speed. Keep MCP usage for trace capture and behavior tuning, while using direct edits as primary path for sprint velocity.

Verification run:

• step438_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step437_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage
• step54_test — PASS (10/10) regression coverage
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target whetstone_editor — PASS

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/LegacyIdiomDetector.h within header-size limit (193 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step438_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (129 lines)

Step 438 experiment note (follow-up):

• Human-in-the-loop comparison confirmed that normal direct text editing is currently faster and easier for sprint delivery than the MCP worker path.
• Decision for now: keep direct editing as the primary implementation path, and use MCP/task-queue flows selectively for behavior tracing and later training-data/worker-tuning experiments.

Step 439: Safety Audit via Annotations

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implemented structured safety analysis with annotation-based findings, CWE mapping, and per-function risk classification.

Files created:

• editor/src/SafetyAuditor.h — full safety audit model:
  • buffer overflow detection (gets, strcpy, sprintf, strcat, unchecked array access)
  • use-after-free detection (manual malloc/free without RAII, dangling dereference)
  • null dereference detection (nullable pointers without null check, unchecked malloc)
  • race condition detection (shared mutable state + threading without synchronization)
  • integer overflow detection (unchecked arithmetic on integer types)
  • CWE code mapping (CWE-120, CWE-416, CWE-476, CWE-362, CWE-190, CWE-787)
  • risk levels: 0=info, 1=low, 2=medium, 3=high, 4=critical
  • per-function safety findings with max risk aggregation
• editor/tests/step439_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  1. buffer overflow via gets() → CWE-120
  2. buffer overflow via strcpy() → CWE-120
  3. use-after-free with manual malloc/free → CWE-416
  4. dangling pointer dereference after free → @Lifetime(dangling)
  5. null dereference with unchecked nullable pointer → CWE-476
  6. unchecked malloc return value → @Nullability(unchecked-alloc)
  7. race condition: thread + global mutable state without sync → CWE-362
  8. no false positive when mutex synchronization present
  9. integer overflow without bounds check → CWE-190
  10. no false positive when INT_MAX check present
  11. per-function findings include function name and max risk
  12. comprehensive CWE mapping across all categories
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step439_test target

Verification run:

• step439_test — PASS (12/12) new step coverage
• step438_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage
• step54_test — PASS (10/10) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SafetyAuditor.h within header-size limit (225 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step439_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (148 lines)

Step 440: Modernization Suggestions

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Maps legacy patterns to modern replacements with @Modernize annotations, effort classification (quick win / moderate / deep refactor), and cross-language modernization support (C→Rust ownership, C→Java/Python GC).

Files created:

• editor/src/ModernizationSuggester.h — suggestion model:
  • maps 7 legacy patterns to modern replacements (malloc→smart_ptr, sprintf→format, strcpy→string, gets→fgets, goto→structured, pointer_arith→span, K&R→ANSI)
  • safety-derived suggestions (unprotected shared state→mutex, unchecked arith→SafeInt)
  • cross-language suggestions (C→Rust ownership, C→Java/Python GC)
  • effort enum: QuickWin, Moderate, DeepRefactor
  • @Modernize(from=..., to=..., risk=...) annotation format
• editor/tests/step440_test.cpp — 12 tests
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step440_test target

Step 441: Modernization Workflow Generation

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Converts modernization suggestions into an ordered workflow with routing (deterministic/LLM/human), dependency tracking, and skeleton code generation.

Files created:

• editor/src/ModernizationWorkflow.h — workflow model:
  • work items with routing (QuickWin→Deterministic, Moderate→LLM, DeepRefactor→Human)
  • priority ordering (safe changes first, risky last)
  • dependency graph (deep refactors depend on quick wins)
  • skeleton generation with @Modernize inline comments
• editor/tests/step441_test.cpp — 12 tests
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step441_test target

Step 442: Modernization RPC + MCP

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

JSON-RPC dispatch and MCP tool definitions for the full modernization pipeline.

Files created:

• editor/src/ModernizationRPC.h — RPC handler + MCP tool defs:
  • analyzeLegacy / whetstone_analyze_legacy — legacy idiom detection
  • getSafetyReport / whetstone_get_safety_report — structured safety audit
  • suggestModernization / whetstone_suggest_modernization — modernization suggestions
  • createModernizationWorkflow / whetstone_create_modernization_workflow — full pipeline
  • JSON serialization for all report types
  • canHandle() + dispatch() for integration with existing RPC chain
  • 4 MCP tool definitions with input schemas
• editor/tests/step442_test.cpp — 12 tests
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step442_test target

Step 443: Phase 20a Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

End-to-end integration: legacy C file → analyze → safety audit → suggest → workflow → validate routing and risk ordering via both native API and JSON-RPC.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step443_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  • full pipeline legacy→workflow, safety report CWE validation,
  • risk ordering verification, C→Rust cross-language, RPC pipeline,
  • deterministic vs LLM/human routing, language version detection

Step 444: Migration Plan Generator

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Multi-file project analysis with dependency resolution, phased migration ordering (leaves first), and effort/risk/routing classification per migration unit.

Files created:

• editor/src/MigrationPlanGenerator.h — plan generator:
  • FileInfo input with exports/imports for dependency resolution
  • topological phase assignment (leaf modules = phase 0)
  • effort (file size), risk (API surface + deps), routing classification
  • ordered execution plan respecting dependencies
• editor/tests/step444_test.cpp — 12 tests
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step444_test target

Step 445: API Boundary Preservation

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Preserves public API surfaces during migration with function signature extraction, type mappings, @Contract annotations, and FFI boundary generation.

Files created:

• editor/src/APIBoundaryPreserver.h — boundary preserver:
  • public function signature extraction from source
  • type mappings C→Rust/Java/Python (int→i32, char*→&str, etc.)
  • @Contract annotations (null preconditions, return postconditions)
  • FFI boundaries (#[no_mangle] for Rust, JNI for Java)
  • verifyPreservation() for pre/post migration comparison
• editor/tests/step445_test.cpp — 12 tests
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step445_test target

Step 446: Test Generation for Migration Validation

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Auto-generates equivalence, edge case, and performance regression tests for migrated modules in the target language.

Files created:

• editor/src/MigrationTestGenerator.h — test generator:
  • equivalence tests (same inputs → same outputs) per public function
  • edge case tests from @Contract pre/post conditions (null handling, etc.)
  • performance regression tests
  • target-language-specific test body generation (Rust #[test], Java @Test, Python def test_)
  • SLM/LLM routing for generated test skeletons
• editor/tests/step446_test.cpp — 12 tests
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step446_test target

Step 447: Migration Execution Integration

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Hooks migration plans into orchestration with dependency-respecting execution, rollback annotations, progressive (partial) migration, and FFI boundary management.

Files created:

• editor/src/MigrationExecutor.h — execution engine:
  • work items with cross-unit dependency tracking
  • ready-items computation (unblocked pending items)
  • completeUnit/failUnit state transitions
  • rollback annotations (@Rollback pointing to original files)
  • partial migration detection (mixed-language state)
  • FFI boundary auto-detection during progressive migration
• editor/tests/step447_test.cpp — 12 tests
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step447_test target

Step 448: Phase 20b Integration + Sprint 20 Summary

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Full integration: 3-file C project → Rust migration with API preservation, test generation, partial migration with FFI boundaries, and combined modernization + migration pipeline.

Files created:

• editor/tests/step448_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  • full 3-file C→Rust migration, API boundary preservation,
  • generated test validation, partial migration (2/3 files),
  • FFI boundary management, legacy+migration combined pipeline,
  • sprint 20 complete pipeline verification

Sprint 20 totals:

• Steps: 438-448 (11 steps)
• Tests: 124/124 passing
• Headers created: 8 (LegacyIdiomDetector, SafetyAuditor, ModernizationSuggester, ModernizationWorkflow, ModernizationRPC, MigrationPlanGenerator, APIBoundaryPreserver, MigrationTestGenerator, MigrationExecutor)
• MCP tools added: 4 (whetstone_analyze_legacy, whetstone_get_safety_report, whetstone_suggest_modernization, whetstone_create_modernization_workflow)
• Capabilities delivered:
  • Legacy code analysis (K&R, goto, deprecated APIs, manual memory, pointer arithmetic)
  • Safety audit with CWE mapping (CWE-120, 190, 362, 416, 476, 787)
  • Modernization suggestions with effort classification and @Modernize annotations
  • Workflow generation with deterministic/LLM/human routing
  • Multi-file migration planning with dependency-ordered phases
  • API boundary preservation with type mappings, contracts, FFI annotations
  • Test generation in target language (Rust, Java, Python)
  • Progressive migration with FFI boundary management

Roadmap Planning — Sprints 12-25+

Status: Planning Complete (Sprints 12-19 detailed, 20-25 in roadmap.md)

Sprint 11 revised: Phase 11e changed from "Training Data Pipeline" to "Workflow Annotation Foundation" — routing annotation types (Subject 9), skeleton AST, and inference-to-routing bridge replace training data export (deferred to post-25).

Planning documents created:

• ARCHITECT.md — Core thesis, skeleton AST concept, architecture invariants, key metrics
• roadmap.md — Sprint 12-25+ high-level roadmap with post-25 training data notes
• sprint11_plan.md — Revised: 11e is now workflow annotation foundation
• sprint12_plan.md — Workflow Model + C++ Depth (22 steps, ~248 tests, 56+ tools)
• sprint13_plan.md — GUI Overhaul Phase 1 (19 steps, ~212 tests)
• sprint14_plan.md — Languages: C, WebAssembly, Common Lisp, Scheme (17 steps, ~188 tests)
• sprint15_plan.md — Orchestration Engine (16 steps, ~180 tests, 68+ tools)
• sprint16_plan.md — C++ Depth + Self-Hosting Phase 1 (11 steps, ~124 tests)
• sprint17_plan.md — Languages: F#, VB.NET, SQL dialects (12 steps, ~136 tests)
• sprint18_plan.md — Claude Code Plugin + MCP Workflow Tools (11 steps, ~124 tests, 75+ tools)
• sprint19_plan.md — GUI Phase 2: Workflow Visualization (10 steps, ~112 tests)
• sprint20_plan.md — Legacy Code Ingestion (11 steps, ~124 tests)
• sprint21_plan.md — Cross-Language Transpilation Engine (11 steps, ~124 tests, 83+ tools)
• sprint22_plan.md — Languages: Assembly + C++ remaining gaps (11 steps, ~124 tests)
• sprint23_plan.md — Architect Mode + Tech Stack Selection (11 steps, ~124 tests, 87+ tools)
• sprint24_plan.md — Security + Static Analysis (11 steps, ~124 tests, 90+ tools)
• sprint25_plan.md — Integration, Self-Hosting, Polish (16 steps, ~180 tests)

Cumulative projections (Sprints 9-25):

• Steps: ~508 (245-508)
• Tests: ~5000+
• Languages: 19+ parsers and generators
• MCP Tools: 90+
• Annotation Types: 80+ across 10 subjects

Key architectural decisions:

1. Skeleton AST = project specification before code exists (annotations on empty functions/classes)
2. Annotations are routing signals — @Automatability, @ContextWidth, @Ambiguity determine worker dispatch
3. Orchestrator prepares context but never calls LLMs — model-agnostic, cost-controlled
4. Plugin is MCP protocol — not a proprietary binary, any MCP client can drive workflows
5. Training data deferred to post-25 — real workflow decisions are better training signal than synthetic pairs

Step 449: Intent-Driven Translation

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Recovered and validated in-progress Sprint 21 work left uncommitted: intent-aware translation that prefers target-language idioms when intent is clear, and falls back to structural translation with review flags when intent is absent/ambiguous.

Files added:

• editor/src/IntentTranslator.h — intent mapping model + translation engine:
  • FunctionIntent, IntentMapping, FunctionTranslation, IntentTranslationResult
  • idiomatic mapping by intent phrase and target language (Rust/Python/Java/SQL/C++)
  • ambiguity/review gating (needsReview, reviewReason)
  • confidence scoring by mapping strength and fallback mode
• editor/tests/step449_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • intent-to-idiom mappings (sort/find/filter/map/reduce/read-file)
  • SQL-specific intent projection (ORDER BY, WHERE)
  • ambiguous/no-intent fallback and review behavior
  • mixed multi-function translation accounting
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step449_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step449_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step449_test — PASS (12/12)

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/IntentTranslator.h within header-size limit (254 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step449_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (166 lines)

Step 450: Algorithm-Level Equivalence

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds algorithm-pattern recognition over source snippets and target-language idiomatic equivalent selection, enabling standard-library mappings beyond literal/syntactic rewrites.

Files added:

• editor/src/AlgorithmEquivalence.h — recognizer + mapping model:
  • AlgorithmPattern, AlgorithmEquivalent, AlgorithmAnalysisResult
  • pattern detection for sort/search/map/filter/reduce/builder/iteration
  • cross-language target mapping (Rust/Python/Java/C++/Go)
  • standard-library usage accounting (countStdLib)
  • pattern catalog (supportedPatterns, 15 entries)
• editor/tests/step450_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • bubble/binary/linear search recognition
  • map/filter/reduce loop recognition and idiomatic target mapping
  • builder-pattern detection
  • cross-language sort target projection validation
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step450_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step450_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step450_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step449_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/AlgorithmEquivalence.h within header-size limit (228 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step450_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (143 lines)

Step 451: Type System Translation

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Completes type-system mapping across language boundaries with explicit safety classification and risk annotations for lossy projections.

Files added:

• editor/src/TypeSystemTranslator.h — type translation engine:
  • nullable mapping (Optional<T>/T?), generic collections, maps, enums
  • class-hierarchy projection (trait + struct, interface + struct, struct + vtable)
  • primitive/string translation across Rust/Python/Java/C/C++/Go
  • safety classification (Preserved, Widened, Narrowed, Lossy)
  • risk annotation tagging for lossy targets (@Risk(medium|high))
• editor/tests/step451_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • nullable/generic/map translations and safety categories
  • enum/class/string lossy/narrowed mappings
  • unknown-type pass-through behavior
  • mixed-batch translation with lossy-count validation
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step451_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step451_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step451_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step450_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/TypeSystemTranslator.h within header-size limit (140 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step451_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (146 lines)

Step 452: Concurrency Model Translation

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds concurrency-pattern translation with explicit runtime/safety annotations for async/thread/channel/mutex constructs across language runtime models.

Files added:

• editor/src/ConcurrencyTranslator.h — concurrency translation engine:
  • source/target model detection (Threads, AsyncAwait, Channels, EventLoop)
  • pattern translators for async/await, thread_spawn, channels, mutex
  • runtime-aware annotations (@Exec, @ThreadModel, @Sync, @Blocking)
  • safety grading (Safe, NeedsReview, Unsafe) and review counts
• editor/tests/step452_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • async mapping across Rust/Python/C targets
  • thread/channel/mutex projection to Go/Rust/C
  • source/target model detection behavior
  • plain-code no-pattern behavior and multi-pattern aggregation
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step452_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step452_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step452_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step451_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ConcurrencyTranslator.h within header-size limit (249 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step452_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (146 lines)

Step 453: Memory Model Translation

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Completes ownership/lifetime translation across manual, RAII, GC, ARC, and borrow-checked models with explicit safety-delta tracking.

Files added:

• editor/src/MemoryModelTranslator.h — memory model translation engine:
  • ownership model detection (Manual, RAII, GC, BorrowChecked, ARC)
  • translation patterns for @Owner(Unique), @Owner(Shared_ARC), @Owner(Manual), @Lifetime(Scope)
  • per-translation safety delta (Gained, Lost, Neutral)
  • migration annotations (e.g., @Risk(high), @Risk(lowered))
• editor/tests/step453_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • manual-memory safety gains in Rust/GC targets
  • unique/shared ownership degradation when targeting C
  • scope-lifetime mapping (defer, try-with-resources, manual fallback)
  • source/target model inference and mixed-pattern safety counters
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step453_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step453_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step453_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step452_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/MemoryModelTranslator.h within header-size limit (249 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step453_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (142 lines)

Step 454: Phase 21a Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Adds Phase 21a end-to-end integration coverage across intent, algorithm, types, concurrency, and memory translation components.

Files added:

• editor/tests/step454_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  • intent-driven idiomatic translation (Python→Rust sort intent)
  • algorithm recognizer stdlib mapping validation
  • type-system preservation vs lossy-risk behavior
  • async runtime review requirements in concurrency translation
  • manual-memory safety gains during C→Rust migration
  • no-intent structural fallback/review behavior
  • combined pipeline signal checks across all phase components
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step454_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step454_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step454_test — PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step453_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/tests/step454_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (119 lines)
• No new production header introduced in this integration step

Step 455: Behavioral Equivalence Checking

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements behavioral-equivalence assertion generation with contract annotation grading from confidence scores (verified/likely/unverified+review).

Files added:

• editor/src/BehavioralEquivalence.h — equivalence checker:
  • EquivalenceAssertion, BehavioralCheckResult, BehavioralChecker
  • inferred input generation for sort/search/sum/generic functions
  • inferred expected-output stubs for common patterns
  • confidence scoring heuristics from target translation shape
  • contract annotation assignment:
    • @Contract(verified) (>=0.90)
    • @Contract(likely) (>=0.70)
    • @Contract(unverified), @Review(required,human) (<0.70)
• editor/tests/step455_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • input inference for sort/search/sum/generic categories
  • custom input override behavior
  • confidence-tiered contract annotation mapping
  • same-language high-confidence default behavior
  • assertion metadata (sameErrors, allPassing) expectations
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step455_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step455_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step455_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step454_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/BehavioralEquivalence.h within header-size limit (141 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step455_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (194 lines)

Step 456: Transpilation Confidence Scoring

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements deterministic confidence scoring categories and review gating for translated functions, including aggregated report statistics.

Files added:

• editor/src/TranspilationConfidence.h — confidence scorer:
  • category model (DirectStdLib, AlgorithmPattern, StructuralWithIntent, StructuralNoIntent, Unknown)
  • deterministic score mapping (0.95 / 0.85 / 0.70 / 0.50 / 0.30)
  • low-confidence review gating (@Review(required,human) when < 0.60)
  • per-function score output + batch report aggregation APIs
• editor/tests/step456_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • category classification and score assignment
  • annotation/review behavior for high vs low confidence
  • scoreAll aggregation, category/review counters, average score
  • function-score lookup and default no-intent behavior
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step456_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step456_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step456_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step455_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/TranspilationConfidence.h within header-size limit (153 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step456_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (155 lines)

Step 457: Translation Report

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds per-function and project-level transpilation reporting, including mapping shape, confidence, annotation deltas, safety delta, idiomatic/literal split, and review-flag rollups.

Files added:

• editor/src/TranslationReport.h — report generator:
  • function-level report model with construct mapping, confidence, rationale, safety delta, and annotation-change tracking
  • project summary metrics: total, idiomatic/literal counts, review flags, and percentage rollups
  • integration with intent translation + confidence scorer
• editor/tests/step457_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • per-function presence and retrieval behavior
  • summary counts and percentage calculations
  • annotation/rationale generation
  • safety delta behavior for c→rust and rust→c
  • intent override impact on confidence path
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step457_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step457_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step457_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step456_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/TranslationReport.h within header-size limit (174 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step457_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (168 lines)

Step 458: Transpilation RPC + MCP

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Exposes semantic transpilation/reporting/equivalence/confidence as JSON-RPC handlers and MCP tool definitions.

Files added:

• editor/src/TranspilationRPC.h — RPC + MCP handler:
  • JSON handlers:
    • transpile
    • getTranslationReport
    • verifyEquivalence
    • getConfidence
  • canHandle + dispatch integration shape (JSON-RPC 2.0 envelope)
  • MCP tool definitions:
    • whetstone_transpile
    • whetstone_get_translation_report
    • whetstone_verify_equivalence
    • whetstone_get_confidence
  • JSON serialization helpers for confidence/report/equivalence payloads
• editor/tests/step458_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • handler method coverage and dispatch behavior
  • result schema/content validation for each RPC method
  • unknown-method error envelope
  • MCP tool definition count/names/schema-required fields
  • low-confidence review and no-intent review behavior
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step458_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step458_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step458_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step457_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/TranspilationRPC.h within header-size limit (255 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step458_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (193 lines)

Step 459: Phase 21b Integration + Sprint 21 Summary

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Adds end-to-end integration coverage for semantic transpilation, report generation, confidence scoring, equivalence checks, and RPC/MCP surface.

Files added:

• editor/tests/step459_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  • semantic transpile flow (Python→Rust) with confidence follow-up
  • translation report rationale/summary validation
  • low-confidence auto-review behavior
  • equivalence assertion generation
  • full JSON-RPC dispatch flow and unknown-method handling
  • MCP tool surface completeness for Phase 21b tools
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step459_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step459_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step459_test — PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step458_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/tests/step459_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (167 lines)
• No new production header introduced in this integration step

Sprint 21 totals:

• Steps: 449-459 (11 steps)
• Tests: 124/124 passing
• Headers created: 9
  • IntentTranslator.h
  • AlgorithmEquivalence.h
  • TypeSystemTranslator.h
  • ConcurrencyTranslator.h
  • MemoryModelTranslator.h
  • BehavioralEquivalence.h
  • TranspilationConfidence.h
  • TranslationReport.h
  • TranspilationRPC.h
• MCP tools added: 4
  • whetstone_transpile
  • whetstone_get_translation_report
  • whetstone_verify_equivalence
  • whetstone_get_confidence
• Capabilities delivered:
  • intent-driven idiomatic translation selection
  • algorithm pattern recognition and stdlib equivalence mapping
  • cross-language type model translation with lossiness annotations
  • concurrency model translation with runtime/review signals
  • ownership/lifetime memory model translation with safety deltas
  • behavioral equivalence assertion generation with contract grading
  • deterministic confidence scoring and review gating
  • per-function/project translation reporting
  • RPC + MCP interfaces for transpilation pipeline operations

Step 460: Assembly AST Nodes

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Introduces core assembly AST node model and per-node JSON serialization round-trip helpers for instructions, labels, directives, registers, and memory operands.

Files added:

• editor/src/ast/AssemblyNodes.h — new assembly node definitions:
  • AssemblyInstruction (opcode, operands, structured register/memory operands)
  • AssemblyLabel (name, isGlobal)
  • AssemblyDirective (.data, .text, .global, .section, .byte, .word, .align)
  • AssemblyRegister (name + bit width)
  • AssemblyMemoryOperand (base/index/scale/offset addressing components)
  • directive enum/string conversion helpers
  • JSON serialization/deserialization helpers for all node types
• editor/tests/step460_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • node construction and field integrity for all assembly node types
  • directive enum/string mapping
  • JSON round-trip for each node type
  • structured operand round-trip in instructions
  • unknown directive fallback behavior
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step460_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step460_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step460_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step459_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/AssemblyNodes.h within header-size limit (200 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step460_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (160 lines)

Step 461: x86 Assembly Parser

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements x86 assembly parsing with Intel/AT&T syntax mode support, including labels, directives, core instructions, register recognition, and memory addressing extraction.

Files added:

• editor/src/ast/X86AssemblyParser.h — x86 parser:
  • syntax-mode support (Intel, ATT)
  • parses directives (.section, .global, .data, .text, etc.)
  • parses labels into function shells (label + instruction body)
  • parses instructions with operand splitting respecting address delimiters
  • register recognition + inferred register size (8/16/32/64)
  • Intel memory addressing parse ([rbp-8], [rax+rbx*4+8])
  • AT&T memory addressing parse (-8(%rbp,%rbx,4))
  • warning diagnostics for unknown/unrecognized opcode lines
  • section directives represented as namespace-like nodes (NamespaceDeclaration)
• editor/tests/step461_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • Intel and AT&T instruction parsing
  • global label detection
  • directive/section parsing behavior
  • register-size recognition across register families
  • Intel + AT&T memory addressing extraction
  • comment stripping behavior
  • known-opcode vs unknown-opcode diagnostics
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step461_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step461_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step461_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step460_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/X86AssemblyParser.h within header-size limit (299 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step461_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (186 lines)

Step 462: ARM Assembly Parser

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements ARM/AArch64 assembly parsing for core instructions, registers, addressing modes, directives, and label/function shaping.

Files added:

• editor/src/ast/ArmAssemblyParser.h — ARM parser:
  • parses ARM/AArch64 instructions (mov, add, sub, ldr, str, b, bl, cmp, conditional branches, ret)
  • register recognition for r0-r15, x0-x30, sp, lr, pc
  • ARM memory addressing extraction:
    • [r0]
    • [r0, #4]
    • [r0, r1, LSL #2]
  • directive handling (.global, .text, .data, .word, .align, .section)
  • section-as-namespace shaping via NamespaceDeclaration
  • warning diagnostics for unknown opcodes
• editor/tests/step462_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • ARM and AArch64 instruction/register parsing
  • special register handling
  • all required addressing forms
  • directive and section handling
  • branch/call opcode coverage
  • unknown-opcode warning behavior
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step462_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step462_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step462_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step461_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/ArmAssemblyParser.h within header-size limit (245 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step462_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (173 lines)

Step 463: Assembly Generator — x86 + ARM

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds assembly code generation for x86 and ARM from AST, plus a simple cross-architecture instruction mapper for straightforward x86→ARM projection.

Files added:

• editor/src/ast/AssemblyGenerator.h — generator and mapper:
  • generateX86 with Intel/AT&T syntax mode support
  • generateArm output path
  • translateX86ToArmSimple mapping for core opcodes (mov/add/sub/cmp/jmp/call/ret)
  • architecture comment prefixes (x86 -> "; ", arm -> "@ ")
  • directive/section emission from module and namespace-like section nodes
• editor/tests/step463_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • x86 Intel/AT&T generation behavior
  • ARM generation behavior
  • directive/section emission
  • x86→ARM opcode mapping including control flow
  • unknown-opcode passthrough
  • comment prefix semantics
  • parse→generate→parse roundtrip sanity check for x86
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step463_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step463_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step463_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step462_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/AssemblyGenerator.h within header-size limit (167 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step463_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (147 lines)

Step 464: Assembly Annotation Mapping

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds assembly-aware semantic annotation mapping with complexity heuristics, register-pressure analysis, alignment mapping, and lightweight C↔assembly projection helpers.

Files added:

• editor/src/ast/AssemblyAnnotationMapper.h — annotation mapper:
  • baseline annotations for assembly functions:
    • @Exec(native)
    • @Risk(high)
    • @Target(x86|arm)
    • @Complexity(low|medium|high)
  • .align directive mapping to @Align(...)
  • complexity scoring from instruction count, branch density, register pressure
  • register-pressure estimation via unique register cardinality
  • cross-language helpers:
    • lowerCToAssembly(...)
    • liftAssemblyToC(...)
• editor/tests/step464_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • required annotation emission
  • complexity tiering behavior
  • branch/register-pressure metrics
  • target architecture inference
  • C→assembly lowering and assembly→C lifting stubs
  • alignment annotation derivation
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step464_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step464_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step464_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step463_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/AssemblyAnnotationMapper.h within header-size limit (128 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step464_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (177 lines)

Step 465: Phase 22a Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Adds Phase 22a integration coverage across x86/ARM parsing, simple cross-architecture translation, annotation mapping, lift/lower helpers, and assembly node round-trip serialization.

Files added:

• editor/tests/step465_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  • realistic x86 parse to valid AST
  • realistic ARM parse to valid AST
  • x86→ARM simple instruction mapping
  • assembly→C lifting stub generation
  • C→assembly lowering shape checks (x86 + ARM)
  • annotation usefulness checks on assembly functions
  • parse→annotate→generate end-to-end ARM flow
  • assembly node JSON round-trip
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step465_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step465_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step465_test — PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step464_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/tests/step465_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (150 lines)
• No new production header introduced in this integration step

Phase 22a totals (460-465):

• Steps: 6
• Tests: 68/68 passing
• Headers added: 5
  • ast/AssemblyNodes.h
  • ast/X86AssemblyParser.h
  • ast/ArmAssemblyParser.h
  • ast/AssemblyGenerator.h
  • ast/AssemblyAnnotationMapper.h
• Capabilities delivered:
  • assembly AST node model with JSON round-trip helpers
  • x86 parser (Intel + AT&T) with label/directive/addressing support
  • ARM/AArch64 parser with addressing mode support
  • x86/ARM code generation + simple x86→ARM opcode mapping
  • assembly semantic annotation mapping (@Exec, @Target, @Risk, @Complexity, @Align)

Step 466: Range-Based For + Structured Bindings

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds focused support for C++ range-based for and structured binding forms, including parse helpers, JSON round-trip, code generation, and cross-language projection of range loops.

Files added:

• editor/src/ast/CppRangeStructured.h — feature-gap helpers:
  • RangeForStatement node model
  • StructuredBinding node model
  • parse helpers:
    • parseRangeFor(...)
    • parseStructuredBinding(...)
  • JSON round-trip helpers for both constructs
  • C++ generation helpers for both constructs
  • range-for projection helpers to Python, Rust, Java
• editor/tests/step466_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • parsing of const-ref and simple range-for forms
  • parsing of structured bindings (2 and 3 names)
  • JSON round-trip behavior
  • C++ generation for both constructs
  • Python/Rust/Java projection checks
  • graceful parse failure on invalid inputs
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step466_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step466_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step466_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step465_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/CppRangeStructured.h within header-size limit (150 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step466_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (163 lines)

Step 467: Exception Handling

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds C++ exception-handling gap coverage for try/catch clauses, throw expressions, noexcept detection, JSON round-trip, and cross-language exception model projections.

Files added:

• editor/src/ast/CppExceptions.h — exception helper model:
  • TryCatchStatement, CatchClause, ThrowExpression
  • parse helpers:
    • parseTryCatch(...)
    • parseThrowExpression(...)
    • hasNoexcept(...)
  • JSON round-trip helpers for try/catch and throw expression
  • projections:
    • C++ try/catch → Rust Result/match
    • C++ try/catch → Python try/except
    • C++ try/catch → Go if err != nil
• editor/tests/step467_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • single and multi-catch parsing
  • catch-all parsing
  • throw expression parsing
  • noexcept detection
  • JSON round-trip
  • Rust/Python/Go projection checks
  • invalid parse failure behavior
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step467_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step467_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step467_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step466_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/CppExceptions.h within header-size limit (178 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step467_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (148 lines)

Step 468: Operator Overloading + Friend

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds focused support for C++ operator-overload declarations, including friend operator forms, JSON round-trip, declaration generation, and projections to named methods in Java/Python.

Files added:

• editor/src/ast/CppOperators.h — operator-overload helpers:
  • OperatorOverload node model (operatorSymbol, params, return type, isFriend, isConst)
  • parser for member and friend operator declarations
  • JSON round-trip helpers
  • C++ declaration generation
  • cross-language projection:
    • < → Java compareTo, Python __lt__
    • == → Java equals, Python __eq__
    • << → display/string projection methods
• editor/tests/step468_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • parsing member/friend overload forms
  • const/friend flag behavior
  • invalid declaration rejection
  • JSON round-trip and declaration generation
  • Java/Python projection behavior for key operators
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step468_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step468_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step468_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step467_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/CppOperators.h within header-size limit (129 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step468_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (152 lines)

Step 469: Initializer Lists + STL Patterns

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds focused support for C++ initializer-list parsing plus STL container and iterator-loop pattern recognition with lightweight annotation outputs.

Files added:

• editor/src/ast/CppInitializerStl.h — initializer/STL helpers:
  • InitializerListExpression model
  • initializer-list parser
  • STL container recognition (vector, map, set, string)
  • element-type extraction from template arguments
  • iterator-loop pattern detector with @Loop(iterator) annotation
  • JSON round-trip helpers for initializer-list node
• editor/tests/step469_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • initializer-list parsing and round-trip
  • STL container kind/type recognition
  • container annotation output checks
  • iterator-pattern detection (begin/end, auto it) and non-iterator negative case
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step469_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step469_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step469_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step468_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ast/CppInitializerStl.h within header-size limit (135 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step469_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (138 lines)

Step 470: Phase 22b Integration + Sprint 22 Summary

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Adds Phase 22b integration coverage across remaining C++ feature-gap modules and self-hosting signal checks against TransformEngineExtended.h.

Files added:

• editor/tests/step470_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  • self-host file signal checks (inheritance + protected section presence)
  • combined parse path across range-for/structured-binding/operator/initializer modules
  • exception + operator projection availability
  • STL iterator detection and annotation path
  • JSON round-trip checks across new Step 466-469 nodes
  • invalid-input regression checks
  • cross-language projection output shape checks
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step470_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step470_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step470_test — PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step469_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/tests/step470_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (157 lines)
• No new production header introduced in this integration step

Sprint 22 totals:

• Steps: 460-470 (11 steps)
• Tests: 124/124 passing
• Headers added: 9
  • ast/AssemblyNodes.h
  • ast/X86AssemblyParser.h
  • ast/ArmAssemblyParser.h
  • ast/AssemblyGenerator.h
  • ast/AssemblyAnnotationMapper.h
  • ast/CppRangeStructured.h
  • ast/CppExceptions.h
  • ast/CppOperators.h
  • ast/CppInitializerStl.h
• Capabilities delivered:
  • assembly AST support (x86 + ARM/AArch64) with parse/generate paths
  • cross-architecture x86→ARM simple instruction mapping
  • assembly annotation model (@Exec, @Target, @Risk, @Complexity, @Align)
  • C++ gap coverage for:
    • range-based for loops
    • structured bindings
    • try/catch/throw/noexcept patterns
    • operator overloading + friend operators
    • initializer lists + STL/iterator pattern detection

Step 471: Problem Description Parser

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Starts Sprint 23 architect mode by extracting structured requirements from natural-language problem descriptions with per-item confidence scores.

Files added:

• editor/src/ArchitectProblemParser.h — structured requirement parser:
  • output model: functional, non-functional, platform, integration buckets
  • heuristic keyword extraction with confidence scoring
  • deduplication behavior for repeated terms
  • fallback functional requirement when extraction is sparse
• editor/tests/step471_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • functional/non-functional/platform/integration extraction
  • confidence range behavior
  • case-insensitive matching and dedupe
  • fallback behavior
  • mixed multi-category prompt extraction
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step471_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step471_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step471_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step470_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ArchitectProblemParser.h within header-size limit (114 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step471_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (157 lines)

Step 472: Module Decomposition Engine

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements strategy-aware module decomposition from structured requirements, with module graph nodes/edges, cross-cutting concerns, and complexity scoring.

Files added:

• editor/src/ArchitectModuleDecomposer.h — module decomposition engine:
  • decomposition strategies:
    • Layered
    • Monolith
    • Microservice
  • module graph model (ModuleNode, ModuleEdge, ModuleGraph)
  • inferred modules from requirements (auth/api/ui/data/search/reporting/notifications/integrations)
  • cross-cutting module insertion (logging/config/error/security/observability)
  • strategy-specific dependency edge shaping
  • normalized complexity scoring with dependency influence
  • helper APIs (hasModule, dependency counting)
• editor/tests/step472_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • module inference from requirement categories
  • strategy-specific edge behavior
  • cross-cutting concern insertion
  • complexity clamping
  • monolith core-hub behavior
  • sparse-input fallback behavior
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step472_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step472_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step472_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step471_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ArchitectModuleDecomposer.h within header-size limit (212 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step472_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (156 lines)

Step 473: Technology Stack Selector

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements per-module technology stack selection from requirements + module graph, including language/framework/database choices, rationale, confidence, and preference overrides.

Files added:

• editor/src/ArchitectTechStackSelector.h — stack decision engine:
  • output model: TechChoice, TechStackDecision
  • strategy-informed module stack selection for UI/API/auth/data/integrations/etc.
  • backend/frontend/database preference overrides
  • language/framework/database heuristics with rationale/confidence
  • fallback behavior for sparse graphs
• editor/tests/step473_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • UI/frontend stack selection
  • performance/security-driven backend language selection
  • database selection from integration requirements
  • preference override behavior (backend/db/frontend)
  • integration module adapter stack behavior
  • confidence range checks
  • per-module coverage and fallback decision behavior
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step473_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step473_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step473_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step472_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ArchitectTechStackSelector.h within header-size limit (156 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step473_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (168 lines)

Step 474: Skeleton Generation from Requirements

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Builds an annotated multi-module skeleton project spec from requirements, module graph, and technology choices, including routing/contract/dependency annotations suitable for workflow creation.

Files added:

• editor/src/ArchitectSkeletonGenerator.h — skeleton generator:
  • output model:
    • SkeletonAnnotation
    • SkeletonFunctionSpec
    • SkeletonModuleSpec
    • SkeletonProjectSpec
  • module-level skeleton assembly from stack decisions
  • function stub generation by module role (api/auth/ui/data/etc.)
  • annotation generation:
    • @Intent
    • @Complexity
    • @ContextWidth
    • @Automatability
    • @Contract
  • dependency capture from module graph edges
  • sparse/partial stack fallback behavior
• editor/tests/step474_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • module and language propagation from graph + stack
  • function skeleton generation by module
  • annotation presence and value behavior
  • dependency propagation
  • context/automatability routing semantics
  • contract enrichment under security requirements
  • sparse-input fallback behavior
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step474_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step474_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step474_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step473_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ArchitectSkeletonGenerator.h within header-size limit (198 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step474_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (187 lines)

Step 475: Architect Review Interface

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements a structured architect review state with snapshot/summary generation and concrete modification actions (language change, merge, add, routing adjustment, approval).

Files added:

• editor/src/ArchitectReviewInterface.h — review interface model:
  • review state/snapshot models:
    • ArchitectReviewState
    • ArchitectReviewSnapshot
    • ModuleReviewSummary
  • review actions:
    • changeModuleLanguage(...)
    • mergeModules(...)
    • addModule(...)
    • adjustRouting(...)
    • approve(...)
  • change-log tracking and graph remapping after merges
  • key-annotation extraction for review summaries
• editor/tests/step475_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • summary snapshot content
  • language change behavior
  • module merge success/failure paths
  • module add success/failure paths
  • routing adjustment success/failure paths
  • approval and change-log behavior
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step475_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step475_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step475_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step474_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ArchitectReviewInterface.h within header-size limit (231 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step475_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (171 lines)

Step 476: Phase 23a Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Adds full Phase 23a integration coverage for architect mode: problem description parsing → module decomposition → tech stack selection → skeleton generation → architect review/approval → workflow task materialization.

Files added:

• editor/tests/step476_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  • end-to-end extraction/decomposition/selection flow for bookstore API scenario
  • frontend/database stack expectation checks
  • skeleton annotation presence checks
  • architect review modifications + approval
  • workflow task creation after approval
  • dependency graph and structured review snapshot checks
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step476_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step476_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step476_test — PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step475_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/tests/step476_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (148 lines)
• No new production header introduced in this integration step

Phase 23a totals (471-476):

• Steps: 6
• Tests: 68/68 passing
• Headers added: 5
  • ArchitectProblemParser.h
  • ArchitectModuleDecomposer.h
  • ArchitectTechStackSelector.h
  • ArchitectSkeletonGenerator.h
  • ArchitectReviewInterface.h
• Capabilities delivered:
  • natural-language requirement extraction with confidence
  • strategy-aware module decomposition graph generation
  • per-module tech stack selection with preference overrides
  • annotated multi-module skeleton generation
  • architect review/modify/approve state model
  • end-to-end architect-mode flow readiness for phase 23b scaffolding

Step 477: Architect Templates

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Introduces reusable architecture templates that instantiate starter module layouts, dependencies, function stubs, and annotations for common product shapes (REST API, CLI, library, microservice, full stack).

Files added:

• editor/src/ArchitectTemplates.h — template library:
  • ArchitectureTemplateKind, TemplateInput, TemplateOutput
  • ArchitectTemplates::instantiate(...)
  • template-specific module graphs and function stubs
  • default annotation emission for generated functions:
    • @Intent
    • @Complexity
    • @ContextWidth
    • @Automatability
    • @Contract
• editor/tests/step477_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • expected module sets for each template kind
  • annotation presence on generated function stubs
  • primaryEntity parameterization (e.g. createBook)
  • dependency expectations (e.g. routes -> handlers)
  • template metadata notes and language defaults
  • non-empty outputs across all template kinds
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step477_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step477_test step476_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step477_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step476_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ArchitectTemplates.h within header-size limit (182 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step477_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (166 lines)
• Naming/style aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md conventions (PascalCase types, camelCase functions)

Step 478: Scaffold File Generation

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds concrete scaffold generation from approved skeletons, including source files, stack-specific project config, .gitignore, and .whetstone state files, with operation plans compatible with fileCreate/fileWrite.

Files added:

• editor/src/ArchitectScaffoldGenerator.h — scaffold planner/applier:
  • ScaffoldInput, ScaffoldFileSpec, ScaffoldOperation, ScaffoldPlan
  • buildPlan(...) to derive file tree + operation queue from skeleton modules
  • source rendering with Semanno annotation comments and per-language stubs
  • config generation:
    • package.json (JS/TS)
    • pyproject.toml (Python)
    • Cargo.toml (Rust)
    • CMakeLists.txt (C/C++)
  • .gitignore composition based on selected languages
  • .whetstone/workflow_state.json + sidecar module files
  • applyPlan(...) executing fileCreate/fileWrite-style operations via existing file ops
• editor/tests/step478_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • Semanno annotations in generated source files
  • stack-specific config file generation
  • language convention path mapping (TS/Go/SQL)
  • .gitignore entries by stack
  • .whetstone workflow + sidecar generation
  • operation queue shape (fileCreate + fileWrite pairs)
  • on-disk apply behavior and idempotency
  • empty-skeleton baseline generation
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step478_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step478_test step477_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step478_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step477_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ArchitectScaffoldGenerator.h within header-size limit (358 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step478_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (224 lines)
• Header-only architecture preserved; naming conventions remain PascalCase types and camelCase methods

Step 479: Dependency + Build System Awareness

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds annotation-level dependency/build awareness derived from module graph dependencies so scaffolded modules carry structured hints for packaging, imports/includes, and SQL migration order.

Files added:

• editor/src/ArchitectBuildAwareness.h — dependency/build annotation engine:
  • BuildDependencyAnnotation, BuildAwarenessReport
  • annotate(...) for per-module build/dependency hints by language:
    • Python import hints + pip-style dependency snippet
    • Rust Cargo.toml [dependencies] snippet + local crate path links
    • Node/TypeScript package.json-style dependency snippet + import hints
    • C/C++ include hints + CMake target/link snippet
    • SQL migration ordering annotations with dependency-derived order
  • deterministic SQL cycle fallback behavior for stable ordering
• editor/tests/step479_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • language-specific manifest/import annotation generation
  • dependency preservation and mixed-language report coverage
  • SQL migration ordering and cycle fallback
  • no-dependency and unknown-language edge cases
  • global note/disclaimer presence for annotation scope
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step479_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step479_test step478_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step479_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step478_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ArchitectBuildAwareness.h within header-size limit (208 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step479_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (186 lines)
• Conventions aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md (PascalCase structs, camelCase methods, header-only)

Step 480: Multi-Language Project Orchestration

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Introduces a single-project orchestration planner for multi-language module graphs with deterministic build ordering and explicit cross-language interface boundaries (@Link, @Shim) flagged for human review.

Files added:

• editor/src/ArchitectMultiLanguageOrchestrator.h — orchestration planner:
  • CrossLanguageLink, OrchestrationTask, MultiLanguageWorkflowPlan
  • createWorkflow(...) producing:
    • one task per module
    • dependency-respecting build order
    • cross-language link records with:
      • @Link(from->to)
      • @Shim(source_to_target)
      • ffiBoundary = true, reviewRequired = true
  • integration of build hints from ArchitectBuildAwareness
  • cycle fallback to deterministic lexical ordering with explicit note
• editor/tests/step480_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • task generation for all modules in a single workflow
  • dependency-order correctness
  • cross-language link/shim emission
  • FFI review gating behavior
  • cycle fallback completeness
  • link direction correctness
  • single-language no-link behavior
  • propagation of build-awareness hints into tasks
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step480_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step480_test step479_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step480_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step479_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ArchitectMultiLanguageOrchestrator.h within header-size limit (175 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step480_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (203 lines)
• Header-only and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 481: Phase 23b Integration + Sprint Summary

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Adds an integrated architect pipeline for Phase 23b that composes: template instantiation, scaffold file planning/application, dependency/build awareness, and multi-language orchestration into a single structured flow.

Files added:

• editor/src/ArchitectProjectPipeline.h — integration composition layer:
  • ArchitectPipelineResult aggregate output model
  • fromTemplate(...):
    • ArchitectTemplates -> ArchitectScaffoldGenerator -> ArchitectBuildAwareness -> ArchitectMultiLanguageOrchestrator
  • fromSkeleton(...) for direct skeleton-based orchestration
  • overrideModuleLanguage(...) for mid-planning stack adjustment/replan flow
• editor/tests/step481_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  • REST API template -> scaffold -> workflow end-to-end
  • multi-language Python+Rust+SQL orchestration as one project plan
  • mid-planning language override and scaffold regeneration
  • Semanno annotations present in scaffolded source files
  • scaffold apply materialization (.whetstone + project files)
  • cross-language shim/review flags
  • sidecar generation completeness
  • structured output shape for MCP consumers
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step481_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step481_test step480_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step481_test — PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step480_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ArchitectProjectPipeline.h within header-size limit (58 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step481_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (156 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Phase 23b totals (477-481):

• Steps: 5
• Tests: 56/56 passing
• Headers added: 5
  • ArchitectTemplates.h
  • ArchitectScaffoldGenerator.h
  • ArchitectBuildAwareness.h
  • ArchitectMultiLanguageOrchestrator.h
  • ArchitectProjectPipeline.h
• Capabilities delivered:
  • reusable architecture templates for common project archetypes
  • scaffold planning/application via fileCreate/fileWrite-compatible ops
  • language-specific dependency/build hint annotation layer
  • single-plan orchestration across multi-language module graphs with @Link/@Shim
  • integrated Phase 23b pipeline with mid-planning language override/replan support

Sprint 23 totals (471-481):

• Steps: 11
• Tests: 124/124 passing
• Headers added: 10
• Outcome: architect mode now supports requirement parsing, decomposition, stack selection, skeleton generation, review/approval, template/scaffold generation, dependency-aware build hints, and multi-language orchestration.

Step 482: Step Spec Expander

Status: PASS (9/9 tests)

Begins Phase 23c self-hosting by adding a step-spec expansion engine that turns sprint-step markdown into structured worker handoff artifacts: test plan stubs, header skeleton outline, and build-system entry.

Files added:

• editor/src/StepSpecExpander.h — expansion engine:
  • StepSpec, StepExpanderInput, PlannedTestStub, HeaderSkeletonStub, BuildEntryStub
  • complexity classification:
    • Trivial (1-4 tests)
    • Standard (5-10 tests)
    • Complex (10-15 tests)
    • Pipeline (6-10 tests)
  • heuristic test-type planning from step text:
    • unit / negative / boundary / integration / smoke / regression
  • complexity-budget enforcement and deterministic test naming
  • header skeleton and build-entry stub generation (cmake + fallback systems)
• editor/tests/step482_test.cpp — 9 tests (unit/negative/boundary focus) covering:
  • complexity classification behavior
  • negative/boundary test injection heuristics
  • naming convention for generated test stubs
  • header/build skeleton output shape
  • empty-input warning path
  • complexity budget range enforcement
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step482_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step482_test step481_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step482_test — PASS (9/9)
• ./editor/build-native/step481_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/StepSpecExpander.h within header-size limit (267 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step482_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (149 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 483: Convention Extractor + Validator

Status: PASS (9/9 tests)

Adds machine-readable project convention extraction and warning-level validation for generated step artifacts, enabling architect review of worker output conformance.

Files added:

• editor/src/ProjectConventionAnalyzer.h — extractor + validator:
  • ProjectConventions, SourceFileDraft
  • ConventionViolation, ConventionValidationReport
  • extract(repoRoot):
    • parses architecture limits (header, main.cpp, function)
    • detects build target pattern from editor/CMakeLists.txt
    • detects test harness conventions from step test files
  • validate(conventions, files) warning checks:
    • header/main line-limit violations
    • missing test assertions (CHECK/assert)
    • class/struct naming mismatch (PascalCase)
    • missing step test target in CMake snippet
• editor/tests/step483_test.cpp — 9 tests (unit/negative/regression):
  • extraction correctness from repo docs/build files
  • negative cases for size, assertions, naming, and build entry violations
  • valid-file acceptance path
  • regression validation against Step 482 outputs
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step483_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step483_test step482_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step483_test — PASS (9/9)
• ./editor/build-native/step482_test — PASS (9/9) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ProjectConventionAnalyzer.h within header-size limit (223 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step483_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (146 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 484: Prior-Step Context Injector

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Adds prior-step API/context injection so worker-facing briefs can include condensed type/method summaries and include dependencies instead of full headers.

Files added:

• editor/src/PriorStepContextInjector.h — context extraction layer:
  • ApiTypeSummary, ApiMethodSummary, StepContext
  • build(headerPaths):
    • parses class/struct names from prior headers
    • extracts declaration/definition-level method signatures
    • records include dependency graph from #include "..." lines
    • infers naming patterns from type suffixes (Spec, State, Report)
    • emits warnings for missing/unreadable headers
  • condensedBrief() for prompt-sized worker context summaries
• editor/tests/step484_test.cpp — 8 tests (unit/integration) covering:
  • type extraction from real prior-step headers
  • method signature extraction and declaration-only shape checks
  • include graph construction
  • naming pattern detection
  • condensed brief content
  • missing-header warning behavior
  • multi-header integration behavior
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step484_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step484_test step483_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step484_test — PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step483_test — PASS (9/9) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/PriorStepContextInjector.h within header-size limit (125 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step484_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (120 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 485: Worker Dispatch + Result Validation

Status: PASS (10/10 tests)

Implements the architect->worker dispatch protocol model for Phase 23c: prepare spec/context/conventions, validate worker output, enforce retry budget, and escalate unresolved submissions to architect review.

Files added:

• editor/src/WorkerDispatchValidator.h — dispatch orchestration model:
  • WorkerDispatchInput, WorkerSubmission, DispatchAttemptReport, WorkerDispatchResult
  • run(...):
    • builds StepSpec via StepSpecExpander
    • builds StepContext via PriorStepContextInjector
    • extracts ProjectConventions via ProjectConventionAnalyzer
    • validates each worker submission (build/tests/conventions)
    • retries up to configurable budget (default 3)
    • marks completion only when build+tests pass and no convention warnings
    • escalates on exhausted retries or missing submissions
  • buildWorkerBrief(...) condensed handoff text for worker prompts
• editor/tests/step485_test.cpp — 10 tests (unit/integration/negative):
  • pre-dispatch artifact generation (spec/context/conventions)
  • successful first-attempt acceptance
  • retry-after-failure success path
  • retry-budget exhaustion escalation
  • convention-violation reporting path
  • build-failure status propagation
  • empty-submission negative case
  • default retry-budget behavior
  • worker brief content checks
  • acceptance gate requiring both build and tests
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step485_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step485_test step484_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step485_test — PASS (10/10)
• ./editor/build-native/step484_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/WorkerDispatchValidator.h within header-size limit (145 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step485_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (165 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 486: Test Plan Generator

Status: PASS (10/10 tests)

Implements the test-plan intelligence layer for Phase 23c: proposes typed, named tests from step semantics and complexity budgets instead of fixed test counts.

Files added:

• editor/src/TestPlanGenerator.h — adaptive test-plan engine:
  • TestPlanInput, GeneratedTestPlan, TestPatternSample
  • typed test proposal across taxonomy:
    • unit / negative / integration / contract / regression / boundary / property / smoke / performance
  • keyword heuristics aligned to sprint plan:
    • validate/detect -> negative
    • pipeline/workflow -> integration
    • RPC/MCP -> smoke
    • score/boundary/max/min -> boundary
    • modify-existing -> regression
  • prior-test pattern influence for regression continuity
  • complexity-aware budget enforcement:
    • trivial: 1-4
    • standard: 5-10
    • complex: 10-15
    • pipeline: 6-10
• editor/tests/step486_test.cpp — 10 tests (unit/boundary/negative focus):
  • heuristic inclusion checks by keyword class
  • regression inference from prior test patterns
  • budget range checks under explicit complexity hint
  • generated test name convention checks
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step486_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step486_test step485_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step486_test — PASS (10/10)
• ./editor/build-native/step485_test — PASS (10/10) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/TestPlanGenerator.h within header-size limit (191 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step486_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (118 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 487: Phase 23c Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Completes Phase 23c by validating the full self-hosting data flow: sprint step description -> conventions extraction -> prior-context injection -> step spec expansion -> adaptive test plan generation -> output validation on known-good and deliberately-broken step artifacts.

Files added:

• editor/src/SelfHostingIntegration.h — phase integration composition:
  • SelfHostingInput, SelfHostingResult
  • run(...) flow:
    • ProjectConventionAnalyzer::extract(...)
    • PriorStepContextInjector::build(...)
    • StepSpecExpander::expand(...)
    • TestPlanGenerator::generate(...)
    • convention validation for known-good and known-broken step files
  • worker-readiness sufficiency gate (workerReady) over spec/context/ conventions/test-plan completeness
• editor/tests/step487_test.cpp — 8 integration/regression tests covering:
  • full flow population of conventions/context/spec/test-plan
  • worker readiness sufficiency for realistic step input
  • pipeline heuristic propagation into generated test types
  • zero-violation validation for known-good step output
  • violation detection for deliberately-broken output
  • flow-note and context-summary checks
  • regression expectation alignment with Step 486 behavior
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step487_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step487_test step486_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step487_test — PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step486_test — PASS (10/10) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SelfHostingIntegration.h within header-size limit (80 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step487_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (126 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Phase 23c totals (482-487):

• Steps: 6
• Tests: 54/54 passing
• Headers added: 6
  • StepSpecExpander.h
  • ProjectConventionAnalyzer.h
  • PriorStepContextInjector.h
  • WorkerDispatchValidator.h
  • TestPlanGenerator.h
  • SelfHostingIntegration.h
• Capabilities delivered:
  • step-to-spec expansion with complexity-bounded test planning
  • machine-readable convention extraction + warning validator
  • prior-step API context briefing for worker prompts
  • dispatch/retry/escalation protocol model for architect-worker handoff
  • adaptive typed test-plan generation (taxonomy-aware)
  • end-to-end self-hosting protocol validation

Final Sprint 23 totals (471-487):

• Steps: 17
• Tests: 178/178 passing
• Headers added: 16
• Outcome: architect mode now spans full planning stack and self-hosting protocol: requirements -> decomposition -> stack selection -> skeleton -> review -> templates/scaffolding -> build/dependency awareness -> multi-language orchestration -> step spec/context/convention/test-plan synthesis -> dispatch/validation -> phase-level integration validation.

Step 488: Security-Preserving Translation

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Starts Sprint 24 Phase 24b by adding a security-preserving annotation translation layer so security metadata is carried into target-language representations and never silently dropped during transpilation.

Files added:

• editor/src/SecurityPreservingTranslation.h — security annotation mapper:
  • SecurityTranslationInput, SecuritySourceAnnotation
  • SecurityMappedAnnotation, SecurityTranslationOutput
  • translate(...) mapping behavior:
    • @InputValidation mapped to target-language validation forms
    • @TrustBoundary preserved across boundaries
    • @Auth mapped to target auth patterns
    • @Encryption mapped to target crypto library forms
    • @CORS mapped for supported targets
    • @Secrets preserved but always reviewRequired
  • strict guardrails:
    • security annotations are always preserved
    • unknown/unmappable security annotations trigger human review
    • insecure crypto values (md5, sha1) force review
• editor/tests/step488_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • per-annotation mapping behavior
  • unsupported-language review escalation
  • no-annotation edge case
  • preservation-count invariants
  • blocking-review flag semantics
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step488_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step488_test step487_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step488_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step487_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SecurityPreservingTranslation.h within header-size limit (166 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step488_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (147 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 489: Secure-by-Default Code Generation

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements secure-by-default snippet generation for high-risk operation classes so generated code starts from safe patterns instead of relying on post-hoc hardening.

Files added:

• editor/src/SecureByDefaultGenerator.h — secure generation engine:
  • SecureGenerationRequest, SecureGenerationOutput, SecureSnippetKind
  • snippet generators for:
    • SQL queries (parameterized placeholders / bind APIs)
    • input handling (@InputValidation(raw) baseline)
    • file operations (path traversal guards)
    • network calls (timeouts + TLS verification)
    • crypto operations (modern defaults + mandatory human review)
  • baseline annotation emission:
    • @Risk(security)
    • @Review(required, human)
    • optional @SecurityRequirement(...)
    • @Automatability(human) for crypto
  • weak-crypto guard (md5/sha1) escalation path
• editor/tests/step489_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • parameterized SQL enforcement
  • raw-input annotation semantics
  • path traversal checks
  • timeout/TLS requirements
  • crypto hardening defaults and human-review gating
  • base security annotation coverage across snippet kinds
  • language-specific secure path checks (Rust SQL/network)
  • secure fallback behavior for unknown languages
  • operation-name propagation and security requirement annotation
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step489_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step489_test step488_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step489_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step488_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SecureByDefaultGenerator.h within header-size limit (202 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step489_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (164 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 490: Threat Model Integration

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds threat-model integration primitives that encode trust boundaries and boundary-crossing data-flow validation requirements, emitting structured E1300-range diagnostics and overlay-ready graph data.

Files added:

• editor/src/ThreatModelIntegration.h — threat model analyzer:
  • TrustBoundary, ThreatDataFlow, ThreatModelInput
  • ThreatDiagnostic, ThreatModelOutput
  • analyze(...) capabilities:
    • module-level @ThreatModel(...) annotation requirement
    • boundary-level @TrustBoundary(...) requirements
    • cross-boundary @DataFlow(...) requirement emission
    • missing-validation detection at high-risk crossings (E1300)
    • raw-validation detection (E1301)
    • missing-boundary model diagnostic (E1302)
    • unknown validation kind diagnostic (E1303)
    • overlay node output for trust-boundary visualization
• editor/tests/step490_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • annotation emission for module/boundary/flow modeling
  • E1300/E1301/E1302/E1303 diagnostic behavior
  • sanitized-flow non-error path
  • validation-required annotation on missing checks
  • non-crossing internal-flow false-positive guard
  • overlay and empty-flow note behavior
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step490_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step490_test step489_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step490_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step489_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ThreatModelIntegration.h within header-size limit (126 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step490_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (167 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 491: Security Testing Skeleton Generation

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds security-focused test skeleton generation so threat-relevant test coverage is scaffolded alongside code and routed by complexity/risk.

Files added:

• editor/src/SecurityTestSkeletonGenerator.h — security test skeleton engine:
  • SecurityTestKind, SecurityTestCaseSpec
  • SecuritySkeletonRequest, SecuritySkeletonOutput
  • generated test classes:
    • input validation fuzz
    • auth bypass
    • SQL injection probe
    • XSS payload probe
    • access control matrix
  • per-test @Intent(...) annotation generation
  • routing hints:
    • simple validation/access matrix -> slm
    • penetration-style tests -> human + humanReviewRequired
  • optional force-human behavior for complex pen-test categories
• editor/tests/step491_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • presence of each security test kind
  • intent annotation completeness
  • routing policy behavior by test complexity
  • force-human mode behavior and notes
  • module/entity propagation into test names/intent text
  • summary note emission
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step491_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step491_test step490_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step491_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step490_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SecurityTestSkeletonGenerator.h within header-size limit (140 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step491_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (164 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 492: Phase 24b Integration + Sprint Summary

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Integrates Phase 24b security components into one pipeline: security-preserving translation, secure-by-default generation, threat-model analysis, and security test skeleton generation.

Files added:

• editor/src/SecurityPipelineIntegration.h — composed security pipeline:
  • SecurityPipelineInput, SecurityPipelineResult
  • run(...) flow:
    • SecurityPreservingTranslation::translate(...)
    • SecureByDefaultGenerator::generate(...) for SQL + input handling snippets
    • ThreatModelIntegration::analyze(...)
    • SecurityTestSkeletonGenerator::generate(...)
  • pipeline notes include execution trace and blocking-review propagation
• editor/tests/step492_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  • Python->Rust security annotation preservation
  • secure-default SQL/input generation checks
  • threat-model diagnostics on missing validation
  • security test skeleton quality/routing checks
  • blocking-review propagation from translation stage
  • phase regression expectations against Step 491 behavior
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step492_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step492_test step491_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step492_test — PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step491_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SecurityPipelineIntegration.h within header-size limit (61 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step492_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (137 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Phase 24b totals (488-492):

• Steps: 5
• Tests: 56/56 passing
• Headers added: 5
  • SecurityPreservingTranslation.h
  • SecureByDefaultGenerator.h
  • ThreatModelIntegration.h
  • SecurityTestSkeletonGenerator.h
  • SecurityPipelineIntegration.h
• Capabilities delivered:
  • security annotation preservation across transpilation boundaries
  • secure-by-default generation for SQL/input/file/network/crypto patterns
  • trust boundary + data-flow threat diagnostics (E1300 range)
  • routed security test skeleton generation
  • end-to-end security pipeline integration

Step 493: Parse Full Whetstone Codebase

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Starts Sprint 25 self-hosting by auditing parser coverage across the Whetstone header corpus (editor/src/ + editor/src/ast/), including parse-rate metrics, construct counts, and skipped-construct logging.

Files added:

• editor/src/SelfHostCodebaseAudit.h — codebase parse audit layer:
  • FileParseAudit, CodebaseParseAudit
  • header discovery over target directories (.h recursive)
  • per-file parse via existing SelfHostHarness::parseFile(...)
  • per-file metrics:
    • class count
    • function count
    • annotation-node count (conceptType contains Annotation)
  • heuristic skipped-construct detection from textual hints vs parsed counts
  • aggregate parse-rate computation + target check (meetsTarget(0.95))
  • unparseable/skipped construct audit log for follow-up coverage work
• editor/tests/step493_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • real directory header discovery
  • aggregate metric sanity and parse-rate bounds
  • per-file audit shape guarantees
  • skipped/unparseable logging paths
  • threshold semantics
  • direct-file-list audit mode
  • real-corpus scale signal checks
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step493_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step493_test step492_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step493_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step492_test — PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SelfHostCodebaseAudit.h within header-size limit (139 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step493_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (172 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 494: Annotate Whetstone's Own Code

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Builds a self-host annotation audit pass over parsed Whetstone headers to measure inferred annotation signals (@Complexity, @Risk, @Owner, @Intent, @TailCall) on the codebase itself.

Files added:

• editor/src/SelfHostAnnotationAudit.h — annotation audit layer:
  • FileAnnotationAudit, SelfAnnotationAuditReport
  • integrates:
    • SelfHostHarness parsing
    • AnnotationInference::inferAll(...)
    • SafetyAuditor risk signal extraction
  • per-file/aggregate metrics:
    • inferred annotation totals
    • complexity counts
    • risk counts (safety findings + unsafe cast/pointer pattern signals)
    • owner counts (inference + smart-pointer pattern signals)
    • intent counts from descriptive function names
    • tail-call counts
  • inline-source audit mode for focused rule tests
• editor/tests/step494_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • real-corpus audit execution and parse-rate metrics
  • category signal extraction (complexity/risk/owner/intent/tailcall)
  • negative path for unparseable input
  • aggregate-vs-per-file metric consistency
  • real-corpus non-zero signal checks
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step494_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step494_test step493_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step494_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step493_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SelfHostAnnotationAudit.h within header-size limit (180 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step494_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (142 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 495: Transpile Whetstone Modules

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds a self-host transpilation audit for three concrete Whetstone headers: AnnotationConflictExtended.h -> Python, ResponseBudget.h -> Rust, Icons.h -> Java, with structure/annotation preservation and confidence metrics.

Files added:

• editor/src/SelfHostTranspileAudit.h — self-host transpilation audit layer:
  • SelfTranspileSpec, SelfTranspileFileReport, SelfTranspileAuditReport
  • default spec set for the three sprint-target headers
  • source parse (cpp) -> projection (CrossLanguageProjector) -> target generation
  • checks:
    • source parse success
    • projection success
    • annotation preservation (annotationsPreserved)
    • generated output non-empty
    • target-language parse viability
  • confidence scoring via TranspilationScorer
  • idiomatic vs literal classification derived from confidence category
  • deterministic fallback generation scaffold when primary generator returns empty
• editor/tests/step495_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • expected header/target mapping set
  • per-file audit shape and success metrics
  • non-empty generation guarantees
  • annotation-preservation checks
  • confidence and aggregate metric bounds
  • idiomatic/literal accounting and summary notes
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step495_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step495_test step494_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step495_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step494_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SelfHostTranspileAudit.h within header-size limit (178 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step495_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (139 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 496: Self-Annotated Workflow

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds a self-modernization workflow model targeting editor/src/AnnotationValidator.h, with rule-level routing across deterministic, LLM, and human-review paths and deterministic output validity checks.

Files added:

• editor/src/SelfModernizationWorkflow.h — self-improvement workflow layer:
  • ModernizationRuleSpec, ModernizationTask, ModernizationWorkflowReport
  • defaultRules() for validator modernization rule set
  • routing policy:
    • simple rules -> deterministic
    • complex rules -> llm + review
    • new diagnostic code rules -> human + critical priority
  • deterministic execution path generating validator rule stubs
  • deterministic output validation via C++ parser (Pipeline::parse)
  • aggregate routing and deterministic-validity metrics
• editor/tests/step496_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • target file and default rule taxonomy
  • routing behavior by rule complexity/type
  • deterministic code generation and parser-valid output checks
  • workflow summary/count consistency
  • diagnostic-code range semantics
  • completion-note presence
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step496_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step496_test step495_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step496_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step495_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SelfModernizationWorkflow.h within header-size limit (157 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step496_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (159 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 497: Self-Hosting Metrics Report

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds a consolidated self-hosting metrics layer that aggregates parse coverage, annotation signals, transpilation quality, and workflow viability into a single report with gap analysis.

Files added:

• editor/src/SelfHostingMetricsReport.h — metrics aggregation/reporting:
  • SelfHostingMetrics model:
    • parse coverage metrics
    • annotation signal metrics/density
    • transpilation confidence + review pressure
    • workflow task/viability metrics
    • gap analysis + notes
  • generate(...) for composed report from:
    • CodebaseParseAudit
    • SelfAnnotationAuditReport
    • SelfTranspileAuditReport
    • ModernizationWorkflowReport
  • generateFromCurrentState() convenience path that runs all upstream self-host phase components
  • threshold-based gap detection:
    • parse coverage < 95%
    • low annotation density
    • low transpilation confidence
    • non-viable deterministic modernization outputs
• editor/tests/step497_test.cpp — 12 tests covering:
  • population of all metric categories
  • deterministic gap-analysis behavior under synthetic thresholds
  • no-blocking-gap path when all thresholds pass
  • parse-coverage ratio math correctness
  • workflow viability signal semantics
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step497_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step497_test step496_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step497_test — PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step496_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SelfHostingMetricsReport.h within header-size limit (96 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step497_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (165 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 498: Phase 25a Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Integrates the full Phase 25a self-hosting pipeline: parse -> annotate -> transpile -> modernization workflow -> metrics, with thesis-level gate checks for parse coverage, transpilation breadth, and workflow viability.

Files added:

• editor/src/SelfHostingPhase25aIntegration.h — phase integration composer:
  • Phase25aIntegrationResult
  • runCurrentState() executes:
    • SelfHostCodebaseAudit
    • SelfHostAnnotationAudit
    • SelfHostTranspileAudit
    • SelfModernizationWorkflow
    • SelfHostingMetricsReport
  • gate evaluation:
    • parse coverage gate (>=95%)
    • transpilation gate (>=3 modules)
    • workflow gate (all deterministic outputs valid)
  • phase pass/fail synthesis + summary notes
• editor/tests/step498_test.cpp — 8 integration tests covering:
  • full pipeline execution
  • gate threshold semantics
  • phase pass conjunction logic
  • cross-report metric consistency
  • integration note/status behavior
• editor/CMakeLists.txt — step498_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step498_test step497_test — PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step498_test — PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step497_test — PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SelfHostingPhase25aIntegration.h within header-size limit (49 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step498_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (105 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Phase 25a totals (493-498):

• Steps: 6
• Tests: 68/68 passing
• Headers added: 6
  • SelfHostCodebaseAudit.h
  • SelfHostAnnotationAudit.h
  • SelfHostTranspileAudit.h
  • SelfModernizationWorkflow.h
  • SelfHostingMetricsReport.h
  • SelfHostingPhase25aIntegration.h
• Capabilities delivered:
  • full-header parser coverage auditing across Whetstone source
  • self-code annotation signal auditing
  • targeted self-module transpilation auditing (Python/Rust/Java)
  • self-modernization workflow routing + deterministic output validation
  • consolidated self-host metrics/gap analysis
  • phase-level self-hosting thesis gate evaluation

Step 499: Scenario - Greenfield Project

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements the first Phase 25b end-to-end scenario for: "Build a URL shortener with user accounts".

Files added:

• editor/src/GreenfieldScenarioRunner.h - scenario orchestration across:
  • problem parsing and layered decomposition
  • stack selection with explicit preferences (python, postgresql, typescript)
  • annotated skeleton generation + scaffold planning/materialization
  • task routing (deterministic / llm / human) with context bundles
  • security auditing over generated code surfaces
• editor/tests/step499_test.cpp - 12 scenario tests covering:
  • decomposition + stack expectations
  • annotation presence in generated skeleton functions
  • deterministic auto-complete, llm context preparation, and human-review surfacing
  • scaffold sidecars/workflow-state materialization on disk
  • security-findings/report shape and execution notes
• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step499_test target

Verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step499_test step498_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step499_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step498_test - PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/GreenfieldScenarioRunner.h within header-size limit (153 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step499_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (191 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 500: Scenario - Legacy Modernization

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements the second Phase 25b end-to-end scenario for modernizing a legacy C codebase with Rust as the migration target.

Files added:

• editor/src/LegacyModernizationScenarioRunner.h - scenario orchestration across:
  • legacy C ingestion and idiom detection
  • safety audit and modernization suggestion generation
  • modernization workflow generation with mixed routing
  • migration plan + execution initialization (c -> rust)
  • API boundary analysis/preservation verification
  • migration test generation from preserved API surface
• editor/tests/step500_test.cpp - 12 scenario tests covering:
  • legacy/safety finding expectations
  • Rust-target modernization suggestions (including ownership strengthening)
  • deterministic + llm workflow and migration routing
  • API boundary + FFI annotation verification
  • migration test-suite generation and scenario notes
• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step500_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step500_test step499_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step500_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step499_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/LegacyModernizationScenarioRunner.h within header-size limit (125 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step500_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (147 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 501: Scenario - Cross-Language Port

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements the third Phase 25b end-to-end scenario for porting a Python ML-style pipeline to Rust with confidence and review gating.

Files added:

• editor/src/CrossLanguagePortScenarioRunner.h - scenario orchestration across:
  • Python function intake and hot-loop tagging
  • intent-driven semantic transpilation (python -> rust)
  • memory model analysis (GC -> borrow-checked target model)
  • concurrency translation (asyncio/async-await -> Rust tokio-oriented runtime notes)
  • per-function confidence scoring and low-confidence review surfacing
  • behavioral equivalence assertion generation
• editor/tests/step501_test.cpp - 12 scenario tests covering:
  • language/source expectations and function extraction
  • hot-loop identification
  • idiomatic transpilation patterns
  • memory/concurrency translation expectations
  • confidence/review semantics
  • equivalence assertion generation and scenario notes
• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step501_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step501_test step500_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step501_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step500_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/CrossLanguagePortScenarioRunner.h within header-size limit (127 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step501_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (165 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 502: Scenario - Multi-Model Orchestration

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements the fourth Phase 25b end-to-end scenario for a 20-function project that exercises all worker classes and review gates.

Files added:

• editor/src/MultiModelOrchestrationScenarioRunner.h - scenario orchestration across:
  • 20-task synthetic project generation
  • routing through deterministic/template/slm/llm/human workers
  • deterministic/template auto-completion behavior
  • per-task token estimate vs actual token tracking
  • progress snapshots across full completion lifecycle
  • review gate tracking for LLM + human paths
• editor/tests/step502_test.cpp - 12 scenario tests covering:
  • exact routing distribution and task-group counts
  • narrow vs wide context routing semantics
  • auto-completion expectations
  • review gate exercise and cost/progress accounting
  • completion and summary notes
• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step502_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step502_test step501_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step502_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step501_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/MultiModelOrchestrationScenarioRunner.h within header-size limit (177 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step502_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (152 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 503: Phase 25b Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Integrates all four Phase 25b scenario runners (steps 499-502) into a single integration pass with scenario-level status, cost snapshots, security aggregation, workflow-path diversity checks, and event-stream completeness signals.

Files added:

• editor/src/Phase25bIntegration.h - integration compositor:
  • executes Greenfield, Legacy Modernization, Cross-Language Port, and Multi-Model scenarios
  • emits per-scenario start/complete events
  • computes per-scenario estimated vs actual token snapshots
  • validates cross-scenario path diversity and cost/event gating
  • aggregates security findings from generated code/audits
• editor/tests/step503_test.cpp - 8 integration tests covering:
  • all-scenario pass state
  • unique workflow-path signal coverage
  • cost tracking shape/accuracy gating
  • security finding aggregation
  • event stream completeness
  • integrated review-gate behavior retention
• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step503_test target

Compatibility fix applied during integration:

• editor/src/APIBoundaryPreserver.h
• editor/src/MigrationTestGenerator.h
  • renamed API migration contract struct to APIMigrationContract to resolve a symbol collision with AST ContractAnnotation when scenario headers are composed in one translation unit.

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step503_test step502_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step503_test - PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step502_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/Phase25bIntegration.h within header-size limit (229 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step503_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (97 lines)
• Updated integration dependencies remain within header-size limits:
  • editor/src/APIBoundaryPreserver.h (253 <= 600)
  • editor/src/MigrationTestGenerator.h (213 <= 600)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 504: Performance Optimization

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements a measurable optimization harness for key hot paths: AST serialization, annotation batching, context assembly caching, and compact representation generation, with sustained-run stability checks.

Files added:

• editor/src/PerformanceOptimizationSuite.h - benchmark and optimization harness:
  • baseline vs optimized timing capture per hot path
  • context assembly cache hit/miss tracking
  • per-function timing KPI calculation
  • sustained-run synthetic memory stability signal
  • optimization summary notes and target gating (<100ms/function)
• editor/tests/step504_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • baseline/optimized timing capture
  • no-regression optimization checks
  • cache effectiveness assertions
  • target threshold and repeatability checks
  • sustained-run stability + summary notes
• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step504_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step504_test step503_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step504_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step503_test - PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/PerformanceOptimizationSuite.h within header-size limit (222 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step504_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (136 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 505: MCP Tool Documentation

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements structured MCP tool documentation generation with category indexing, schema/example coverage, error-code metadata, and materialized markdown/json resources for MCP client consumption.

Files added:

• editor/src/MCPToolDocumentation.h - documentation resource builder:
  • structured tool documentation model (description, input/output schema, examples, errors)
  • category index generation (AST, Diagnostics, Workflow, Routing, Security)
  • completeness validation checks
  • markdown + JSON renderers
  • resource materialization writer (mcp_tool_docs.md, mcp_tool_docs.json)
• editor/tests/step505_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • per-tool documentation completeness
  • required category presence
  • schema/error metadata coverage
  • markdown/json export validity
  • writable/readable documentation resource output
  • invalid-doc rejection behavior
• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step505_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step505_test step504_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step505_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step504_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/MCPToolDocumentation.h within header-size limit (192 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step505_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (167 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 506: Edge Case Cleanup

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements explicit guardrails for high-risk edge cases with stable error codes and non-crashing fallback behavior across file handling, workflow persistence, dependency validation, language fallback, and MCP request validation.

Files added:

• editor/src/EdgeCaseCleanup.h - edge-case guard module:
  • empty/binary/oversized file detection
  • malformed annotation validation
  • circular dependency detection
  • concurrent workflow modification conflict detection
  • interrupted workflow save/resume helpers
  • unknown-language fallback to plain_text
  • malformed MCP request validation
• editor/tests/step506_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • each edge-case error path + code/message semantics
  • workflow save/resume success/failure behavior
  • language fallback behavior
  • valid-path no-crash behavior
• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step506_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step506_test step505_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step506_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step505_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/EdgeCaseCleanup.h within header-size limit (139 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step506_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (150 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 507: Full Test Suite Regression Gate

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements regression quality gating for multi-run suite execution summaries, including strict checks for all-pass behavior, flaky-test detection, duration budget, and leak budget.

Files added:

• editor/src/FullRegressionGate.h - regression gate evaluator:
  • aggregates run outcomes across suite partitions
  • detects flaky suites from mixed pass/fail run states
  • enforces duration target (<60s) and memory-leak budget (0)
  • emits gate summary notes and failure/flaky suite lists
  • includes synthetic phase dataset helper representing full 245-506 coverage scale
• editor/tests/step507_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • full-gate happy path across 3-run stability

  • 5000-test dataset semantics

  • flaky/failure/perf/leak failure-path detection
  • gate-conjunction logic and summary note generation
• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step507_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step507_test step506_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step507_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step506_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/FullRegressionGate.h within header-size limit (98 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step507_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (142 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 508: Sprint 25 Summary + Post-25 Readiness

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Implements Sprint 25 closure summary and Sprint 26 readiness signaling with threshold-checked project metrics and post-25 training-data prerequisites.

Files added:

• editor/src/Sprint25SummaryReadiness.h - summary/readiness generator:
  • Sprint 25 headline metrics (languages, tools, annotation scale, steps/tests)
  • self-hosting coverage threshold signal
  • validated scenario count from Phase 25b integration
  • post-25 readiness signals:
    • event-stream data accumulated
    • workflow decisions logged
    • transpilation pairs logged
  • final Sprint 26 readiness gate synthesis
• editor/tests/step508_test.cpp - 8 tests covering:
  • all headline metric thresholds
  • self-hosting coverage threshold
  • 4-scenario validation signal
  • post-25 readiness signal states
  • final Sprint 26 readiness gate + notes
• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step508_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step508_test step507_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step508_test - PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step507_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/Sprint25SummaryReadiness.h within header-size limit (68 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step508_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (94 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Phase 25c totals (504-508):

• Steps: 5
• Tests: 56/56 passing
• Headers added: 5
  • PerformanceOptimizationSuite.h
  • MCPToolDocumentation.h
  • EdgeCaseCleanup.h
  • FullRegressionGate.h
  • Sprint25SummaryReadiness.h

Sprint 25 totals (493-508):

• Steps completed: 16
• New tests in this sprint plan: 180/180 passing

Post-Sprint 25 Planning Update

Added the next multi-sprint roadmap as standalone plan documents in repo root, following the same structure pattern as previous sprint plans:

• sprint26_plan.md — GUI/UI/UX foundations, docking reliability, visual identity, interaction-state clarity, and modifier-edge shortcut notation
• sprint27_plan.md — constrained constructive editing I (taskitem contracts, legal operation graph, symbol scope enforcement)
• sprint28_plan.md — constrained constructive editing II (legal-choice APIs, multi-language adapters)
• sprint29_plan.md — routing/context/cost discipline for constrained execution
• sprint30_plan.md — debugger/runtime observability I (breakpoints, stepping, stack traces, call stack, locals/watches)
• sprint31_plan.md — debugger/runtime observability II (memory reflection, advanced debug views)
• sprint32_plan.md — markdown intake and architect-side taskitem generation with confidence/ambiguity labeling
• sprint33_plan.md — productization, onboarding/value communication, release hardening and benchmark readiness

These plans intentionally distribute work across multiple sprints (rather than a single sprint) to preserve implementation quality and maintainability.

Step 509: Docking Reliability Audit + Deterministic Layout Rules

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements a headless docking reliability guard that audits panel/layout state, repairs drift and hidden-critical-panel failures, and provides deterministic startup/session-restore normalization.

Files added:

• editor/src/DockingReliability.h - docking reliability module:
  • invariant audit + repair pipeline (auditAndRepair)
  • deterministic reset behavior for startup/recovery paths
  • deterministic preset materialization (deterministicStateFromPreset)
  • session restore reconciliation (reconcileFromSession)
  • canonical layout fingerprinting for stability checks
  • explicit issue code taxonomy (D001-D008)
• editor/tests/step509_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • stable baseline (no false positives)
  • ratio clamping and center-width safety floor
  • hidden editor recovery
  • editor dock drift recovery
  • empty-session panel restoration
  • deterministic reset behavior and fingerprint stability
  • invalid focus recovery
  • missing editor insertion
  • center visibility enforcement
  • session reconciliation semantics
  • recovery issue-code emission

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step509_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step509_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step509_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step508_test - PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/DockingReliability.h within header-size limit (283 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step509_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (180 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 510: Panel Boundaries, Resizers, and Hit-Target Corrections

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements deterministic split-bar hit testing and geometry normalization to reduce ambiguous click zones where content selection steals resize intent, and to enforce reliable keyboard/mouse resize behavior.

Files added:

• editor/src/PanelBoundaryReliability.h - panel boundary reliability module:
  • resize-priority click resolution over overlapping content
  • panel minimum-size enforcement and split-bar thickness clamping
  • bounded keyboard-driven split-bar resizing with fine-step mode
  • proximity-based navigation ordering for panel-focus traversal
• editor/tests/step510_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • resize-vs-content hit-target priority
  • miss-path behavior
  • panel width/height minimum clamping
  • split-bar thickness lower/upper clamp behavior
  • keyboard resize movement, bounds, and fine-step mode
  • proximity navigation order and normalization note emission

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step510_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step510_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step510_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step509_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/PanelBoundaryReliability.h within header-size limit (140 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step510_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (146 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 511: Interaction State Model

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements a shared interaction-state model for hover/focus/active/pressed/ disabled with deterministic token-driven style resolution and WCAG AA contrast checks for state transitions.

Files added:

• editor/src/InteractionStateModel.h - state model module:
  • precedence-based state resolver (disabled > pressed > active > focus > hover > idle)
  • token-driven style resolution for surface/text/border/focus ring
  • contrast-ratio computation with AA pass/fail signal per state
  • whole-state map resolver and failure extraction for audits
• editor/tests/step511_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • state-precedence ordering correctness
  • focus-ring semantics
  • disabled/idle token application
  • all-state resolution completeness
  • AA contrast pass for default dark tokens
  • low-contrast failure detection
  • pressed-vs-active visual differentiation

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step511_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step511_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step511_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step510_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/InteractionStateModel.h within header-size limit (166 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step511_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (142 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 512: Window Chrome + Hierarchy Pass

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements deterministic surface hierarchy and chrome/elevation semantics across work surfaces, tool surfaces, overlays, modals, and notifications, including validation of layering invariants and interaction blocking behavior.

Files added:

• editor/src/WindowHierarchyModel.h - hierarchy/chrome model:
  • role-based style + z-index synthesis
  • deterministic ordering by elevation/layer
  • hierarchy validation with explicit violation signals
  • normalization pass for modal semantics
  • modal/overlay interaction-blocking checks
• editor/tests/step512_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • role z-index ordering (work < tool < overlay < modal)
  • modal-flag validation and normalization
  • deterministic z-index sorting
  • modal/overlay interaction blocking semantics
  • depth-sensitive z-index behavior
  • notification layering between overlay and modal
  • baseline valid hierarchy behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step512_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step512_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step512_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step511_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/WindowHierarchyModel.h within header-size limit (142 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step512_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (153 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 513: Accessibility Baseline Pass

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements a baseline accessibility validation model covering keyboard-only traversal, focus-ring visibility constraints, and contrast thresholds for text and iconography.

Files added:

• editor/src/AccessibilityBaseline.h - accessibility baseline module:
  • keyboard traversal order generation from tab-order metadata
  • focus-ring style resolution with high-contrast mode support
  • focus-ring visibility checks (thickness/alpha/contrast)
  • aggregate accessibility validation (focusability, ring, text/icon contrast)
• editor/tests/step513_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • traversal ordering and disabled/invisible-node filtering
  • focus-ring enabled/disabled and visibility semantics
  • positive baseline pass condition
  • failure-path detection for no focus targets, low text contrast, low icon contrast, and non-visible focus ring

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step513_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step513_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step513_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step512_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/AccessibilityBaseline.h within header-size limit (99 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step513_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (138 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 514: Phase 26a Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Integrates Steps 509-513 into a single phase gate verifying docking stability, hit-target reliability, interaction-state correctness, hierarchy validity, and accessibility baseline compliance with an explicit editor-flow-safe signal.

Files added:

• editor/src/Phase26aIntegration.h - phase integration gate:
  • consolidated execution of Step 509-513 reliability checks
  • per-domain pass/fail signals plus final phase pass synthesis
  • integration notes including explicit phase-pass marker
• editor/tests/step514_test.cpp - 8 integration tests covering:
  • each domain gate (docking, hit-targets, interaction, hierarchy, accessibility)
  • combined editor-flow-safe signal
  • final phase pass signal
  • pass-marker note emission

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step514_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step514_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step514_test - PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step513_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/Phase26aIntegration.h within header-size limit (100 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step514_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (91 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 515: Theme Token System v2

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements a semantic token system for Sprint 26 visual language with black/stone layered surfaces, accent channels, spacing/radius/border/elevation scales, derivation support, and AA contrast validation.

Files added:

• editor/src/ThemeTokenSystemV2.h - token system module:
  • semantic color token set (base/layers/text/accent/error)
  • contrast-variant derivation for adaptive readability
  • spacing scale generation (xs..xl)
  • contrast ratio + AA validation helpers
  • explicit purple-bias detection guard for default accent policy
• editor/tests/step515_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • layered black/stone baseline semantics
  • spacing monotonicity and required keys
  • variant derivation effects on text/layer brightness
  • AA contrast checks for baseline tokens
  • purple-bias detection behavior
  • radius/border/elevation scale ordering

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step515_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step515_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step515_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step514_test - PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ThemeTokenSystemV2.h within header-size limit (107 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step515_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (121 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 516: Signature Visual Identity Pack

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements Sprint 26’s signature visual identity primitives: black-surface gradient depth treatment, blade-edge accent semantics for active surfaces, and electric-blue logic-link styling with distance-aware fading and motion-aware reveal timing.

Files added:

• editor/src/SignatureVisualIdentity.h - visual identity module:
  • elevated/base black-surface gradient presets
  • blade-edge accent model (edge, thickness, intensity, active state)
  • electric-blue logic-link style with highlight and distance fade behavior
  • reduced-motion aware reveal and stagger timing helpers
• editor/tests/step516_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • gradient stop structure/order and elevated-depth brightness
  • active blade-edge thickness/intensity behavior
  • highlighted link width/glow behavior
  • distance-based logic-link alpha fade
  • electric-blue profile detection
  • reduced-motion reveal/stagger behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step516_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step516_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step516_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step515_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SignatureVisualIdentity.h within header-size limit (81 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step516_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (123 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 517: Control Library Restyle

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements shared control styling semantics for core widgets (buttons, toggles, tabs, menus, dropdowns, checkboxes) with explicit pressed-depth signaling, contrast thresholds, and DPI-stable geometry scaling.

Files added:

• editor/src/ControlLibraryRestyle.h - control style module:
  • per-control geometry/depth token synthesis
  • pressed-state depth signal validation helper
  • contrast validation for labels/icons
  • DPI stability checks and scaling clamps
• editor/tests/step517_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • depth and pressed-signal behavior
  • control-specific radius/border expectations
  • contrast compliance
  • DPI scaling growth and clamp edges
  • all-control contrast regression sweep

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step517_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step517_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step517_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step516_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ControlLibraryRestyle.h within header-size limit (83 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step517_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (127 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 518: Icon + Typography Contrast Harmonization

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements icon and typography harmonization for dark surfaces with density-aware sizing, stroke-weight balancing, contrast thresholds, and panel rhythm scoring to reduce visual drift between dense and sparse UI regions.

Files added:

• editor/src/IconTypographyHarmonizer.h - harmonization module:
  • density-aware typography profile synthesis
  • icon stroke/contrast profile synthesis
  • harmonization validity checks for text/icon contrast and sizing
  • rhythm scoring for cross-panel density consistency
• editor/tests/step518_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • density scaling + clamp behavior
  • heading/body sizing hierarchy
  • text/icon contrast thresholds
  • harmonization pass/fail behavior
  • rhythm score behavior for consistent vs divergent panel densities

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step518_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step518_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step518_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step517_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/IconTypographyHarmonizer.h within header-size limit (60 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step518_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (125 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 519: Modifier-Edge Shortcut Notation

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements compact modifier-edge shortcut notation with deterministic edge mapping (Ctrl=left, Shift=right, Super=top, Alt=bottom), combined modifier support, and stable text fallback labels for non-glyph environments.

Files added:

• editor/src/ModifierEdgeNotation.h - notation module:
  • modifier-to-edge mapping model
  • glyph construction with key normalization
  • edge-activity counting and compactness checks
  • fallback label generation with stable modifier ordering
• editor/tests/step519_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • per-modifier edge mapping
  • combined-edge behavior
  • key normalization and invalid-key handling
  • fallback-label correctness and ordering
  • glyph-disabled fallback behavior
  • compactness and edge-count sanity cases

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step519_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step519_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step519_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step518_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ModifierEdgeNotation.h within header-size limit (76 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step519_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (116 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 520: Completion Overlay UX Hardening

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements completion-overlay hardening for predictable non-intrusive behavior: viewport-safe placement, dismissal intent persistence, semantic-trigger reopen logic, and stable pointer/keyboard navigation semantics.

Files added:

• editor/src/CompletionOverlayUXHardening.h - overlay UX module:
  • cursor-relative placement with overflow-aware flip/clamp logic
  • dismissal-state persistence and semantic-trigger reopen policy
  • pointer selection clamping and empty-list handling
  • keyboard navigation with wrap behavior
• editor/tests/step520_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • placement under normal and overflow conditions
  • dismissal/reopen behavior across trigger states
  • pointer selection bounds and zero-item handling
  • keyboard navigation wrap semantics

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step520_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step520_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step520_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step519_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/CompletionOverlayUXHardening.h within header-size limit (87 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step520_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (123 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 521: Notification + Status Signaling Refresh

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements refreshed notification/status signaling semantics with consistent info/warn/error/critical behavior, readability guarantees, duration policies, and stack management rules including persistent critical signaling.

Files added:

• editor/src/NotificationStatusRefresh.h - notification signaling module:
  • severity-specific style and duration policy
  • message factory with policy-derived timing
  • expiration logic with dismissal override and persistent critical support
  • stack-capping policy retaining newest messages
  • readability checks for text/icon contrast
• editor/tests/step521_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • duration progression by severity
  • persistent critical behavior
  • readability checks across levels
  • expire/no-expire timing boundaries
  • dismissed-message handling
  • stack truncation behavior and ordering

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step521_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step521_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step521_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step520_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/NotificationStatusRefresh.h within header-size limit (72 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step521_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (133 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 522: Cross-Panel Consistency Sweep

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements a cross-panel consistency sweep enforcing shared spacing/elevation/ border conventions plus state-model and token-version uniformity, with drift histograms and normalization helpers for rapid alignment.

Files added:

• editor/src/CrossPanelConsistencySweep.h - consistency sweep module:
  • baseline-vs-panel drift detection with tolerances
  • drift categorization and histogram reporting
  • normalization pass to align panel contracts to baseline
  • checked-panel accounting for sweep coverage
• editor/tests/step522_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • aligned pass case
  • drift detection for spacing/elevation/border/version mismatches
  • normalization behavior for metrics and versions
  • histogram grouping behavior
  • tolerance boundary behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step522_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step522_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step522_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step521_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/CrossPanelConsistencySweep.h within header-size limit (81 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step522_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (152 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 523: Sprint 26 Integration + Summary

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Implements the Sprint 26 closure gate by integrating Phase 26a reliability, visual token + identity systems, control/typography harmonization, modifier-edge shortcuts, overlay hardening, notification semantics, and cross-panel consistency into a single summary signal.

Files added:

• editor/src/Sprint26IntegrationSummary.h - sprint integration summary module:
  • aggregates Step 514-522 validation signals
  • computes final Sprint 26 pass flag
  • emits Sprint completion summary notes
• editor/tests/step523_test.cpp - 8 tests covering:
  • phase and domain gate pass signals
  • final sprint pass synthesis
  • completion-note emission

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step523_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step523_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step523_test - PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step522_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/Sprint26IntegrationSummary.h within header-size limit (90 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step523_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (92 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Sprint 26 totals (509-523):

• Steps completed: 15
• New tests in this sprint plan: 172/172 passing
• Phase 26a (509-514): 68/68 passing
• Phase 26b (515-519): 60/60 passing
• Phase 26c (520-523): 44/44 passing

Sprint 26 End Refactor Pass (Architecture Compliance)

Performed a dedicated post-sprint refactor pass focused on maintainability and architecture-rule alignment without behavior changes.

Refactors applied:

• editor/src/CompletionOverlayUXHardening.h
  • extracted shared helpers for clamping/index wrapping
  • removed duplicated inline clamp/wrap logic
• editor/src/NotificationStatusRefresh.h
  • factored repeated style construction into makeStyle(...)
  • reduced duplicated initializer literals
• editor/src/CrossPanelConsistencySweep.h
  • centralized drift recording in recordDrift(...)
  • reduced repeated pass/fail mutation logic

Architecture compliance audit:

• Header size gate: PASS (<=600 across audited sprint files)
• goto usage in runtime path: PASS (none in Sprint 26 modules)
• Stale TODO markers in Sprint 26 modules: PASS
• Header-only pattern for Sprint 26 additions: PASS

Refactor verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step520_test step521_test step522_test step523_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step520_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step521_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step522_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step523_test - PASS (8/8)

Step 524: Typed Taskitem Contract Schema

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements a strict typed taskitem contract schema for constrained execution with required fields for allowed targets/ops/symbols, forbidden symbols, and expected diagnostics deltas, rejecting under-specified taskitems.

Files added:

• editor/src/TypedTaskitemContractSchema.h - schema module:
  • JSON parse + required-field validation
  • semantic consistency rules (duplicate op detection, symbol conflict detection)
  • under-specification guards for constrained execution path
  • helper checks for operation/symbol legality
• editor/tests/step524_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • valid contract acceptance
  • required-field rejection paths
  • duplicate-op and symbol-conflict rejection
  • diagnostics-delta under-specification rejection
  • operation/symbol allow/deny helper behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step524_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step524_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step524_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step523_test - PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/TypedTaskitemContractSchema.h within header-size limit (114 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step524_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (148 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 525: Legal Operation Graph

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements a legal-operation graph for language/node-kind pairs so constrained editor tasks can validate whether requested refactors are structurally allowed before execution.

Files added:

• editor/src/LegalOperationGraph.h - operation-eligibility graph module:
  • default per-language/per-node operation rules
  • rule registration and override support
  • deduplication of operation sets
  • query helpers for supported nodes and allowed operations
• editor/tests/step525_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • default rule coverage across cpp/c/python/typescript/rust/go
  • unsupported language/node behavior
  • rule registration and override semantics
  • operation deduplication behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step525_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step525_test step524_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step525_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step524_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/LegalOperationGraph.h within header-size limit (79 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step525_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (131 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 526: Symbol Scope Extractor

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements symbol-scope extraction for constrained taskitems by building a language/node-aware in-scope candidate snapshot and explicitly rejecting unresolved symbol requests before apply.

Files added:

• editor/src/SymbolScopeExtractor.h - scope extraction module:
  • default per-language/per-node symbol-kind rules
  • nearest-scope candidate selection for duplicate names
  • forbidden-symbol filtering
  • unresolved symbol detection and apply-eligibility check
• editor/tests/step526_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • default filtering and nearest-scope selection behavior
  • unsupported language/node handling
  • unresolved symbol reporting and apply blocking
  • forbidden symbol exclusion behavior
  • dynamic rule registration/override behavior
  • empty symbol-table edge case

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step526_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step526_test step525_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step526_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step525_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SymbolScopeExtractor.h within header-size limit (102 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step526_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (158 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 527: Constraint Violation Diagnostics

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds structured constraint diagnostics for constrained execution failures, including out-of-scope symbol usage, illegal operations, and contract-policy violations with machine-readable retry/escalation payloads.

Files added:

• editor/src/ConstraintViolationDiagnostics.h - diagnostics module:
  • evaluates operation legality against legal-op graph + taskitem contract
  • evaluates symbol usage against extracted scope snapshot + contract policy
  • emits structured violation records with retryability metadata
  • computes deterministic recommended action (proceed/retry/escalate)
  • serializes diagnostics packet to JSON for retry/escalation routing
• editor/tests/step527_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • clean-path packet behavior with no violations
  • contract-forbidden and graph-illegal operation violations
  • unsupported context violations
  • out-of-scope and forbidden/disallowed symbol violations
  • retry-only vs escalate action selection
  • violation deduplication and multi-violation aggregation
  • machine-readable JSON payload shape
  • empty symbol request edge case

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step527_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step527_test step526_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step527_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step526_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ConstraintViolationDiagnostics.h within header-size limit (169 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step527_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (223 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 528: Phase 27a Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Integrates the Phase 27a constrained pipeline so taskitems must pass typed contract validation, symbol-scope extraction, legal operation checks, and constraint diagnostics before execution is allowed.

Files added:

• editor/src/ConstrainedTaskitemIntegration.h - phase integration gate:
  • schema-first taskitem validation via Step 524 contract module
  • forbidden-aware scope snapshot extraction via Step 526
  • constraint diagnostics evaluation via Step 527
  • deterministic route/execute decision (routed + executed)
  • actionable schema-failure packet generation for under-constrained taskitems
• editor/tests/step528_test.cpp - 8 tests covering:
  • full constrained path success for valid taskitem
  • schema rejection for missing required constraint fields
  • schema rejection for missing diagnostics delta and duplicate allowed ops
  • illegal operation rejection with escalation diagnostics
  • out-of-scope symbol rejection with retry diagnostics
  • forbidden symbol and unsupported-context rejection paths

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step528_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step528_test step527_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step528_test - PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step527_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ConstrainedTaskitemIntegration.h within header-size limit (86 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step528_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (179 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Phase 27a totals (524-528):

• Steps completed: 5
• New tests in phase plan: 56/56 passing
• Constraint model + diagnostics + integration: PASS

Step 529: Pre-Apply Validation Gate

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds a deterministic pre-apply gate that validates candidate edits against contract schema, allowed targets, legal operation graph, and in-scope symbol snapshot before any mutation is allowed.

Files added:

• editor/src/PreApplyValidationGate.h - pre-apply validation module:
  • schema-first taskitem validation gate
  • forbidden-aware scope snapshot build for candidate edit context
  • operation/symbol constraint evaluation via structured diagnostics
  • explicit allowed and mayMutateBuffer decision flags
  • target-kind contract enforcement (target_out_of_contract)
• editor/tests/step529_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • valid pre-apply allow path
  • illegal op, unsupported context, and out-of-scope symbol rejections
  • target contract mismatch rejection
  • forbidden symbol rejection
  • schema-failure rejection paths
  • retry vs escalate action semantics
  • multi-violation aggregation behavior
  • empty symbol-list edge case

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step529_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step529_test step528_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step529_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step528_test - PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/PreApplyValidationGate.h within header-size limit (130 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step529_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (202 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 530: Post-Apply Structural Gate

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Adds a deterministic post-apply structural validation gate that requires successful reparse of touched regions and rejects unexpected symbol-graph drift after candidate edits are applied.

Files added:

• editor/src/PostApplyStructuralGate.h - post-apply gate module:
  • validates region reparse completion
  • validates AST integrity via parse error count check
  • computes symbol additions/removals from before/after snapshots
  • enforces allowed symbol-drift policy
  • emits structured diagnostics for unexpected drift and integrity failures
• editor/tests/step530_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • clean reparse/no-drift pass path
  • AST integrity and missing-reparse failure paths
  • unexpected add/remove symbol drift rejection
  • allowed drift pass behavior (add/remove)
  • duplicate-symbol dedup behavior
  • aggregated multi-failure reporting
  • empty graph edge case

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step530_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step530_test step529_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step530_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step529_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/PostApplyStructuralGate.h within header-size limit (123 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step530_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (155 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 531: Contract Delta Checker

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements a contract delta checker that validates expected diagnostic delta semantics and required post-condition symbols, blocking edits that violate post-apply contract expectations.

Files added:

• editor/src/ContractDeltaChecker.h - contract delta validation module:
  • computes before/after diagnostic add/remove sets
  • verifies expected diagnostic adds/removes occurred
  • optionally enforces strict unexpected diagnostic drift rejection
  • verifies required post-condition symbols are present after apply
  • emits structured violation diagnostics and final pass/fail action
• editor/tests/step531_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • expected add/remove pass path
  • missing expected add/remove failures
  • strict unexpected add/remove rejection behavior
  • non-strict drift tolerance behavior
  • required post-condition symbol presence checks
  • duplicate diagnostics normalization behavior
  • empty-delta edge case
  • aggregated multi-failure reporting and escalation action

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step531_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step531_test step530_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step531_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step530_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ContractDeltaChecker.h within header-size limit (149 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step531_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (200 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 532: Retry/Escalation Protocol for Constraint Failures

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements deterministic retry/escalation behavior for constraint failures, including automatic correction for retryable scope failures and full failure packet escalation when non-retryable or unresolved conditions remain.

Files added:

• editor/src/RetryEscalationProtocol.h - retry/escalation module:
  • immediate pass-through for already-valid diagnostics
  • immediate escalation for non-retryable violations
  • deterministic repair pass for correctable retryable failures
  • retry-budget control with attempt history
  • machine-readable escalation packet with reason/final diagnostics/attempts
• editor/tests/step532_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • resolved/no-retry path
  • immediate escalation for non-retryable and mixed failures
  • successful retry for correctable failures
  • retry-budget exhaustion behavior
  • escalation packet structure and attempt history
  • deterministic repeatability guarantees
  • zero-budget edge case
  • applied-fix metadata capture

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step532_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step532_test step531_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step532_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step531_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/RetryEscalationProtocol.h within header-size limit (129 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step532_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (171 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 533: Sprint 27 Integration + Summary

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Completes Sprint 27 integration by synthesizing Step 524-532 readiness signals into phase-level and sprint-level pass/fail outcomes with actionable summary notes.

Files added:

• editor/src/Sprint27IntegrationSummary.h - sprint integration module:
  • aggregates all Phase 27a and 27b gate signals
  • computes phase pass flags and final Sprint 27 pass flag
  • emits failure-note diagnostics for missing gates
  • emits constrained-execution completion notes on full pass
• editor/tests/step533_test.cpp - 8 tests covering:
  • full sprint pass path
  • phase-specific failure blocking behavior
  • success and failure note emission
  • multi-failure aggregation
  • all-false boundary behavior
  • phase-status isolation on single gate failure

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step533_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step533_test step532_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step533_test - PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step532_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/Sprint27IntegrationSummary.h within header-size limit (71 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step533_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (135 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Sprint 27 totals (524-533):

• Steps completed: 10
• New tests in this sprint plan: 112/112 passing
• Phase 27a (524-528): 56/56 passing
• Phase 27b (529-533): 56/56 passing

Sprint 27 End Refactor Pass (Architecture Compliance)

Performed a dedicated post-sprint refactor pass to reduce duplication and re-validate architecture constraints without changing runtime behavior.

Refactors applied:

• editor/src/ConstraintSchemaFailurePacket.h
  • extracted shared helper makeUnderConstrainedContractPacket(...)
  • centralized schema-failure diagnostics payload construction
• editor/src/ConstrainedTaskitemIntegration.h
  • replaced inline schema-failure packet builder with shared helper usage
  • removed duplicate private schema-failure implementation
• editor/src/PreApplyValidationGate.h
  • replaced inline schema-failure packet builder with shared helper usage
  • removed duplicate private schema-failure implementation

Architecture compliance audit:

• Header size gate (<=600 lines): PASS across Sprint 27 modules
  • largest audited header: editor/src/ConstraintViolationDiagnostics.h (169 lines)
• goto usage in Sprint 27 runtime path: PASS (none)
• Stale TODO markers in Sprint 27 modules: PASS (none)
• Header-only pattern for Sprint 27 additions: PASS

Refactor verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step524_test step525_test step526_test step527_test step528_test step529_test step530_test step531_test step532_test step533_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step524_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step525_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step526_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step527_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step528_test - PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step529_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step530_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step531_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step532_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step533_test - PASS (8/8)

Step 534: Operation Selector API

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements legal-operation selection for constrained editing by exposing only operations legal for the active language/node context and taskitem contract, ranked by predicted constraint-success signals.

Files added:

• editor/src/OperationSelectorAPI.h - operation selection module:
  • intersects legal-op graph results with taskitem allowed ops
  • ranks candidates using risk/context/preference heuristics
  • emits candidate reasons for selector explainability
  • deterministic score + tie-break ordering
• editor/tests/step534_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • supported/unsupported context behavior
  • contract op filtering behavior
  • score sorting and tie-break behavior
  • preferred-op boost behavior
  • scope-context weighting behavior
  • low-risk/high-risk scoring behavior
  • empty allowed-op and unknown-language edge cases

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step534_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step534_test step533_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step534_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step533_test - PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/OperationSelectorAPI.h within header-size limit (88 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step534_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (208 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 535: Symbol Selector API

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements constrained symbol selection by exposing only in-scope symbols allowed by contract policy, enriched with typed role/category metadata and category-based filtering.

Files added:

• editor/src/SymbolSelectorAPI.h - symbol selection module:
  • filters scope snapshot symbols through contract allow/forbid policy
  • maps symbol kinds to selector categories (function/type/field/module/constant)
  • supports category filter queries
  • deterministic sorting and dedupe behavior
• editor/tests/step535_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • supported/unsupported scope handling
  • forbidden/contract-disallowed symbol filtering
  • each category filter behavior
  • multi-category filtering
  • scope-depth sort behavior
  • duplicate symbol-name dedup behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step535_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step535_test step534_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step535_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step534_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/SymbolSelectorAPI.h within header-size limit (81 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step535_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (163 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 536: Argument Shape Validator

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements argument-shape validation for constrained operations, enforcing operation-specific required fields, enum constraints, forbidden keys, and contract legality for operation/symbol pairs.

Files added:

• editor/src/ArgumentShapeValidator.h - argument shape validation module:
  • operation/symbol contract allow checks
  • per-operation required argument schemas (rename/update/insert/extract/delete)
  • enum validation for constrained argument fields
  • semantic no-op guard for rename operations
  • malformed-argument object checks and forbidden-key enforcement
• editor/tests/step536_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • valid rename path
  • required field failures per operation
  • enum validation failures
  • delete confirm-type requirement
  • disallowed op/symbol failure paths
  • malformed args (non-object) edge case

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step536_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step536_test step535_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step536_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step535_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ArgumentShapeValidator.h within header-size limit (113 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step536_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (144 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 537: Constrained Execution Telemetry

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements constrained execution telemetry to track candidate breadth, selection paths, rejection reasons, and token-usage deltas versus unconstrained baselines.

Files added:

• editor/src/ConstrainedExecutionTelemetry.h - telemetry module:
  • records per-taskitem constrained execution events
  • aggregates success/failure counts and candidate breadth averages
  • builds rejection-reason and selected-operation histograms
  • computes constrained vs baseline token totals/savings/ratio
• editor/tests/step537_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • empty-summary behavior
  • event recording/counting behavior
  • success/failure aggregate behavior
  • average candidate breadth computation
  • token savings and ratio computation
  • rejection and operation histogram behavior
  • baseline-zero and negative-savings edge cases
  • mixed-event aggregate behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step537_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step537_test step536_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step537_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step536_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ConstrainedExecutionTelemetry.h within header-size limit (75 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step537_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (175 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 538: Phase 28a Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Integrates legal-choice operation/symbol menus, argument-shape validation, and telemetry into a single constrained execution surface for agent-facing editing.

Files added:

• editor/src/Phase28aIntegration.h - Phase 28a integration gate:
  • builds operation and symbol legal-choice menus
  • enforces selection membership (operation + symbol must come from legal menus)
  • validates selected argument shape before execution
  • records per-attempt telemetry for success and rejection paths
  • returns integrated execution result + aggregate telemetry summary
• editor/tests/step538_test.cpp - 8 tests covering:
  • valid legal-choice execution path
  • illegal operation/symbol menu rejection paths
  • argument-shape rejection path
  • menu unavailability failure path
  • telemetry candidate-breadth, token-savings, and rejection histogram behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step538_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step538_test step537_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step538_test - PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step537_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/Phase28aIntegration.h within header-size limit (118 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step538_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (154 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Phase 28a totals (534-538):

• Steps completed: 5
• New tests in phase plan: 56/56 passing
• Legal-choice API + validation + telemetry integration: PASS

Step 539: C/C++ Constructive Edit Adapter

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements a C/C++ constructive edit adapter with construct-aware legal operation mapping and header/source boundary safety checks.

Files added:

• editor/src/CppConstructiveEditAdapter.h - C/C++ adapter module:
  • legal operation mappings for declarations/definitions/includes/macros/classes/members
  • language support for both c and cpp
  • header/source boundary guards for sensitive operations
  • structured diagnostics for unsupported constructs/languages and blocked ops
• editor/tests/step539_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • legal operation paths across declarations, definitions, includes, macros, members
  • boundary-safe rejections (header/source violations)
  • unsupported construct/language behavior
  • C language compatibility path

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step539_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step539_test step538_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step539_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step538_test - PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/CppConstructiveEditAdapter.h within header-size limit (90 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step539_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (126 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 540: Python/TypeScript Constructive Edit Adapter

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements Python/TypeScript constructive edit adaptation with construct-aware legal operation mappings and module-level side-effect protection guards.

Files added:

• editor/src/PythonTypeScriptConstructiveEditAdapter.h - Python/TypeScript adapter module:
  • legal operation mappings for functions/classes/imports/signatures/module statements
  • shared support for both python and typescript
  • module side-effect risk guardrails for reorder/delete/inline-sensitive paths
  • structured diagnostics for unsupported constructs/languages and illegal ops
• editor/tests/step540_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • legal operation paths across Python/TypeScript constructs
  • side-effect risk blocking behavior
  • illegal operation rejections for constrained constructs
  • unsupported construct/language behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step540_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step540_test step539_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step540_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step539_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/PythonTypeScriptConstructiveEditAdapter.h within header-size limit (84 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step540_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (126 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 541: Rust/Go Constructive Edit Adapter

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements Rust/Go constructive edit adaptation with ownership/lifetime and concurrency-sensitive guardrails for high-risk transform paths.

Files added:

• editor/src/RustGoConstructiveEditAdapter.h - Rust/Go adapter module:
  • legal operation mappings for functions/structs/impl/import/channel/borrow regions
  • shared support for both rust and go
  • borrow/lifetime safety guards for Rust-sensitive operations
  • concurrency safety guards for Go-sensitive operations
  • structured diagnostics for unsupported constructs/languages and illegal ops
• editor/tests/step541_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • legal operation paths across Rust and Go constructs
  • ownership/lifetime guard behavior in Rust
  • concurrency guard behavior in Go
  • illegal operation rejections
  • unsupported construct/language behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step541_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step541_test step540_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step541_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step540_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/RustGoConstructiveEditAdapter.h within header-size limit (91 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step541_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (127 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 542: Cross-Language Consistency Gate

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements a cross-language consistency gate that normalizes adapter outcomes, standardizes failure categories, and applies consistent fallback behavior across C/C++, Python/TypeScript, and Rust/Go adapters.

Files added:

• editor/src/CrossLanguageConsistencyGate.h - consistency gate module:
  • routes language-specific requests to the appropriate constructive adapter
  • normalizes adapter diagnostics into canonical failure categories
  • assigns standardized fallback actions (readonly, suggest_legal_ops, escalate, retry)
  • preserves raw adapter diagnostics for downstream handling
• editor/tests/step542_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • allowed-path normalization across languages
  • safety-guard failure normalization for side-effect/lifetime/concurrency blocks
  • illegal-operation and unsupported construct/language normalization
  • fallback action consistency by canonical failure type
  • diagnostic preservation behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step542_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step542_test step541_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step542_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step541_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/CrossLanguageConsistencyGate.h within header-size limit (108 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step542_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (132 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 543: Sprint 28 Integration + Summary

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Completes Sprint 28 integration by synthesizing Step 534-542 readiness signals into phase-level and sprint-level pass/fail outcomes with closure notes.

Files added:

• editor/src/Sprint28IntegrationSummary.h - sprint integration module:
  • aggregates all Phase 28a and 28b gate signals
  • computes phase pass flags and final Sprint 28 pass flag
  • emits failure-note diagnostics for missing gates
  • emits completion notes on full sprint pass
• editor/tests/step543_test.cpp - 8 tests covering:
  • full sprint pass path
  • phase-specific failure blocking behavior
  • success/failure note emission
  • multi-failure aggregation
  • all-false boundary behavior
  • phase-status isolation on single Phase 28b failure

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step543_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step543_test step542_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step543_test - PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step542_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/Sprint28IntegrationSummary.h within header-size limit (70 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step543_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (128 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Sprint 28 totals (534-543):

• Steps completed: 10
• New tests in this sprint plan: 112/112 passing
• Phase 28a (534-538): 56/56 passing
• Phase 28b (539-543): 56/56 passing

Sprint 28 End Refactor Pass (Architecture Compliance)

Performed a dedicated post-sprint refactor pass to reduce adapter duplication and re-validate architecture constraints without behavior changes.

Refactors applied:

• editor/src/AdapterOperationUtil.h
  • added shared adapter operation helper adapterHasOperation(...)
  • removed repeated inline membership helpers across language adapters
• editor/src/CppConstructiveEditAdapter.h
  • switched operation legality checks to shared helper
  • removed local duplicate membership implementation
• editor/src/PythonTypeScriptConstructiveEditAdapter.h
  • switched operation legality checks to shared helper
  • removed local duplicate membership implementation
• editor/src/RustGoConstructiveEditAdapter.h
  • switched operation legality checks to shared helper
  • removed local duplicate membership implementation

Architecture compliance audit:

• Header size gate (<=600 lines): PASS across Sprint 28 modules
  • largest audited header: editor/src/Phase28aIntegration.h (118 lines)
• goto usage in Sprint 28 runtime path: PASS (none)
• Stale TODO markers in Sprint 28 modules: PASS (none)
• Header-only pattern for Sprint 28 additions: PASS

Refactor verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step534_test step535_test step536_test step537_test step538_test step539_test step540_test step541_test step542_test step543_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step534_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step535_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step536_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step537_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step538_test - PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step539_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step540_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step541_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step542_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step543_test - PASS (8/8)

Step 544: Constrained Routing Ruleset Extension

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements constrained-mode routing policy extensions with deterministic template promotion at high legal-choice confidence and explicit precedence for post-apply failure escalation.

Files added:

• editor/src/ConstrainedRoutingRulesetExtension.h - constrained routing module:
  • constrained/non-constrained mode branching
  • failure-first escalation for unstable recent outcomes
  • deterministic template promotion for high-confidence legal-choice paths
  • constrained-worker routing for moderate confidence
  • low-confidence fallback to general worker
• editor/tests/step544_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • constrained-mode and non-constrained routing behavior
  • escalation precedence behavior
  • template promotion thresholds
  • constrained-worker thresholds
  • confidence propagation behavior
  • rationale-tag emission behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step544_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step544_test step543_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step544_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step543_test - PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ConstrainedRoutingRulesetExtension.h within header-size limit (60 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step544_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (126 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 545: Context Bundle Minimizer

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements minimal-sufficient context bundling for constrained taskitems, retaining contract-relevant context while dropping unrelated project and dependency noise for narrow operations.

Files added:

• editor/src/ContextBundleMinimizer.h - context minimization module:
  • seeds relevance keys from contract targets/symbols/ops
  • filters file/project/dependency context by relevance and structural heuristics
  • applies stricter pruning for narrow operations
  • returns explicit kept vs removed context sets
  • deterministic dedupe normalization for outputs
• editor/tests/step545_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • narrow-mode relevance retention/drop behavior
  • non-narrow structural keep behavior
  • symbol/op-driven relevance behavior
  • dedupe behavior for kept/removed sets
  • empty-input edge case
  • irrelevant-note dropping behavior
  • dependency relevance by symbol-match behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step545_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step545_test step544_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step545_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step544_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ContextBundleMinimizer.h within header-size limit (88 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step545_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (169 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 546: Confidence Calibration for Constrained Paths

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements confidence calibration for constrained routing by combining base legal-choice confidence with historical success/failure rates and explicit penalties for repeated post-apply failures.

Files added:

• editor/src/ConstrainedConfidenceCalibrator.h - confidence calibration module:
  • route scoring for deterministic/constrained/general policy paths
  • success-rate boosts and post-apply failure penalties
  • extra decay for repeated post-apply failures
  • preferred-route bias with post-bias score clamping
  • best-route selection and adjusted-confidence emission
• editor/tests/step546_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • neutral/no-history behavior
  • success/failure rate calibration effects
  • repeated-failure decay behavior
  • preferred-route bias behavior
  • clamping behavior at score bounds
  • recommended-route and adjusted-confidence consistency
  • route score coverage across all policy paths

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step546_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step546_test step545_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step546_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step545_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ConstrainedConfidenceCalibrator.h within header-size limit (97 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step546_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (143 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 547: Cost Policy Guard

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements cost policy enforcement for constrained orchestration with per-step and per-workflow token ceilings, rationale requirements, and escalation approval controls for overage execution.

Files added:

• editor/src/CostPolicyGuard.h - cost policy enforcement module:
  • step/workflow ceiling checks
  • violation capture for exceeded ceilings
  • rationale-required flow for policy overages
  • escalation-approval gate for over-budget execution
  • deterministic action outputs (allow/request_rationale/escalate)
• editor/tests/step547_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • within-limit allow behavior
  • step/workflow/both overage violation behavior
  • rationale and escalation approval behavior
  • equal-to-ceiling boundary behavior
  • zero-ceiling disabled-check behavior
  • negative-token edge behavior
  • no-escalation behavior when within limits

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step547_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step547_test step546_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step547_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step546_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/CostPolicyGuard.h within header-size limit (60 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step547_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (132 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 548: Phase 29a Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Integrates Phase 29a routing intelligence, context minimization, confidence calibration, and cost policy enforcement into a unified constrained orchestration decision flow.

Files added:

• editor/src/Phase29aIntegration.h - Phase 29a integration gate:
  • composes Step 544 routing policy, Step 545 context minimizer, Step 546 confidence calibration, and Step 547 cost guard
  • emits integrated pass/fail signal with structured error reasons
  • guards template routing when calibrated confidence is too low
  • enforces cost-policy and escalation outcomes in final decision
• editor/tests/step548_test.cpp - 8 tests covering:
  • pass-path with reduced context and cost compliance
  • cost-policy block behavior
  • routing-escalation block behavior
  • narrow-context minimization behavior
  • low-calibrated-confidence template block behavior
  • calibration route-shift behavior
  • approved overage path behavior
  • non-narrow context tolerance behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step548_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step548_test step547_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step548_test - PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step547_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/Phase29aIntegration.h within header-size limit (69 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step548_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (132 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Phase 29a totals (544-548):

• Steps completed: 5
• New tests in phase plan: 56/56 passing
• Routing/context/cost optimization integration: PASS

Step 549: Suggestion Engine for Cost Reductions

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements cost-reduction suggestion generation for constrained orchestration, including template substitution, batching, and context narrowing opportunities with priority and savings estimates.

Files added:

• editor/src/CostReductionSuggestionEngine.h - cost suggestion module:
  • emits template substitution recommendations when deterministic paths exist
  • emits batching recommendations for compatible multi-op workloads
  • emits context narrowing recommendations for wide symbol candidate sets
  • computes estimated token savings and priority by budget pressure
  • deterministic sorting by priority and estimated savings
• editor/tests/step549_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • suggestion emission behavior per optimization path
  • no-suggestion baseline behavior
  • over-budget priority amplification behavior
  • savings scaling behavior by op/symbol breadth
  • path eligibility thresholds for batching/context narrowing
  • ordering/tiebreak behavior
  • rationale presence requirements

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step549_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step549_test step548_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step549_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step548_test - PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/CostReductionSuggestionEngine.h within header-size limit (68 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step549_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (146 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 550: Worker Efficiency Dashboard Data Model

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements a worker-efficiency dashboard aggregation model covering completion, cost, rejection, and latency metrics by worker and task class.

Files added:

• editor/src/WorkerEfficiencyDashboardModel.h - dashboard model module:
  • records per-run worker/task telemetry
  • aggregates metrics by worker and by task class
  • computes success/failure counts and rates
  • computes total/average tokens, latency, and rejection counts
• editor/tests/step550_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • empty snapshot behavior
  • worker/task grouping behavior
  • success/failure and success-rate computations
  • average tokens/latency/rejections computations
  • aggregate totals behavior
  • cross-worker task-class aggregation behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step550_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step550_test step549_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step550_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step549_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/WorkerEfficiencyDashboardModel.h within header-size limit (71 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step550_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (170 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 551: Review-Gate Policy Refinement

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements refined review-gate policy logic to reduce unnecessary human escalations while preserving hard safety/security/policy protections.

Files added:

• editor/src/ReviewGatePolicyRefinement.h - review-gate policy module:
  • policy-violation hard block precedence
  • safety/security escalation precedence
  • repeated post-apply failure escalation trigger
  • high-confidence deterministic auto-approval path
  • moderate-confidence auto-approve-with-audit path
  • low-confidence/high-cost escalation behavior
• editor/tests/step551_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • policy/safety/security precedence behavior
  • failure-streak escalation behavior
  • auto-approve and audit-path behavior
  • low-confidence/high-cost escalation behavior
  • precedence override behavior across mixed conditions
  • threshold boundary behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step551_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step551_test step550_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step551_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step550_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ReviewGatePolicyRefinement.h within header-size limit (70 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step551_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (132 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 552: Cost vs Quality Regression Suite

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements a cost-vs-quality regression suite to enforce that optimization policy tightening preserves quality, pass rate, and safety while meeting token reduction targets.

Files added:

• editor/src/CostQualityRegressionSuite.h - regression suite module:
  • evaluates optimized runs against absolute quality/pass/safety floors
  • enforces minimum token reduction targets
  • detects relative quality/pass regressions vs baseline
  • reports detailed failure codes and token reduction deltas
• editor/tests/step552_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • passing baseline/optimized scenario
  • token/quality/pass/safety floor failures
  • relative regression detection behavior
  • multi-failure reporting behavior
  • threshold boundary behavior
  • token reduction reporting behavior
  • negative reduction failure behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step552_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step552_test step551_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step552_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step551_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/CostQualityRegressionSuite.h within header-size limit (60 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step552_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (167 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 553: Sprint 29 Integration + Summary

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Completes Sprint 29 integration by synthesizing Step 544-552 readiness signals into phase-level and sprint-level outcomes with closure diagnostics.

Files added:

• editor/src/Sprint29IntegrationSummary.h - sprint integration module:
  • aggregates all Phase 29a and 29b gate signals
  • computes phase pass flags and final Sprint 29 pass flag
  • emits failure-note diagnostics for missing gates
  • emits completion notes on full sprint pass
• editor/tests/step553_test.cpp - 8 tests covering:
  • full sprint pass path
  • phase-specific failure blocking behavior
  • success/failure note emission
  • multi-failure aggregation
  • all-false boundary behavior
  • phase-status isolation on single Phase 29b failure

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step553_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step553_test step552_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step553_test - PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step552_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/Sprint29IntegrationSummary.h within header-size limit (70 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step553_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (128 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Sprint 29 totals (544-553):

• Steps completed: 10
• New tests in this sprint plan: 112/112 passing
• Phase 29a (544-548): 56/56 passing
• Phase 29b (549-553): 56/56 passing

Sprint 29 End Refactor Pass (Architecture Compliance)

Performed a dedicated post-sprint refactor pass to reduce policy-guard duplication and re-validate architecture constraints without behavior changes.

Refactors applied:

• editor/src/PolicyDecisionUtil.h
  • added shared helpers for policy decision transitions
  • centralized common escalation/action state assignment logic
• editor/src/ReviewGatePolicyRefinement.h
  • switched repeated escalation decision branches to shared helper usage
  • removed duplicated inline escalation state mutation
• editor/src/CostPolicyGuard.h
  • switched repeated action/allow/escalation transitions to shared helper usage
  • removed duplicated inline action-state assignments

Architecture compliance audit:

• Header size gate (<=600 lines): PASS across Sprint 29 modules
  • largest audited header: editor/src/ConstrainedConfidenceCalibrator.h (97 lines)
• goto usage in Sprint 29 runtime path: PASS (none)
• Stale TODO markers in Sprint 29 modules: PASS (none)
• Header-only pattern for Sprint 29 additions: PASS

Refactor verification run:

• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step544_test step545_test step546_test step547_test step548_test step549_test step550_test step551_test step552_test step553_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step544_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step545_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step546_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step547_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step548_test - PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step549_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step550_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step551_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step552_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step553_test - PASS (8/8)

Step 554: Debug Session Model

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements the core debug session lifecycle model with start/attach/pause/ resume/stop transitions and multi-target per-buffer context support.

Files added:

• editor/src/DebugSessionModel.h - debug session control-plane model:
  • session lifecycle transitions (start/attach/pause/resume/stop)
  • multi-target session state with per-target buffer/executable context
  • current-target switching
  • per-buffer target lookup for editor mapping
• editor/tests/step554_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • lifecycle transition behavior and invalid transition guards
  • attach semantics for inactive/active sessions
  • multi-target session behavior
  • target switching behavior
  • per-buffer target mapping behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step554_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step554_test step553_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step554_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step553_test - PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/DebugSessionModel.h within header-size limit (106 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step554_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (140 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 555: Breakpoint System

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements breakpoint management for line, conditional, and hit-count breakpoints, including enable/disable persistence and line reconciliation across file edits.

Files added:

• editor/src/BreakpointSystem.h - breakpoint subsystem:
  • line, conditional, and hit-count breakpoint creation
  • enable/disable/remove operations
  • runtime break-decision evaluation (condition + hit-count semantics)
  • file-edit reconciliation with line-shift/clamp behavior
• editor/tests/step555_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • breakpoint creation variants and invalid input guardrails
  • enable/disable persistence behavior
  • simple/conditional/hit-count break evaluation behavior
  • file-edit reconciliation behavior
  • removal behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step555_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step555_test step554_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step555_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step554_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/BreakpointSystem.h within header-size limit (118 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step555_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (150 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 556: Step Engine

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements deterministic stepping semantics for debug control with step_into, step_over, step_out, and continue command mapping and explicit runtime state transitions.

Files added:

• editor/src/StepEngine.h - stepping control-plane module:
  • deterministic command execution mapping
  • state transitions across paused/running/completed states
  • stack depth and instruction pointer progression semantics
  • command validity guards for unknown/invalid lifecycle states
• editor/tests/step556_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • per-command transition behavior
  • root/ nested step_out behavior
  • deterministic continue behavior
  • unknown command behavior
  • completion-state command guard behavior
  • command tracking and progression monotonicity

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step556_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step556_test step555_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step556_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step555_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/StepEngine.h within header-size limit (135 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step556_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (154 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 557: Exception + Stack Trace Capture

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements structured exception event capture with validated stack traces and editor navigation anchors for each stack frame.

Files added:

• editor/src/ExceptionStackTraceCapture.h - exception capture module:
  • structured exception event model (type/message/thread/frames)
  • frame validation and normalization
  • navigation anchor generation (file:line) for editor linking
  • explicit error reporting for invalid/missing payload fields
• editor/tests/step557_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • valid capture behavior
  • missing required field behavior
  • invalid frame validation behavior
  • navigation anchor generation
  • mixed valid/invalid frame behavior
  • event field persistence behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step557_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step557_test step556_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step557_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step556_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/ExceptionStackTraceCapture.h within header-size limit (71 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step557_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (149 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 558: Phase 30a Integration

Status: PASS (8/8 tests)

Integrates debug session lifecycle, breakpoint handling, stepping, and exception capture into a complete Phase 30a debug control-plane cycle.

Files added:

• editor/src/Phase30aIntegration.h - Phase 30a integration gate:
  • composes Step 554 session lifecycle, Step 555 breakpoint system, Step 556 step engine, and Step 557 exception capture
  • executes breakpoint-hit to step-command to optional exception flow
  • emits integrated pass/fail state with explicit error reasons
• editor/tests/step558_test.cpp - 8 tests covering:
  • full cycle pass paths (with and without exception)
  • breakpoint add/hit failure paths
  • step command failure path
  • session start failure path
  • step-result propagation and exception anchor linkage

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step558_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step558_test step557_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step558_test - PASS (8/8)
• ./editor/build-native/step557_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/Phase30aIntegration.h within header-size limit (80 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step558_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (117 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Phase 30a totals (554-558):

• Steps completed: 5
• New tests in phase plan: 56/56 passing
• Debug control-plane integration: PASS

Step 559: Call Stack and Frame Inspector

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements call stack frame inspection with frame navigation and variable scope mapping for runtime inspection surfaces.

Files added:

• editor/src/CallStackFrameInspector.h - frame inspector module:
  • frame selection by index
  • payload validation for frame navigation metadata
  • selected-frame scope extraction
  • variable name listing helper for panel rendering
• editor/tests/step559_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • top/middle/bottom frame navigation
  • invalid/empty stack guard behavior
  • invalid frame payload guard behavior
  • variable scope mapping and exposure behavior
  • selected-index reporting behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step559_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step559_test step558_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step559_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step558_test - PASS (8/8) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/CallStackFrameInspector.h within header-size limit (58 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step559_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (146 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 560: Locals + Watches Panel Data Model

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements runtime locals and watch-expression state modeling with type-aware locals display fields and watch lifecycle management.

Files added:

• editor/src/LocalsWatchesPanelModel.h - locals/watches data model:
  • type-aware local variable entries
  • watch add/remove/enable-disable lifecycle
  • watch evaluation value/status tracking
  • active-watch filtering and index-rebuild safety
• editor/tests/step560_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • locals persistence/type behavior
  • watch lifecycle behavior and input validation
  • watch enable/disable behavior
  • evaluation update behavior
  • active-watch filtering behavior
  • index rebuild behavior after watch removal

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step560_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step560_test step559_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step560_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step559_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/LocalsWatchesPanelModel.h within header-size limit (90 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step560_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (138 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 561: Trace Timeline Model

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements a runtime trace timeline data model for ordered pause/step/exception state transitions with session/type/window query support.

Files added:

• editor/src/TraceTimelineModel.h - trace timeline module:
  • event append with payload validation
  • deterministic timeline ordering
  • query helpers by event type, session, and time window
  • support for mixed runtime event categories
• editor/tests/step561_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • event validation behavior
  • ordering behavior
  • type/session/window query behavior
  • timestamp tie-break behavior
  • detail payload preservation
  • mixed-event support behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step561_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step561_test step560_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step561_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step560_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/TraceTimelineModel.h within header-size limit (58 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step561_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (144 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md

Step 562: Workflow-Aware Debug Hooks

Status: PASS (12/12 tests)

Implements workflow-aware debug hooks that bind debug sessions to active workflow items and diagnostic IDs for coordinated runtime/debug context.

Files added:

• editor/src/WorkflowAwareDebugHooks.h - workflow debug hook model:
  • workflow-item to debug-session attachment lifecycle
  • active/inactive binding state toggles
  • diagnostic linkage management per workflow item
  • active-binding and diagnostic query helpers
• editor/tests/step562_test.cpp - 12 tests covering:
  • attach/detach lifecycle behavior
  • duplicate/invalid attach guards
  • active state toggle behavior
  • diagnostic add/duplicate/unknown behavior
  • active-binding filtering behavior
  • unknown diagnostic query behavior

Files modified:

• editor/CMakeLists.txt - step562_test target

Verification run:

• cmake -S editor -B editor/build-native - PASS
• cmake --build editor/build-native --target step562_test step561_test - PASS
• ./editor/build-native/step562_test - PASS (12/12)
• ./editor/build-native/step561_test - PASS (12/12) regression coverage

Architecture gate check:

• editor/src/WorkflowAwareDebugHooks.h within header-size limit (77 <= 600)
• editor/tests/step562_test.cpp within test-file size guidance (133 lines)
• Header-only architecture and naming conventions remain aligned with ARCHITECTURE.md